I agree with the sentiment, but I don't feel these are mutually exclusive methods. The techniques used by the developer in this case could easily be genericized

I agree with the sentiment, but I don't feel these are mutually exclusive methods. The techniques used by the developer in this case could easily be genericized and shared out as a useful framework for those who end up in this position. That's a big deal, even if it is a short-term benefit while longer-term solutions are designed and implemented.