9 ms·
Meals based on vegetable protein sources (beans and peas) are more satiating (2016)
- Melting_Harps 6y agoCan anyone provide a scihub link, I'd really like to read this as a friend and I had a through discussion about this very topic. Thanks!
- nairboon 6y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5073301/pdf/FNR-60-32634.pdf https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5073301/pdf/FNR...
- creamynebula 6y agohttps://sci-hub.se/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27765144/ https://sci-hub.se/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27765144/
- jtdev 6y agoBeing satiated <> being properly nourished.
- xmaaayyy 6y agoAnd you get just as much if not more nutrients from plant based meals?
- jtdev 6y agoPlant based diets are well known to be deficient in numerous essential nutrients.
- bitexploder 6y agoMostly amino acids. There are simple rules to follow to ensure you get complete nutrition and amino acid profiles. Otherwise what nutrients are you really missing?
- jtdev 6y agoJust things like Choline, but feel free to starve your brain (literally and figuratively) if you really want to: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/08/190829184143.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/08/190829184143.h...
- KittenInABox 6y agoThat link doesn't really have anything to do with whether or not vegan/vegetarian diets are missing choline. It's that the UK nutritional chart doesn't track choline at all. It has nothing to do with diet. I was super confused at how this paper had anything to do with the conversation except to say choline exists and is important. Afterwards I googled and choline isn't exclusive to meat sources so I'm still confused what vegetarian/vegan diets and choline deficiency have to do with each other- very common vegan/vegetarian foods are high in choline like brocoli, peas, chickpeas, various legumes, etc. Could you cite studies that correlate vegetarian/vegan diets with deficiencies in nutrition?
- jtdev 6y agoFrom the linked article: “The primary sources of dietary choline are found in beef, eggs, dairy products, fish, and chicken, with much lower levels found in nuts, beans, and cruciferous vegetables, such as broccoli. In 1998, recognising the importance of choline, the US Institute of Medicine recommended minimum daily intakes. These range from 425 mg/day for women to 550 mg/day for men, and 450 mg/day and 550 mg/day for pregnant and breastfeeding women, respectively, because of the critical role the nutrient has in fetal development. In 2016, the European Food Safety Authority published similar daily requirements. ... ‘This is....concerning given that current trends appear to be towards meat reduction and plant-based diets," says Dr Derbyshire.’” Is something unclear about this?
- KittenInABox 6y agoSorry, most of the article appeared to be about that UK isn't releasing daily choline requirements so I was a little confused. It also doesn't say whether or not there's actual evidence that choline deficiency due to a vegetarian diet exists, much less is linked to something?
- La1n 6y agoThe average US diet is deficient in numerous essential nutrients. You can eat healthy on a plant based diet or omni diet, but just adding or removing animal products is still not going to make an unhealthy diet healthy.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThe majority of your comments on HN are downvoted because they are all one-liner negative quips. Is there a reason you take your anger out on HN? Have you considered the zen of a plant-based diet?
- solinent 6y agoI think it's related to the fermentation going on in your stomach. I'm not sure if it's the best way to become satiated. I personally find saturated fats to be much more satiating, I can go without food for a full day without feeling hungry if I eat enough.
- fbelzile 6y agoI also agree with fats being the most satiating for me. For a second, I missed the part where they controlled for it, but it's there: > The meals (all 3.5 MJ, 28 energy-% (E%) fat)...
- xmaaayyy 6y agoThen add some high fat foods to the veggie meals. Nuts, avocado, etc are all super nutritious and fatty.
- papandada 6y agoFermentation happens in the gut where all the bacteria is, right? Does fullness in the gut translate to feeling full?
- solinent 6y agoI should have said gut--I've been calling my gut my stomach for too long and have had difficulty stopping that habit. However, I don't think we really know where satiety comes from yet, that's why we have all of this research on the topic still. There are a few different theories, but I wouldn't call them proven. It may not be a sensation related to some measure of the volume of matter in your gut. I think it's also related to gut microfauna such as lactobacilla, and appetite is definitely related to the brain as well through the gut, so it probably gets pretty complicated and possibly is very individualized. I'm no expert, but I do read a lot about these topics.
- tyleo 6y agoThis is interesting and clashes with my personal experience. I eat two vegetarian meals a day which usually include beans, eggs, or oats. In my experience meat is considerably more satiating than meals with beans or eggs but less satiating than the meals with oats.
- nmfisher 6y agoYeah, this clashes with my experience too. I experimented with vegetarian meals a few months back and found I could eat literally 1kg+ of cooked lentils/beans/etc and still feel hungry. <500g of chicken breast (plus vegetables), on the other hand, would see me through.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> Yeah, this clashes with my experience too. Ultimately, as with all biological systems, its hard to make absolute assertions of the most optimal diet (the sample size in this trial is n=43 which is pretty small when you consider the variation in peoples gut biomes due to genetics and lifestyle) be it full carnivore to the strictest form of veganism, there will always be people who can perform on these diets. But most people fall within the averages, and thus personal experimentation is required to adjust and refine for one's own use. I worked at a highly acclaimed Vegan and Vegetarian farm to table, and for the life of me I couldn't even get my body to adjust to eating seitan or tempeh as a main source of protein. I'd eat tons of salads with qunioa and legumes and still feel fatigued all day and I drank tons of kombucha to try and make the most use of the additional fiber. Ultimately I gave up after 2 weeks and just ended up bringing in my own grass fed beef and cooking it in tallow or goose fat after service with all the veg sauted in the pan as sides and felt way better. I had a horrible mental fog and dull headache the entire time, my body felt sluggish and I felt like I was not sleeping well for those 2 weeks and I don't think I'd cope with that for very long as I have a hard time keeping my weight up as it is. After spending the better part of decade on matters related to diet and longer if I include self experimentation, I've come to realize its far more Art than it is Science and that one shoe does not and cannot fit all. Obviously we should reduce our meat consumption in the West, and opt for smaller, organic and grass fed cuts of better quality meat cooked in good animal fats in our diet but phasing it out entirely seems like an unobtainable panacea to me at best, and a horrible existence for most like myself. But Life is too short to suffer through more than one bad meal a month, and I work to damn hard to not enjoy myself for the 1 meal I eat a day now. Which is often a 4:1 ratio of Veg/Carb to meat. Context: I grew up eating tofu as a kid, so I was no stranger to eating soy based protein but it was usually as a side dish or a garnish in a soup rather than meal itself.
- z5h 6y agoThe high protein vegetable meal has 4 times the fibre as the high protein meat meal. The next recommended article is Protein from Meat or Vegetable Sources in Meals Matched for Fiber Content has Similar Effects on Subjective Appetite Sensations and Energy Intake-A Randomized Acute Cross-Over Meal Test Study https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29337861/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29337861/
- SergeAx 6y agoComments like this is why I visit HN in the first place. Thanks!
- h0l0cube 6y agoThis matches my own observations where swapping a pure 'bran' cereal for any other breakfast meal allows me to feel fuller while eating less. Also, subbing TVP for mince is also a way of increasing fibre and protein at the same time. After hydration TVP is almost double protein by weight compared to store-bought mince (at least where I shop), and it also has a good dose of fibre content, and no fat. Once again, I went 50/50 on this and I could eat less and feel fuller, and I argue it tasted better because the dish wasn't as oily.
- dkjaudyeqooe 6y agoIf only TVP were easy to buy worldwide. I suspect you're in the US where I've seen it offered cheaply in bulk. Elsewhere it seems unobtanium.
- howlin 6y agoTry a grocery that carries Taiwanese (most asian grocers) or Mexican food. These places usually have it for sale cheap.
- h0l0cube 6y agoYou can find it in health food shops or buy in bulk online. It keeps for ages, so it doesn't hurt to have extra. I'm currently in Australia. My local grocer has started selling it, though it's pricier than from other sources.
- annoyingnoob 6y agoI like my beans with meat.
- joegahona 6y agoThis is my experience too, though I eat a lot of starch in the form of potatoes and rice as well.
- Proven 6y agoThey probably taste like crap tho
- Dowwie 6y agoTempeh is a great source of protein and easy enough for many people to make at home. You can add it as a source of protein to a wide range of dishes with surprising results. It's even good when cubed and added to spaghetti marinara as a meatball substitute.
- xmaaayyy 6y agoWarning to all; if this is your first time eating something soy based, I’d go for tofu or TVP before tempeh. Tempeh is fermented so it can be a bit strong, where tofu and TVP are still high in protein but take on other flavours more easily.
- Dowwie 6y agoThat's like, your opinion-- xmaaaayyy. :) Tempeh isn't that bold a move. It depends on how it's made, really. Maybe the stuff you've had is strong. We quality control here by making it from scratch.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoSlice it kind of thin, marinate in soy sauce, maple syrup and a dash of smoked paprika for a couple of hours (at least). Bake it for 20 minutes in the oven. Tasty.
- estaseuropano 6y agoTofu slices soaked in a few spoons of soy sauce and a few drops of liquid smoke, then fried in olive oil until crunchy. Delicious bacon that my non-veggie family all prefer over real bacon.
- reddotX 6y agowhy not both? beans + meat
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dukeofdoom 6y agoVegan protein powder tastes pretty great. I use a Costco brand. You can add it to almost any meal. If you are lifting weights, its almost impossible to get enough vegan sources of protein to meet the 1g / 1 lb of body weight that is usually recommended. Actually, if anyone knows how to put together 150g+ protein /day on a vegan diet in under 2100 calories I would be interested. I would switch over at least a few of my days to vegan.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> 1g / 1 lb Why would you mix units like this?!
- dukeofdoom 6y agoThis is the standard way this is discussed. Most people aim for 1 gram of protein per 1 lb of body weight.
- chrisseaton 6y agoYeah but I mean why mix imperial and metric units in the same situation? Seems mind-bending and error-prone.
- rco8786 6y agoBecause (at least in the US) we weigh ourselves in pounds and weigh protein by the gram. That’s kinda of the long and the short of it lol.
- swsieber 6y agoSomebody made a humorous flowchart about using imperial vs metric: https://preview.redd.it/k1brffgbngk31.png?width=681&format=png&auto=webp&s=8cc428c345b687a3f79d8e481561781f38d0630e https://preview.redd.it/k1brffgbngk31.png?width=681&format=p... There a lot of situations I can imagine from that flowchart where you mix systes in a single sentence.
- dirtyid 6y agoMore bloat from carb + water retention as well. Comfort of pants varied between low/high carb days. Sometimes feeling full is just feeling fat.
- k_sze 6y agoThis is an interesting subject. I wish I knew and understood more, so I can eat less meat and eat more healthily. My problem is that I’m Chinese and I live in Hong Kong. I’ve lived many years in Montréal before but I never picked up any “Western” culinary knowledge. Meanwhile, I get the impression that a lot of these nutritional studies seem to be based on Western diet, and there are ingredients that we Chinese are not familiar with (e.g. I can’t name at least half of the beans and vegetables that go into a salad at Passion by Gérard Dubois), let alone know where to buy without getting ripped off. Things that one would find completely ordinary and affordable in US/Canada can be ridiculously expensive and/or hard to find in Hong Kong. If anybody has recommendations (books, YouTube channels, links, etc.) for someone living in East Asia to replicate similarly satiating, nutritious, and appealing meals, that would be awesome
- KittenInABox 6y agoMy brother who is east asian and is vegetarian follows anything that goes along with buddhist eating styles (except he also declines fish).
- nicoty 6y agoIt isn't exactly East Asian, but have you tried Indian food? A lot of it is plant-based since many Indians are vegetarian, and being an Asian cuisine, many of the ingredients used are also similar/the same to those found in other Asian cuisines. This YouTube channel might be of some use - https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCDbZvuDA_tZ6XP5wKKFuemQ https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCDbZvuDA_tZ6XP5wKKFuemQ. If you're dead set on only cooking up East Asian style food though, maybe try this channel instead - https://m.youtube.com/user/marystestkitchen https://m.youtube.com/user/marystestkitchen.
- colsandurz 6y agoCan anyone link to some recipes that feature plant based protein? Here's a few my wife and I really like: https://food52.com/recipes/30932-heidi-swanson-s-pan-fried-giant-white-beans-with-kale https://food52.com/recipes/30932-heidi-swanson-s-pan-fried-g... https://www.rickbayless.com/recipe/cowboy-beans/ https://www.rickbayless.com/recipe/cowboy-beans/ https://www.ranchogordo.com/blogs/recipes/spicy-baked-royal-corona-beans https://www.ranchogordo.com/blogs/recipes/spicy-baked-royal-...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bagacrap 6y agoThis seems entirely expected and in line with previous research and understanding of nutrition because the animal protein meals had lower fiber. A less sensationalist way to phrase this would be "high fiber meals are more satiating when controlling for macronutrient content."
- rognjen 6y agoAnecdotally, my experience is that this is true however I get hungry earlier. So the net result is null.
- t0mmel 6y agoDecreasing the amount of meat you eat is really not that hard, and it’s SO easy to replace it with some nice chunky blanched vegetables and a more beans and some more plant based fats. This whole pandemic emphasised healthy eating in our family, and not only are we eating more healthy food, but household is happier, more balanced and there’s just a way better spirit in the house now. And cutting back on meat was the first step to realising that it’s not really hard to do.