3 ms·
Chrome extensions are an interesting study in trust. Even with their push for manifest v3, you can still run arbitrary JS on any url. Which, of course, allows a
by tyingq 6y ago
Chrome extensions are an interesting study in trust. Even with their push for manifest v3, you can still run arbitrary JS on any url. Which, of course, allows arbitrary spying and manipulation.
If they hobble that, though, a large portion of extensions become useless. I don't personally see any real middle ground. It's either a credible risk, or too complicated for practical use. The way manifest v3 hobbles practically required things like heuristics is a good example.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoI've had an extension which I downloaded for automatic tab reloading on chrome insert porn ads into YouTube, I think the extension was removed after reporting but considering Google does take payment for publishing extensions (Unlike Mozilla) and puts them through review; Why not do it right?
- EdwardDiego 6y agoOne of our testers had that addon installed, same issue with porn ads.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoInteresting, I remember it being taken down immediately after my complaint it would have been really bad if it had resurfaced.
- corytheboyd 6y agoI know it would break many extensions but I am of the opinion the architecture is all wrong. There instead should be clear APIs for some access to page content (for example, right-click context menus, tab control without content access, etc). The idea will probably be met with opposition because I didn’t explain it well enough, but maybe someone will get the idea hah. I’ve worked on large chrome extensions that heavily rely on hacking UI on top of page content and it’s truly awful. Everything you do feels liked it will break at the setup of a feather, because it does. Sure, there are some ways of making that LESS painful, but at the end of the day it will always be dirty hacks.