4 ms·
It's fine to ask questions, but the whole 5G thing is missing a fundamental understanding of the physical world that's difficult to put into words. I'll give it
by jiggawatts 6y ago
It's fine to ask questions, but the whole 5G thing is missing a fundamental understanding of the physical world that's difficult to put into words. I'll give it a go:
Individual ignorance doesn't counter a century of established science. It's not a matter of authority, or lack of evidence, or insufficient testing. There's a real weight to certain fields now, where literally thousands of textbooks have been written on surprisingly narrow topics, because of an intense interest both theoretically and practically for industrial purposes.
It's not even a matter of laboratory experiments. Sure, we haven't done a zillion tests specifically with 5G. That simply doesn't matter. Some things are effectively field tested millions of times over through simple everyday activity. We know gravity doesn't turn on and off randomly because we would notice!
Even for subjects that our ordinary everyday experience doesn't cover, vast industrial experience does. Literally millions of workers do their work every day with chemicals, machines, and electronics. They know how they work! They depend on that knowledge being accurate!
There simply cannot be such a thing as our knowledge of electromagnetic waves being this fundamentally flawed in the same manner as we cannot possibly have misunderstood chemistry to the point that we missed an element in between oxygen and nitrogen.
I just did some random Googling and found stacks of complaints sent to governments demanding a lower maximum 5G power level. Here's one quote from a paper: "The extraordinary sensitivity of the VGCC voltage sensor to the forces of the EMFs tells us that the current safety guidelines allow us to be exposed to EMF levels that are something like 27.2 million times too high." [1]
According to that guy's theory we're all already screwed, because the background radiation in all frequency bands has been waaaaaay higher than that since the 1950s! [2]
All of that just doesn't matter though, because simple and well-established physics shows that for both 26 GHz and 60 GHz, the penetration depth is less than 0.5 mm into the skin[3], which means that at most the new 5G frequency bands could cause skin cancer.
That hasn't stopped bloggers breathlessly repeating bad science where researchers take samples of cells from internal tissues and nuke them with high power RF sourcers for weeks on end in order to "demonstrate" the potential harm from radiofrequency radiation.
PS: Sabine has an axe to grind and seems to be grandstanding an awful lot. Her videos are mostly pop-science and full of ads. She's not an authority on anything other than an extremely narrow field related to quantum gravity, and even there most physicists do not agree with her stance.
[1] https://www.radiationresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/EU-EMF2018-6-11US3.pdf https://www.radiationresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06...
[2] https://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lanplh/PIIS2542-5196(18)30221-3.pdf https://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lanplh/PIIS2542-5196...
[3] https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1503/1503.05944.pdf https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1503/1503.05944.pdf
- NiceWayToDoIT 6y agoRegarding Sabine, it seems if one cannot win an argument then discredit those that do not agree, is that it, is that the way? > Individual ignorance doesn't counter a century of established science. I bet that in 18th century, physicians were saying beside on a century of established science, we conclude that bloodletting is best cure for all illnesses. Why is so hard to accept that "we do not know"? Amazingly, at this point, there will be response, "but that is different", we know much more now? Do, we? Do, we really know? During this Covid-19 pandemic I just witnessed how much we really know, science was was changing opinions by the hour. If I could take a dollar for each of my developer in the team who said, don't worry that will work, I would have been a millionaire. Despite unite tests, test team, there is always something. So, I love when people tell me about physical world, which has few orders of magnitude of things that may go wrong, don't worry according established science... :) Should I just mention uranium glass? > penetration depth is less than 0.5 mm into the skin[3], which means that at most the new 5G frequency bands could cause skin cancer. That is not enough? Or risk is acceptable proceed to implement, we will have 7 billion test subjects, cost of progress? What if interferes vitamin D production, and then impacts all other issues connected with lack of vitamin D, like a depression, osteoporosis, weakened immune system? I am not saying it does any of those things but I am for asking questions, and I would like if science would address those with data, not dogmatic beliefs.
- bawolff 6y ago> Regarding Sabine, it seems if one cannot win an argument then discredit those that do not agree, is that it, is that the way? You were the one who brought up that she was a physicist, and appealed to her authority. Whether or not she is the right type of physicist for this subject matter seems quite relevant. Ultimately though, appeals to authority are always weak arguments. They are better than nothing, but fundamentally, experts are people - you can probably find at least one expert who holds whatever view you want. A single expert (even if it was in the right field) in the entire world agreeing with you doesn't exactly mean much. Its much better to concentrate on the arguments that the experts give. > During this Covid-19 pandemic I just witnessed how much we really know, science was was changing opinions by the hour It was a brand new virus. The media was often overstating the certainty of what scientists were saying. Most of the time scientists were saying - this is our best guess at the moment, but this is new so its just a guess, and the media reported that as - Scientists 100% sure that X is what you should do. > Should I just mention uranium glass? What about it. Its generally considered safe if made correctly. (That's honestly a weird example, because there is so many radiation based products in the early 1900's that were ridiculously bad ideas. Uranium glass is probably not one of them, even if I would definitely prefer not to have uranium in my kitchenware) > What if interferes vitamin D production, and then impacts all other issues connected with lack of vitamin D What if it causes dinosaurs to resurrect back to life, and velociraptors eat us? Without a theory as to how or why it might possibly effect that, you're basically shooting blind and you could say the same thing about anything. > Why is so hard to accept that "we do not know"? "We do not know" is not a single category. By some standards we do not know anything (perhaps excepting "cognito, ergo sum"). We don't know if the sun will rise tomorrow, if cause preceedes effect, whether or not we live in the matrix, etc. But just because we don't know anything for sure, doesn't mean we don't know some things more than others. I think fundamentally, we are talking past each other because you are arguing "we don't know", where I don't think that's the relevant question since that is always true. We obviously don't know for sure. The question is, do we know enough that use of the technology is reasonable. I think your argument would be more convincing if you set goalposts for what would be enough knowledge, in your mind, for you to consider 5g "safe" (And those goalposts be consistent, so that the other things you consider safe, already meet those standards).