4 ms·
George Lucas post 1976 is a mediocre director, and a worse writer. Even before 1976 he wasn't that great either - American Graffiti is a forgetable coming of ag
by coldtea 6y ago
George Lucas post 1976 is a mediocre director, and a worse writer. Even before 1976 he wasn't that great either - American Graffiti is a forgetable coming of age movie. If it wasn't made by Lucas of later 'Star Wars' fame nobody would remember it today.
What he is actually known for is being great at worldbuilding once, with Star Wars (beginner's luck?). Middle age took that ability away though after the eighties, like a punk band trying to be relevant in their 40s: only for hardcore fans.
And I say it regretably. I'd too wanted a great Star Wars 1, 2, and 3. That said, most modern S.W. movies are also crap. The J.A. ones were so much a blatant copy of the original story plots as to be useless, whereas Han Solo bordered on camp. Rogue One was somewhat decent though, and I hear good things about the Mandalorean...
Spielberg on the other hand is a true master...
- paul_f 6y agoRegarding American Graffiti, it was a huge hit, before anyone heard of Star Wars. It was the number 3 grossing film of 1973 after The Sting and The Exorcist. It made AFI's list of the top 100 movies.
- coldtea 6y agoIt was a hit (for it's money) but there are tons of hits (with similar acclaim) from back then that are forgotten today.
- ghaff 6y agoTo be fair, how many non-film buffs know a lot of films from the early 70s today? Star Wars is an exception mostly because it became such a franchise.
- ghaff 6y agoIt would almost certainly be on my Top 100 list as well. I think it stands up pretty well. Those other two are pretty classic too--although I'm not really a horror film fan. (That said, I could see people not being able to identify with the where/when the movie was set. I certainly wasn't part of that either but I still really enjoyed it.) But, yeah, the films Lucas directed go way downhill after American Graffiti and Star Wars.
- lioeters 6y agoFor those (like me) who were unaware of "AFI's list of the top 100 movies": > American Film Institute's list of the 100 Greatest Movies, selected by AFI's blue-ribbon panel of more than 1,500 leaders of the American movie community https://www.afi.com/afis-100-years-100-movies/ https://www.afi.com/afis-100-years-100-movies/
- Taylor_OD 6y agoIt is incredible to me that GL could best be celebrated as a world builder yet the Star Wars cannon might be the smallest universe out of any mainstream film series. Part of the reason I lost interest is that they refuse to create something new in the SW universe and constantly just microwave and serve the leftovers of the old movies.
- coldtea 6y agoI don't think the size of the universe matters. Marvel has a huge universe but it's mostly derivate, trite, n-th repeatitions of same-old under different names and guises. Star Wars had a cultural significance in a way that Marvel movies never had (but Marvel comics, in their heyday, did, albeit for a smaller niche). Plus, the Star Wars world was such a good fit for building upon, that it was expanded vastly by hundreds of comics, books, and so expanding "the canon". >and constantly just microwave and serve the leftovers of the old movies Funny coming from someone who enjoys Marvel.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoWait did I say I enjoy Marvel movies? If your defense of the Star Wars Universe is to belittle the Marvel Universe (Another "large" but tiny universe) I think you are grasping at straws. I don't enjoy Star Wars or Marvel movies. I only watch them with friends/family who really love them since they seem to be important to them.
- grafityeah 6y agoAmerican Graffiti (1973) is very enjoyable. I consider it a great movie. Great ensemble cast. Highly recommended.
- andi999 6y agoI read that in the Star Wars IV movie, the actors refused to read his lines and made up their own ones. Then later for episode one he was so famous nobody dared to refuse his wishes... result is known.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoDisagree with you about "American Graffiti". It would be remembered today if for no other reason for the actors that got a career-launch from it. Never mind the 1960's revivalism it kicked off. Writing-wise, a good chunk wasn't even written by Lucas.
- matt-attack 6y agoAnd if you dig into Star Wars you’ll find the it’s success is really a result of others. First edits were laughable until a new edit came aboard to give the movie its trademark style. I’d say SW movies were a success in spite of Lucas not because of Lucas. The prequels prove the point as those movies were 100% him and quite unwatchable IMO.
- goto11 6y agoThis is quite unfair to Lucas. Star Wars was a groundbreaking achievement at the time, and it was due to unique vision of Lucas. He should get credit for that, even if he later made some mediocre movies and angered some fans. I know Star Wars is said to have been "saved in the editing", but it is quite normal for movies going through many edits and to correct issues in postproduction. Many successful movies need re-shoots after scheduled shooting ends. How many reshoots did Lord of the Rings need? More fundamentally, the director does not just direct the actors, he direct all roles like editor, cinematographer, sound designer. If he select great people and get them to do their best work to realize his vision, it shows he is a good director. It doesn't mean that a successful result is "because of others". At least not any more for George Lucas than for say Orson Welles. Sure the prequels were underwhelming, but the newest trilogy was just as bad without the involvement of Lucas. This just shows how well the original trilogy was written - we don't really need to know the prehistory of Darth Vader or Han Solo and we don't need to see the characters return again. The original story arch was perfectly told and satisfyingly resolved.