4 ms·
That doesn't make it a prison: neither another student nor the teacher can step in and learn the material for your child. I don't know what you think would be a
by ineedasername 6y ago
That doesn't make it a prison: neither another student nor the teacher can step in and learn the material for your child. I don't know what you think would be an appropriate option there.
Also, you may have a job where none of your responsibilities are unique to you, but that's not often the case outside of some types of shift work. If I take a vacation or sick days, I have catching up to do. No one is going to step in for a couple of days and pickup where I left off on a project I've been working on for 3 months.
As for missing school, my kids go to typical mediocre public schools. When a student is struggling, they're given a little extra help. When they miss because they're sick, they're given plenty of time to makeup the work. And if a student is struggling so much that they can't reasonably move on to the next year's more complex material, the school literally devotes and extra year if resources to
- em-bee 6y agomontessori designed a way of teaching, where each child learns at their own pace. missed time simply never causes a problem that way
- ineedasername 6y agoThat doesn't mean a student doesn't miss something when they're away from school. Self-paced just changes the timing. The dynamic is not comparable to a work environment where someone else might be able to do the work for you. No one can learn for your child when they are away, and that fact doesn't change with less rigidly structured Montessori schools.
- em-bee 6y agoit definetly does mean that they don't miss anything, because the students just resume where they left off without any pressure to speed up.
- ineedasername 6y agoThey still need to actually learn the stuff. That's my point based on your original comment: You're comment was comparing work to school, and that normal schools were bad in some way because at work you could miss time and someone else would step in. I said, repeated, and will say again: learning does not work that way. No one can step in for you. Montessori doesn't change that. It changes the timing and, sure, the direct pressure from the teacher. That doesn't mean there isn't some type of pressure: from the parent, from the other students that are obliged to help in their co-operative learning structure, etc. I'm not debating the merits of Montessori schools. I'm saying the "missing time" aspect of your comment does not have a good analog from work to learning. That's all.
- em-bee 6y agoi am not concerned about who is doing the work, but when it needs to be done. missing time means, that you need to work overtime to make up for it. at work this is not normally the case. if the work can't be done by someone else, then it will simply be delayed. the timing changes. same with montessori learning. you will simply delay all your learning by a few days. which is not a problem at all because everyone is learning at their own pace anyways. contrast that with traditional schooling where overtime is the only way to catch up with your classmates
- em-bee 6y agoAlso, you may have a job where none of your responsibilities are unique to you, but that's not often the case outside of some types of shift work. in that environment how do you take a vacation? sure a planned downtime is easier than an unplanned one but the process is the same. in a programming team other team members pick up tasks. if my assistant is away, i may have to do some things myself. if i am sick, my customers will just have to wait. if i set my deadlines to short, not giving any buffer time, it's my fault. yes, there may be catch up type work, but usually i am not compelled to work overtime, which is how kids catch up time looks like. they are forced to catch up on their own time, not in class and they are not given a choice.