6 ms·
Yeah but objecting to every attempt to do good because, it doesn't go far enough! Is a recipe for doing nothing.
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
Yeah but objecting to every attempt to do good because, it doesn't go far enough! Is a recipe for doing nothing.
- klyrs 6y agoA card that leaks crude oil on every purchase would be more effective (if ridiculous from an engineering/logistical perspective) -- salves for consumer guilt aren't merely not doing enough, they're enabling the behavior that's doing the most harm.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThis credit card doesn't enable anything that wasn't already enabled. That argument is similar to 'what-about-ism' where irrelevant objections about another subject are injected as if they follow from the premise.
- gajomi 6y agoI can imagine a variant of this card that tries to tackle the point you bring up. Not all purchases are equal. Some of them have negative carbon footprints. The tree planting offsets the footprint for every purchase. These things are not easy to estimate exactly but since there are probably order of magnitude differences in carbon footprints for different products there should be useful information about the relative impact of a purchase to display to the consumer and to demonstrate the overall impact of the project.
- glaugh 6y agoThis feels very clever to me. I think people have very wrong senses of how bad various actions are for carbon footprint. I know folks who don’t eat meat for CO2 reasons (which I’m fine with) but fly across the US all the time—-sorry citation needed and happy to be corrected but I did this math once and it was roughly one year of meat = one (round?)trip. A side-benefit, in my view, is to show that actually offsetting carbon footprints isn’t terribly expensive (for people who have the disposable income to fly across the country), which I think counters the “We’d have to shut down the economy to stop global warming” misconception that I believe a lot of people have (citation also needed here, just personal experience) The Indulgences That Actually Work Card (in the sense of old Catholic indulgences), you could call it :)
- darawk 6y agoHow exactly would a card that leaks crude oil be more effective? Leaking crude oil is terrible for the environment. Planting trees is good for it.
- klyrs 6y agoIt's a thought experiment, analogous to Tullock's Spike [1]. The idea is to modify incentives, by putting environmental impact at the forefront of a consumer's mind, by making them actually handle the mess that the card produces (thereby making them reluctant to make purchases). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tullock%27s_spike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tullock%27s_spike
- darawk 6y agoWhy would that modify anyone's behavior? Consumption already has negative environmental externalities, and it doesn't seem to be causing much modification.
- klyrs 6y agoCrude oil is nasty, smelly stuff. You wouldn't wanna pull that out for anything but the absolute necessities, because it's gross and you'd need to clean up the gross thing.
- skeeter2020 6y agomaybe take a closer look at the thread; they're saying that purchasing "stuff" is the worst thing for the environment, so a card that leaks oil on purchases would discourage the act of doing so, and hence do more good tha encouraging purchases to plant trees.
- darawk 6y agoI read the thread. I get the idea, and it's nonsense. At scale, nobody cares about negative environmental externalities. If you added an extra one, behavior would not change in any scalable way. And it certainly wouldn't change in greater proportion to the damage it causes.
- nmca 6y ago"Enabling the behaviour that's doing the most harm" - I'm somewhat skeptical of environmental viewpoints that hinge on individual consumer guilt. As one random reference point, a single cruise-operating corporation was responsible for as much sulphur-based air pollution as all the cars in Europe in 2018/19 [0]. This is not so much to say that the card in question is a good idea, but more to point out that if you can salve some guilt and get people to vote green, you likely end up in a better position than if you maximise guilt. [0] https://www.ft.com/content/8bceef94-86cd-11e9-a028-86cea8523dc2 https://www.ft.com/content/8bceef94-86cd-11e9-a028-86cea8523...