4 ms·
No matter what Snowden uncovered, people who believe the CIA is controlling their thoughts with orbital lasers are wrong, even when they cite Snowden or MKULTRA
by krapp 6y ago
No matter what Snowden uncovered, people who believe the CIA is controlling their thoughts with orbital lasers are wrong, even when they cite Snowden or MKULTRA as "proof." Adopting a worldview that accepts every claim, however absurd, as equally valid to all others is foolish. The world isn't flat, nor hollow. COVID isn't part of a New World Order plot to harvest your adrenochrome, we did on the moon, Hillary Clinton doesn't bathe in the blood of child sex slaves to maintain her human form, Sandy Hook was not a false flag, there are no FEMA death camps, no aliens at Area 51, HAARP doesn't control the weather, CERN didn't hack the Matrix, "cultural marxism" doesn't really exist, and neither does the "Deep State."
You can accept that the world is more complex than you understand, and that conspiracies exist, while still having a standard for obvious bullshit. Or at the very least, while being dubious of extraordinary claims presented without extraordinary proof.
- lend000 6y agoOf course, no one suggests that you accept every claim, but instead that you truly evaluate them, especially those with compelling arguments and evidence. Most people struggle to distinguish between ridiculous and taboo. There is a difference. Your reaction is the reaction I described -- it sounds like you have some work to do on being more open-minded. Being more open minded has helped me across many facets of my life, and I still have plenty of room for improvement. I highly recommend it.
- bad_extension 6y agoWhich of the mentioned claims do you think need more open-mindness?
- bondarchuk 6y agoThere is a kernel of truth to almost all of them, and what's concerning is when the most extreme bullshit is used to discredit this kernel of truth (and guess who benefits from this..). I think the cool kids call it "motte and bailey" nowadays. Most obviously, although indeed "Hillary Clinton doesn't bathe in the blood of child sex slaves to maintain her human form", there is now conclusive evidence of child sex slavery in the highest echelons of society.
- lend000 6y agoThis: it's transparent and embarrassing when someone uses hyperbole to misrepresent and discredit someone else's opinion. Yet it's one of the most common forms of "debate" on the internet. I've found it's probably a futile exercise trying to have a productive discussion with someone who is set in their ways online. I have had much more success in person, because there is more mutual respect, which breeds open-mindedness, even when it challenges a worldview. Disclaimer: I haven't personally seen any compelling arguments for any of the conspiracies he listed save one, though I doubt anyone would phrase their opinions the way the original poster did.
- notional 6y agoThere's no time for nuance in online discussions. I think it's just the nature of online discussions. You pop in and out of them scrolling down the links on the front page of this site, or even less time for attention when scrolling twitter posts. Memes are an evolution of this. Shorter and shorter methods of conveying thought and expressions. It's like bumper sticker conversations everywhere
- krapp 6y agoThe "kernel of truth" isn't the problem - of course sex slavery exists in the highest echelons of society, that's always been the case. The extreme bullshit that leads from there to QAnon is the problem. That the former exists doesn't mean the latter serves some kind of useful purpose or that they're at least half-right. In fact, QAnon does more harm than good to the legitimate causes fighting child abuse and exploitation. Yet here I am being attacked and called closed-minded for even pointing things like this out.
- lend000 6y agoIt's the tone, hyperbole, and dishonesty that is earning you ire. You are arguing against a point no one made to claim something obvious that goes without saying on a place like HN, and using hyperbole to make your imagined opponents seem ridiculous.
- pfisch 6y agoI don't know why you're getting downvoted. It is deeply concerning that there isn't a general consensus that you are correct. It makes me think the great filter theory is true and we are going to destroy ourselves because a very significant number of people are incapable of basic reasoning, and the number seems to be growing...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]