5 ms·
> Also, the free market is extremely slow! The free market is the second fastest organisational method we have, beaten only by the military which can achieve s
by roenxi 6y ago
> Also, the free market is extremely slow!
The free market is the second fastest organisational method we have, beaten only by the military which can achieve specific operational goals extremely quickly. The free market is by far the fastest and most efficient force at sustained logistics.
As I recall it first group to have good Coronavirus testing
was the Koreans who let private industry do its thing [0]. The free market with government as another equal client would be faster than the government at distribution a vaccine.
[0] https://edition.cnn.com/2020/03/12/asia/coronavirus-south-korea-testing-intl-hnk/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2020/03/12/asia/coronavirus-south-ko...
- majormajor 6y agoThis is a pretty specific operational goal so why haven't we used our military? WTF are we spending so much money on them for if not for combating something that's caused hundreds of thousands of deaths?
- roenxi 6y ago> This is a pretty specific operational goal so why haven't we used our military? As in "fly over to Pakistan and assassinate bin Laden" sort of goals. Stuff that burns unreasonable amounts of resources to do something very specific very quickly. If something takes months to execute the market will be faster. "Get a vaccine to everyone who can afford it" is something that the market will be fastest at. It would be prudent to leave it alone to solve that problem. Government can go solve a different problem.
- majormajor 6y agoI disagree on the effectiveness of market solutions for fighting a year-long military campaign. No, it's not a single "assassinate bin Laden" mission, but it maps pretty well to a war where you have both tactical goals to achieve with logistical challenges AND overarching strategic goals. The market SUCKS at strategic goals. It's basically the opposite: you're giving up on strategic goals because you're in a situation where you don't think central planning can be as effective as competition. But military history shows us that central planning can be very effective for this sort of campaign, complete with elaborate supply chains and logistical accomplishments.
- roenxi 6y ago> I disagree on the effectiveness of market solutions for fighting a year-long military campaign. Markets are generally smart enough not to think killing large numbers of people and overthrowing governments is a good idea. If the US government was somehow replaced with a market the Middle East would likely be a more peaceful place. Markets generally find better ways of doing things - like financial incentives - than military intervention. I'm more than happy to admit defeat if you want to argue that markets are ineffective at subjugating exotic new lands. In terms of defence, I havn't looked in to it at all. I expect market based economies to beat command and control economies at war because they can better sustain an effort.
- geofft 6y agoEr, the US government is basically funded by (and lobbied by) market participants. The market has realized that killing large numbers of foreign people and overthrowing foreign governments is good for domestic economic growth, and therefore happily operates in the US. The US defense budget is huge, and in turn it's a huge portion of taxes on market participants, and they'd figure out a way to make it stop if they weren't getting their money's worth, precisely because markets are good at solving problems and not wasting money. The Swiss have their bank accounts, yes. You could convincingly argue that people who are happy to accept low gains as a tradeoff for low risk are interested in avoiding war. But the world's largest markets are in the US. And before they were in the US, they were in the capital of the British Empire. Markets are very good at solving the sort of problems they solve. But be careful about extrapolating that into "Markets are very good." (Also, don't forget about the British East India Company.)
- geofft 6y agoThe problem here isn't sustained logistics. The problem here is dealing with an entirely novel transient: vaccines for a novel virus exist (or were approved) when they didn't before, and people need them now, and then they're done with it. The market works great once it has had time to deal with transients and do price discovery, but this particular problem is entirely about transients and price discovery. Think back to the toilet paper shortage, or the mask shortage, or the hand sanitizer shortage, and how long it took the market to respond to those events. Maybe the market is the "second fastest' method we have, in relative terms. My point is it's still very slow, and if you're saying that days matter, the market is not the tool we want. (That said, throwing the military at this problem seems fine to me, honestly. It is a special case of throwing the government at the problem; it's the branch of the government that specializes in logistics and quick decision-making in life-or-death scenarios, as you point out, and they are used to dealing with situations that arise exactly once in the history of the world.)
- roenxi 6y ago> Think back to the toilet paper shortage, or the mask shortage, or the hand sanitizer shortage, and how long it took the market to respond to those events. Not long? Toilet paper distribution recovered quickly, little old ladies are now knitting masks and I hear distilleries have started converting into hand sanitiser plants. There was a month of confusion then in my experience everything started snapping back to normal. I've never seen so much hand sanitiser as is now available. > My point is it's still very slow, and if you're saying that days matter, the market is not the tool we want. Yet if we don't go with the market I bet a worse alternative will be chosen. Back in March-February people would have argued in February that the US CDC was there to overrule greedy companies rushing out coronavirus tests and make sure that there are high quality standards. Then the CDC shipped a test that didn't work and scuppered the US's opportunity to nip the pandemic in the bud. That instance alone is a damning indictment of a government-first response to a healthcare emergency. People can keep making a big song and dance about how this time the market can't possibly work because it is different to all the other times the market worked really well. Then the government will implement something slower than just letting people buy vaccines like everything else. In time the complete screw-up of the response will be used as evidence that there is no way a free market could have handled something so complicated. Pretty much every time a free market has been used to solve a problem, the problem gets resolved as fast as possible with minimum fuss. The only exception is problems that poor people have. Coronavirus is not a poor-person-problem. Leaving it to the market will get great results. > That said, throwing the military at this problem seems fine to me, honestly. It'll be slower than letting people buy a vaccine off the shelf. The military has no special advantage here. There are great reasons that the military isn't left in charge of running a countries logistics networks - they are competent but not the best at it.