4 ms·
>> I've never seen anyone shop a desktop CPU by TDP, rather than by performance and price. Oh oh, me! Back in the day I bought a 65W CPU for a system that coul
by phkahler 6y ago
>> I've never seen anyone shop a desktop CPU by TDP, rather than by performance and price.
Oh oh, me! Back in the day I bought a 65W CPU for a system that could handle a 90W. I wanted quiet and figured that would keep fan noise down at a modest performance penalty. It should also last longer, being the same design but running cooler. I ran that from 2005 until a few years ago (it still run fine but is in storage).
Planning to continue this strategy. I suspect it's common among SFF enthusiasts.
- koolba 6y agoSFF?
- lostlogin 6y agoThe Intel Nuc and Mac mini are good examples of this - however the Nuc doesn’t have its psu inside, it’s a brick. Great for fixing failures, horrible in general as a built in psu is so much tidier.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoInternal PSU adds heat that is noisy or expensive to dissipate or is avoided by throttling performance.
- oconnor663 6y ago"small form factor" as far as I can tell
- sam_lowry_ 6y agoHm... My 2013 NUC in fanless Akasa enclosure runs 24/7 on a 6W CPU, I recently looked at the options, and the 2019 6W offering changes little in performance. Yes, memory got faster, but that's it. My passive-cooled desktop is also running a slightly trottled down 65W CPU. So yes, there are people who choose there hardware by TDP.
- francis-io 6y agoWhen looking for a CPU for a server that sits in my living room, I went down the thought process of getting a low tdp. I don't have a quote, but I seem to remember coming to the conclusion that tdp is the max temp threshold, not the consistent power draw. If you have a computer idling I believe you won't see a difference in temp between cpus, but you will have the performance when you need it. These days, a quiet, pwm fan with good thermal paste (and maybe some linux CPU throttling) more than achieves my needs for a "silent" pc 99% of the time. I would love to be told my above assumptions are wrong if they are.
- mlyle 6y agoYah-- one should look at performance within a given power envelope. Being able to dissipate more and then either end up with the fan running or the processor throttling back somewhat is good, IMO. The worst bit is, AMD and Intel define TDP differently-- neither is the maximum power the processor can draw-- though Intel is far more optimistic.
- mlyle 6y agoOn AMD, with Ryzen Master, you can set the TDP-envelope of the processor to what you want. Then the boost/frequency/voltage envelope it chooses to operate in under sustained load is different. IMO, shopping by performance/watt makes sense. Shopping by TDP doesn't. (Especially since there is no comparing the AMD and Intel TDP numbers as they're defined differently; neither is the maximum the processor can draw, and Intel significantly exceeds the specified TDP on normal workloads).
- vvanders 6y agoTDP matters a fair bit in SFF(Small Form Factor) PCs. For instance the 3700x is a fantastic little CPU since it has a 65W TDP but pretty solid performance. In a sandwich style case you're usually limited to low profile coolers like Noctua L9i/L9a since vertical height is pretty limited.
- phkahler 6y agoI'm running a 2400G in a Mellori-ITX. Another issue is sizing the power supply.
- mlyle 6y agoPerformance/watt matters. You can just set TDP to what you want with throttling choices. If you want a 45W TDP from the 3700X, you can just pop into Ryzen Master and ask for a 45W TDP. Boom, you're running in that envelope. I think shopping based on TDP is not the best, because it's not comparable between manufacturers and because it's something you can effectively "choose".