3 ms·
> I wish more people thought like him. I don't, because instead of introspectively looking at why the world didn't turn out exactly like he wanted it, he blame
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
> I wish more people thought like him.
I don't, because instead of introspectively looking at why the world didn't turn out exactly like he wanted it, he blames others by dismissing their achievements as stagnation.
Those futuristic looking user interfaces never caught on because while they look good in movies they suck for actual productivity, even for non-technical users.
And when it comes to "non-programmer programming", just look at the success of tools like Zapier. I see tons of non-programmers using them to great success.
- erichanson 6y agoI wish more people thought like Zapier too. Their pipe flow designer thing is pretty star trek. The world is chock full of shit software that people have to use eight hours a day and absolutely hate. I mean, seriously, hate to the point of shaking and tears at the idiotic hoops they have to jump through all day long, every day, for years. Genuine mental health impact. They come home miserable and snap at their kids. Maybe he's channeling their frustration. And maybe we deserve it.
- networkimprov 6y agoThat's the widespread failure to apply insights from Human Factors and HCI research, much of which has been around for decades. A different problem than better programming paradigms.
- infinite8s 6y agoIs it really? Programming is just really low level HCI.
- osullivj 6y agoSounds like you're talking about corporate environments, where the people using the software aren't the same folk as those paying for it.
- carapace 6y agoGo back to the page, look at the right-hand sidebar under "Links", it has: About me Email me Subtext Click on "Subtext". Read up.
- asdff 6y agoWhy not, though? Programming itself is a layer of abstraction. Why did we invent this bespoke complicated and arbitrary syntax that can be explained succinctly with a comment in your native language, rather than just develop the computer to interpret commands in common native language syntax directly? I shouldn't have to remember that ls is list directory contents. I should be able to type all sorts of permutations of 'show me what stuff is here' in my language and not some bullshit syntax that someone came up with on a whim 50 years ago, if the computer was truly developed to be a tool for everyone. I'm not confident it's going to change for the better and democratize what computers can truly do, simulate and model. People who've already paid the cost of memorizing all the ins and outs of complicated computer syntax don't really care how much of a hill they've had to climb anymore now that they've learned enough to be familiar. Now you have this memorization lock in, where you've spent years and perhaps thousands with university learning some dense programming language and start building your tooling around what you've learned, and in the process you force the next generation to have to learn that syntax if you are to hire them, and so on and so forth. That's why we've been typing ls since the 80s and we will still be typing ls in 50 years. I'm sure the authors of ls would find that horrifying.
- kazinator 6y ago> just develop the computer to interpret commands in common native language syntax directly? We have that: e.g. Google Assistant. (If you don't mind needing an internet connection, and sending your voice to the cloud.) > I shouldn't have to remember that ls is list directory contents. Nobody's had to do that in 35+ years, except those of us who prefer that sort of thing. The rest click on some folder icon or something.
- asdff 6y agoGoogle Assistant et al do not do that. I can't ask Siri to show the contents of my directory. I can't ask Siri to run anything on the command line at all. These voice assistants just do a number of predefined functions, they don't offer 1:1 control of your device the same as traditional inputs. Yeah, that's true that most people use a GUI, but the point still stands. You have to remember these distinct workflows to do something readily explained in person. An old person might have to take a computer class because they want to send an email, whereas an intutively designed system would take that persons input, "email jake" and do all the behind the scenes stuff we do ourselves to compose emails for us. An ideal computer is a secretary that can do everything you can think of since you are both versed in the native language. Siri is not a perfect secretary, Siri is like an elevator man only able to press one of the couple dozen buttons on the wall for you.
- sriku 6y ago> And when it comes to "non-programmer programming", just look at the success of tools like Zapier. I see tons of non-programmers using them to great success. Or Excel for that matter.