4 ms·
In NY (and, I think, California), that's illegal. I found this out, because at the company at which I worked, managers kept making verbal commitments, then gas
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
In NY (and, I think, California), that's illegal.
I found this out, because at the company at which I worked, managers kept making verbal commitments, then gaslighting me about them. I could never get them to commit in writing, and my own "reflection" emails (the standard advice about this) were worthless. I considered walking around with a little digital recorder in my pocket.
But many states have explicit laws against surreptitious audio recording. I suspect that comes from politicians being caught with wires (yeah, I'm a cynic).
That's why, if you get a surveillance camera that also records audio, they will usually have a card in there that tells you to post notices if you switch on the audio recorder.
- mpalmer 6y agoIt is not illegal in New York to record a conversation if the person recording is part of the conversation (one-party consent).
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoHuh. I did not know that. Thanks!
- greenyoda 6y agoHere's a summary of NY law regarding one-party consent: https://recordinglaw.com/united-states-recording-laws/one-party-consent-states/new-york-recording-laws/ https://recordinglaw.com/united-states-recording-laws/one-pa...
- jonas21 6y agoHowever, it is illegal in California, where the original author was located.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hinkley 6y agoBy reflection emails you mean where you summarize what was said and try to get the other person to confirm them? I think those only work if you disregard any statements that don't get confirmed, and/or you twist the statements into action items that you don't prioritize until they confirm them.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThe way that weasels (BTW: The Way of the Weasel, by Scott Adams, is downright prophetic about this kind of stuff) deal with it, is to not respond at all. Then, when you bring it up, they say “I never agreed to/said that!” If you then share the email, they say “I never got that. I would have corrected it, if I had.” Their manager always has their back on these exchanges.
- apricot 6y agoThat's why my reflection email always includes at least one question about some detail of the statement I want to confirm. "Per our conversation of this morning when you asked me to delete all our backups, do you want me to erase the disks or should I also roll over them with the company steamroller?"
- hinkley 6y agoHow about, “I’ll get started on that as soon as you confirm.”
- ffhhj 6y ago> But many states have explicit laws against surreptitious audio recording. I suspect that comes from politicians being caught with wires (yeah, I'm a cynic). Voices can be easily faked, that's the reason. Same will happen to video as deepfake technologies keep improving.
- swiley 6y agoRegardless of legality if you get found out you'll probably get walked out of the building by security (even if you're just using it as eg a substitute for taking notes among people with mutual trust.) I've heard stories about people who tried this and it's unlikely to end well.