3 ms·
> What is interesting is the degree to which the Five Factor Model is insulated from falsification. It makes no causal predictions; others may make predictions
by roenxi 6y ago
> What is interesting is the degree to which the Five Factor Model is insulated from falsification. It makes no causal predictions; others may make predictions about correlations, and these may replicate, or not.
I remember struggling with feelings I would describe similarly when being taught how to fit an ARMA model to the stock market. Professor was very proud of himself and I was baffled about why he'd thought he'd done something. Eventually I decided maybe such models serve a function in academics very similar to a compression algorithm. The end goal is simply to be able to describe the data without having to present the data line by line - nothing more. No predictive or support in decision making is implied.
The Big 5 model looks like it is a lot better than nothing. "Do you normally feel good?" and "Do you normally feel joyful?" are different questions, but determining when they are practically different requires a deep mastery of the language.
Mr. Banana makes some good criticisms and the model will probably be abused to justify some stupid stuff out in the wild as many things in psychology are. But for academic sense, being replicable is all the model needs to do unless someone comes up with something clearly better.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vlovich123 6y agoWhat I took away from that analysis is that the entire field is self correlated (good) but lacking any underlying falsifiable theory (bad) or any ability to predict anything (bad). Repeatability, falsifiability, and predictability are the three requirements for any science. Remove one or more and it’s no longer science regardless of how much you want to believe it’s providing useful results. The history of science is littered with many such approaches. It could be the big five could eventually find better theoretical footing. My observation of the social sciences is less keen on this outcome. They perennially fail to accomplish it and thus move to “greener” pastures in terms of their financial incentives. For an example, consider the case where the study authors had a hypothesis that three of the five traits would predict something, only 2 did and they decided this was a success. Meanwhile astrophysics is arguing about potential sources of errors when results are off by 0.001%. Obviously different fields but the social sciences lack of establishing a solid quantifiable footing is non-ironically dismissed as “humans are difficult” rather than acknowledging that the basic science that’s attempted to be done is flawed and will never yield scientific results with the course it’s on.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThe fundamental problem with social "science" is that it's trying to predict human behavior, but human behavior is uncomputable. Literally. If you publish a study that says humans will do something, the humans will read your study, take it into account, and then do something different. That's the halting problem, game over.
- mjburgess 6y agoThis seems equivalent to the insight that a machine cannot be a programmer, ie., a system which cannot frame open problems cannot design systems which solve closed problems. NB. open here meaning aprox. "a problem class which is framed as a class by the solver"; closed meaning, "one of a class of pre-solved problems". Since humans are extreme open-problem framers, their framing strategies are themselves updated adaptively (by the environment) -- which cannot be reduced to any class of closed problems. Since (social) science does not have a theory of open-framing (ie., intelligence & problem solving proper) each description can only be a closed-solution description of a particular behaviour -- which then becomes invalidated when we reframe (eg., via reading the journal article). Your claim, re the haulting problem, suggests that there -- in some sense -- can never be a computable theory of open framing (, this seems highly plausible to me). In which case psychology is broadly impossible. However things like anger, family, etc. do exist. Psychology as a science of behaviour may be impossible; but there is a science of deterministic forces of human behaviour.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- quotemstr 6y agoOf course human behavior is computable, at least in aggregate. How do you think marketing works? The mind is a computer and there's nothing special about it.
- coldtea 6y agoThere's a lot of thing special about it, whether it's a computer or not. For one, it's a whole different architecture. Second, it's several orders of magnitude more complex. Third, it changes based on all kind of strange inputs, not just conditions in the program and some IO (e.g. changes in chemicals in the body). Even the substructure where the "program" runs changes properties (like a CPU changing material properties mid-execution). Fourth, the "program" is self-modifying constantly, as opposed to a static program or different reprogrammings of an FPGI. Fifth, there's no manual or clear schematics.