16 ms·
Italy Will Rebuild Colosseum’s Floor
- zw123456 6y agoI was there a few years back and the thing is really run down, they should really rebuild the whole thing. And those Pyramids, those things are showing their age, right ? Don't even get me started on the Parthenon.
- kypro 6y agoI'm not sure if you're just joking around, or if this is a critic of restoring and rebuilding ancient monuments, but I know I used to be critical of restoring ancient monuments when I was younger. I thought the process of restoring these sites with new materials and even going so far as to reimagine what parts might have looked like thousands of years ago made the cultural experience somewhat less genuine because I knew a lot what I was seeing was added recently and probably didn't fully reflect what it would have looked like back when it originally built. But I've become a lot more accepting of the practise the more I've learnt. I don't know much about the Colosseum's history, but I'm sure over the many years it was in operation parts of it would have been being rebuilt and extended. Arguably in most cases the original monument was destroyed long before anybody in modern society touched it. I also started to realise that without a huge amount of restoration most of my favourite historical places would be almost unrecognisable. For example, if you look at Stone Henge before and after the restoration work you'll see what I mean. It's also true that without occasional upkeep and maintenance many of these monument wouldn't survive long given the number of visitors they attract each year. So if we need to do some amount of restoration anyway, why not also restore what was lost before modern times? I think so long as we are respectful and honour the character of what was built before we arrived it's probably fine to do our best to restore what we believe was once there. After all in most cases we're simply continuing what would be a long history of modifications and restorations. If it wasn't for those modifications and restorations we wouldn't be able to enjoy these sites in the first place so we probably have some duty to continue that work for future generations.
- zw123456 6y agoYou're not sure I was joking around? Really?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ip26 6y agoThe more I come to see history as a way of understanding the past instead of revering it, the more I want to experience faithful restorations. Imagine trying to understand the culture of NASCAR a thousand years from now by looking at some rusted out car frames in a case. The best part of floating museums like the USS Bowfin is actually standing there inside the cramped corridor, everything around you (at least appearing) ready for service... you can almost imagine you are there.
- shadowofneptune 6y agoWhat's most fascinating to me about the Colosseum is how it is a reminder of the post-apocalyptic city Rome was until recently. Parts of it were used for building material, such as in the Vatican, but it survived while the buildings nearby were completely destroyed over time. Even as recently as 250 years ago, parts of Rome had been reclaimed by nature. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cc/Giovanni_Paolo_Panini_-_View_of_the_Colosseum_-_Walters_372367.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cc/Giovanni...
- spideymans 6y agoInteresting. Why did people return to Rome?
- _petronius 6y agoPeople never really left Rome: describing it as "post-apocalyptic" is IMO a bit misleading (a real post-apocalyptic cultural transition looks a lot more like what happened to the north American native cultures in the aftermath of European contact than what happened on the Italian peninsula during the collapse of the western empire). That said, as things like coastlines and rivers changed, settlement patterns evolved, and the post-Imperial city of Rome changed size and political importance, parts of the city that had been inhabited in ancient times did empty out and came to be dominated by abandoned ruins, some of which were quarried for their marble, others left to be buried by sediment and detritus. I think a more apt comparison here is something like what happened to Detroit, but more so and over a longer period. A good overview using the example of the Forum can be found here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Forum#Medieval https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Forum#Medieval
- shadowofneptune 6y agoYeah, post-apocalyptic was misleading. Better said that after the chaos that Italy fell into in the 500s, the cities were depopulated.
- 6y ago
- shadykiller 6y agoWould it be linoleum ? Get it ? Coleseum - Linoleum :)
- rasengan 6y agoI’m looking at pictures of the venue and wondering how it will only cost 10m to restore the floor? Secondly, if it’s so cheap relatively, why wasn’t it done earlier?
- mhb 6y agoThat's not what it will cost. It's not even designed yet. That's what the Italian government has pledged towards it.
- dmurray 6y agoEven if it's free (€10m does sound too cheap) it's always a tough question for conservators: is it better to restore an ancient building or artwork to what we think it used to look like, or to preserve it so that everything you see is authentic? There are arguments on both sides. We don't generally repaint Ancient Greek marble statues, for example.
- mam2 6y agoSince i'm a kid i've never understood what good there was to keep ruins, as opposed to rebuilding "in the spirit of". In the end that's what do a lot of movies and video games and it's a better experience than visting ruins. This may sound childish but I'm dead serious.
- joe_91 6y agoI've always thought the same! It would make history so much more relatable and generate more interest in ancient buildings. They wouldn't even have to do all of it, just one third would at least show us what we think it used to look like!
- crowf 6y agoFor one, look at how Sadam rebuilt Babylon. He literally rebuilt walls by putting new stone on top of the ruins. As expected, that caused permanent damage to the ruins. So what should have been done? Destroy the ruins and rebuild how it was?
- cambalache 6y agoAre they pre-selling tickets for the first show?
- irrational 6y agoWill they be giving out free bread to attendees at Colosseum shows?
- StavrosK 6y agoNo, just circus tickets.
- jxramos 6y ago> that both celebrated and embodied the grandeur of Rome. So what exactly put an end to these inhumane shows? Did the arena become destroyed in a fire or was sacked and plundered, or did the populace lose its taste for gore and grow a conscience or something in that direction? Or was it that these shows went on for the full life of the Roman Empire and yet no following generation and municipality picked it up again and or didn't know how to operate the thing when the empire fell.
- Kelamir 6y ago> So what exactly put an end to these inhumane shows? You might want to check out the Hardcore History podcast by Dan Carlin, episode "Painfotainment". It has some ideas as to why that happened.
- rendall 6y agoChristianity, essentially
- cblconfederate 6y ago> St. Ignatius, the first Christian who died in the Colosseum, chose to die for his religion in front of tens of thousands of people rather than escape persecution or die in a less public place. About 3000 Christian martyrs in all died in the Colosseum.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 6y agoper Wikipedia: Honorius issued a decree during his reign, prohibiting men from wearing trousers in Rome. The last known gladiatoral games took place during the reign of Honorius, who banned the practice in 399 and again in 404, reportedly due to the martyrdom of a Christian monk named Telemachus while he was protesting a gladiator fight. (Which was pretty much at the end of the Roman Empire and the city was sacked a few years later.)
- baron816 6y ago> “The arena will be used for high culture, meaning concerts or theater,” Russo adds, “but no gladiator shows.” That’s a shame. Simulated gladiator shows would be a HUGE draw. Right now, the Colosseum isn’t much to look at, just a bunch of rubble. But imagine if they had actors recreate some of the battles they had there. Maybe throw in some holographic lions. Every young boy around the world would be demanding to visit Rome. I would argue the recreated Globe Theater in London is a better tourist attraction than the Colosseum, on account of it being a more immersive experience.
- saberdancer 6y agoI have to ask what is impressive to you if you call Colosseum "just a bunch of rubble".
- ThalesX 6y agoI was recently thinking about this as they built a state of the art office building nearby. It has around 15 floors, looks amazing, it appears well built based on what I could tell. It’s going to house hundreds if not thousands of humans, will be perfectly equipped to handle climatization, waste disposal, cleanliness. This is an amazing feat, and one that I personally did not really give proper thought. Basically what I’m arguing is that any modern office building is so much more impressive than the colliseum was, maybe even at inception. More specifically, to answer your question directed at OP, I’m hard pressed not to find anything modern that’s less impressive than the Colosseum. I’m interested in what you find so special about the bunch of rubble that warrants lack of intervention? Edit: really I had no idea this would bring me to negative points. Would love someone explaining what I’m missing in these downvotes.
- echan00 6y agoI love the history. But sometimes it really feels like that's what Italy is all about: let's spend money on the past for more tourist money.
- hutzlibu 6y agoHave you been to italy? Because even though tourism is important, I never had this impression.
- mynegation 6y agoI love technology. But sometimes it really feels like that’s what Google is all about: let’s spend money on search for more advertisers’ money. Obviously it works for Italy and huge number of people so why not?
- thefz 6y agoItaly instead should promote even more of its cultural heritage like France does, as an example, and not less. It is really the most valued richness of our country. Investing in valorising the past does not mean crystallizing on it, it means learning from its lessons.
- bamboleo 6y agoWait till you hear about Egypt. Prices in Italy are balanced and not even that bad. The ticket to the colosseum is 16€ and includes the entire park nearby. 16€ for the main attraction in one of the most visited countries in the world is pretty reasonable.
- greatpatton 6y agoIt is also funny to note that many other roman arena and theater are still used today for shows. From concert to bull fighting.
- Thorrez 6y agoIn high school my track team once ran around the Circus Maximus for practice.
- duxup 6y agoI attended a concert at one in Orange: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Theatre_of_Orange https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Theatre_of_Orange I wondered if emperor Augustus could imagine his statue would overlook such an event centuries later.
- bamboleo 6y agoOne must note * across Europe. No bullfighting in Italy.
- greatpatton 6y agoAnd in Switzerland this is Swiss Cow fighting (combat de Reines)
- wdb 6y agoNote that's two cows fighting one other
- hertzrat 6y agoThe show “Alive” makes me think of colosseums sometimes. It is a reality show about surviving in the wild, except that they drop you in at the start of the fall where there is no food and the end of every season is a starvation and suffering fest. The most recent season there are mostly poor people, one formerly homeless, who are all so desperate for the money that they take medical or wildlife-related risks on a regular basis. In one season, a poor dad is hiding frost bitten toes so a he can try to win money for his kid etc. In several seasons somebody has requested emergency extraction because of cold or animals or other things and it took 6–12 hours to get help - imagine if it was really urgent. I used to really enjoy the show but reality tv is pushing the envelope here a bit too much. They aren’t slaves and are doing this by choice, but like I said, some are desperately poor
- extr 6y agoI just finished watching season 6 of Alone and at first found it to be an interesting watch, but as I saw more episodes (and the contestants had been out there longer), I saw more and more of what you're talking about here. And after I finished the show and looked it up online, I was surprised to see just how much of the narrative I had just watched was completely fabricated and morally repugnant. For those who aren't familiar, the premise is 10 people are shipped to a remote destination with the basics (sleeping bag, axe, cord, etc...) and whoever lasts the longest gets $500K ($0 if you lose, I presume). They are also given camera equipment and are responsible for filming themselves. They don't see anyone else while they're out there except a medical team for occasional check-ups. Season 6 took place in northern Canada in near arctic conditions, starting in late fall and continuing through winter. (Spoilers) * The skill gap between best/worst contestants is portrayed as minimal. In reality, some contestants came in with years of lived experience thriving in the exact environment of the show (like the victor, who had spent years living in Siberia with people native to the region), or are literally paid professionals (like the army survival instructor, who tapped out because he was so successfully surviving he was bored, and didn't need the money), while others come from difficult backgrounds and have picked up wilderness skills only as a hobby or by necessity. When you find out just how large the skill gap was, and how some of these contestants basically never had a chance, it feels completely exploitive and effectively rigged. * Contestants give "camera confessions" in classic reality TV style, but these take a very dark turn as the show progresses. Going from "Excited to overcome the mental challenge of isolation", to starving, choking through tears "If I can hang on just a few more days I might be able to win the prize money for my family and give them the life I never had" in just a few episodes. If people are out there doing this for pride or because they enjoy the experience, so be it, but it's another thing entirely to dangle a large monetary prize in front of them. It just feels really sick to be watching people who are incredibly vulnerable and literally dying open up about their traumas and making it very clear they are only sticking it out for the cash. Begging to be allowed to stay when they are clearly underweight and at risk for cardiac issues. * The final episode makes it seem like the 2 remaining contestants are both just hanging by a thread, a literal starvation contest, which would be sad enough. But if you do some research afterward, you find out that while the 2nd place contestant had lost a dangerous amount of weight and was eating rabbit entrails, the winner had 100s of lbs of food stored (including moose and plenty of fish) and had not lost any weight. Hell, the last (gigantic) fish he caught they apparently brought back and used to feed the production camp. * All this said, the winner of Season 6, Jordan Jonas, is a very interesting (and apparently humble, good natured) guy, and I have enjoyed reading his commentary on the show on reddit and his blog. The show portrays him as lucky in some respects, probably to make him seem more like the other contestants, but he was in fact using a great deal of very specific techniques and knowledge, like how to build an structurally sound/ideal shelter, track/bait/hunt large game, ice fish, or build structures to keep stored food away from other predators. He himself admits the show obviously created a false narrative around his chances to win.
- coldtea 6y ago>to Its Gladiator-Era Glory Or "infamy". Between gladiator and slave fights to death, executions, and martyrs, it's not more glorious than a concentration camp would be...
- hankchinaski 6y agosupposedly Glory is intended as the magnificence that originally had for people at the time
- ericmay 6y agoWe tend to have different standards for the ancients. For better or worse. Look at structures such as the Great Wall of China, which according to Wikipedia[1] estimates say hundreds of thousands, up to a million perished during the construction. I’ve never been, but I doubt there is a lot of “wow we were so awful for building this” going on in the tourists centers. Maybe I’m wrong. Potentially the Cultural Revolution had that impact. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Wall_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Wall_of_China
- csomar 6y agoA wall is a really different thing. I guess China (at that time) did the math that the wall construction was going to cost a million life; but a wall was going to save them all from the enemy. So it made sense and actually saved lives.
- retrac 6y agoIn reality, when the enemy finally did cross the wall (multiple times), they just killed the elites, moved into their palaces, and then took over the ever-so-burdensome task of administering the canals... and collecting the taxes.
- jonny_eh 6y agoMore: http://blog.tutorming.com/expats/was-the-great-wall-china-effective-did-it-work http://blog.tutorming.com/expats/was-the-great-wall-china-ef...