5 ms·
Democracy has a scaling problem. The further the voter is from the matter of the voting, the less informed the vote is. Voting for local changes or electing an
by nine_k 6y ago
Democracy has a scaling problem. The further the voter is from the matter of the voting, the less informed the vote is.
Voting for local changes or electing an official within your small village or a city precinct works well, because the voters both actually know what the matter is, and directly feel the consequences. This is how it works in the only directly democratic country I know, Switzerland.
OTOH voting for a national leader in a country with 100M population cannot enjoy the same effect. Very few people have any opinion about candidates based on more or less close interaction. Neatly all opinions are manufactured by the PR people hired by the candidates, publicity stunts, and the big media. Getting more useful information is hard. This is why elections tend to become a popularity contest and involve emotionally overloaded rooting not unlike on a stadium. This is not how you can make a balanced, rational choice which can keep a democracy running well.
- Noumenon72 6y agoMatthew Yglesias wrote on Substack last week that this has completely changed and is no longer true. Because local newspapers no longer exist, our news consumption has shifted to large, national stories. I know 1000 times more about Trump and AOC than any official in my city precinct. Even when we know a local candidate well and know they bring home the bacon to our district, we often vote based on the national implications of the partisan conflict instead. Yglesias closes by saying, "We need to adjust to a world where information dissemination is not limited by truck routes (this is a good thing!) and we are consequently better informed about bigger units rather than “closer” ones." He suggests that means consolidating levels of government and putting more power into accountable executives. https://www.slowboring.com/p/local-news https://www.slowboring.com/p/local-news
- nine_k 6y agoIf you know a politician only from media, no matter local or global, you have already lost. I mean knowing an official by knowing what decisions (s)he has made in your local vicinity, which affected you personally. Or knowing by being neighbors. That is, somehow directly.
- Noumenon72 6y agoThe average American knows 600 people. This isn't a workable standard for any but the tiniest towns. I also question whether there's much chance of learning who made decisions that affected me personally other than through the media. I lived in a 10,000 person town from 2000 to 2015 and I was completely in the dark about any layer of government except when the mayor got caught drunk driving.