3 ms·
> Yeah; but thats all so incremental. Better compiler error messages? Really? That makes the top 10 list from 25 years of work? Aren't good error messages very
by oblio 6y ago
> Yeah; but thats all so incremental. Better compiler error messages? Really? That makes the top 10 list from 25 years of work?
Aren't good error messages very hard to implement and also a _major_ productivity increase? They're also a boon to beginners.
Both are very important as the most powerful resource we have is people.
- josephg 6y agoSure; important and took a lot of work, but they’re still incremental improvements over what came before. I could name dozens of equally important improvements - typescript, css grids, llvm, http2, the M1 processor, WSL, C++ smart ptrs, io_uring, zfs, SeL4 and so on. This is all important work, but none of it makes you think of computing in a new way. Not like the web did, or Haskell, or the idea of a compiler & high level language, a preemptive kernel, or TCP/IP. These were all invented by people, and a lot of the people who invented them are still around. There are plenty of sibling ideas in the idea space. But for some reason computing cooled down and tectonic shifts of that scale don’t seem to happen anywhere near as frequently now. How long has it been since an interesting new OS appeared on the scene? Feels like a very long time. And even Haiku uses POSIX internally anyway.
- khooke 6y agoSide comment: most new developers tend to ignore/not read compile or runtime error messages and ask for help before even realizing the cause of the problem they're trying to fix is right there in front of them. Better error messages for 'beginners' has questionable benefits for developers just getting started, until they get to the point where they realize error messages are actually useful
- oblio 6y agoThere are two kinds of new developers: a) new developers in general (totally new to programming) b) developers new to this specific programming language I'd be curious what the percentages are, but my personal hunch is that for any specific language there are more in category b) than a). And for category b), those are definitely helped by error messages.