3 ms·
Maybe I need to emphasize the original comment’s #3? > Therefore X and anything that even kind of resembles X is no longer an acceptable solution for Y.
by eyelidlessness 6y ago
Maybe I need to emphasize the original comment’s #3?
> Therefore X and anything that even kind of resembles X is no longer an acceptable solution for Y.
- giantg2 6y agoIf you have evidence to support that, it's a valid conclusion. Basically, you seem to be arguing that that conclusion is always wrong. I'm saying it could be right depending on the evidence supporting or opposing it. (ie there's no evidence that number 3 means what you say it means)
- eyelidlessness 6y agoI’m not saying the conclusion is definitely wrong, I’m saying it’s unreasonable to assume it’s correct. What I’m saying is that the premise in the syllogism you replied to is that, in the case it applies to, the conclusion is suspect due to the errors that led to it. Empiricism doesn’t stop at falsification, it also involves reconsidering assumptions and trying to identify and eliminate complicating factors.