4 ms·
There is another related syllogism that I don't have a name for: 1. We tried X as a solution for Y. 2. X didn't work, because we didn't implement it properly
by nerdponx 6y ago
There is another related syllogism that I don't have a name for:
1. We tried X as a solution for Y.
2. X didn't work, because we didn't implement it properly or we didn't understand how to implement it properly or some unrelated situation caused it to not work properly.
3. Therefore X and anything that even kind of resembles X is no longer an acceptable solution for Y.
- hackeraccount 6y agoThat's pretty much empiricism.
- nerdponx 6y agoWhat do you mean by that?
- giantg2 6y agoHypothesis failed; choose new hypotheses and try them. Edit: Since I'm getting down voted I wanted to specify that empirical evidence is gained through experience. The scientific method of trying hypotheses is a way of gaining empirical evidence.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoAs explained, it’s not empiricism because it misstates/ignores empirical data which would call into question the conclusion.
- giantg2 6y agoWhat empirical data would that be? If the only way to gain empirical evidence is through experience, and the previous hypothesis failed, then you would need a new hypothesis based on that failure. The way you state it, you are implying that there exists other evidence/data which is being ignored, but the scenario doesn't actually say that such evidence exists nor that it is being misstated.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoAdding emphasis to step 2 in the comment you responded to: > X didn't work, because we didn't implement it properly or we didn't understand how to implement it properly or some unrelated situation caused it to not work properly. Empiricism would seek to learn about these failures before step 1 as mitigation and before step 3 to determine if there’s new/more understandable data to prepare more effective mitigation for a repeat experiment.
- giantg2 6y ago"Empiricism would seek to learn about these failures before step 1 ..." In the context of the discussion (politics), this occurs in debates of legislation. Whether or not it's a meritorious debate depends on the subject and partisan makeup. "... and before step 3 to determine if there’s new/more understandable data to prepare more effective mitigation for a repeat experiment." In politics, this starts over as a new bill for debate. It could also mean allocating money to investigate the issue at hand too.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoMaybe I need to emphasize the original comment’s #3? > Therefore X and anything that even kind of resembles X is no longer an acceptable solution for Y.
- giantg2 6y agoIf you have evidence to support that, it's a valid conclusion. Basically, you seem to be arguing that that conclusion is always wrong. I'm saying it could be right depending on the evidence supporting or opposing it. (ie there's no evidence that number 3 means what you say it means)
- eyelidlessness 6y agoI’m not saying the conclusion is definitely wrong, I’m saying it’s unreasonable to assume it’s correct. What I’m saying is that the premise in the syllogism you replied to is that, in the case it applies to, the conclusion is suspect due to the errors that led to it. Empiricism doesn’t stop at falsification, it also involves reconsidering assumptions and trying to identify and eliminate complicating factors.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nyokodo 6y agoYet another related syllogism: 1. We tried X as a solution for Y. 2. X didn’t work, because the basis is fundamentally flawed. 3. We endlessly superficially tweak X to try to get it to work and it fails every time but we claim X is still good because it’s “never really been tried.”
- nerdponx 6y agoI feel like both of our syllogisms tend to be invoked by the same people in the same political debates!
- jessaustin 6y agoAh yes, any day now we'll happen upon that True Scottish capitalism that miraculously doesn't immediately devolve into crony capitalism.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> that True Scottish capitalism that miraculously doesn't immediately devolve into crony capitalism. Prevent the regulatory agencies from being captured by those corporations they were ostensibly intended to regulate.
- jessaustin 6y agoCapitalism doesn't require regulators or regulation. It doesn't even require the rule of law. It only requires that workers and consumers be prevented from free negotiation of the terms of production and commerce. Laws and regulations are often used this way, but capricious despotism does the job nearly as well.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoI'm not sure I follow, it would seem that the opposite of this is true: > Capitalism [...] only requires that workers and consumers be prevented from free negotiation of the terms of production and commerce. Isn't capitalism what arises when workers and consumers are permitted to freely negotiate terms?
- jessaustin 6y agoThere's another party to consider. (hint... it's in the name!) In truly fluid and uncertain situations, capital takes a beating. Humans can adapt or even move; those factories that burned down won't rebuild themselves. After the Revolutionary War, but before the USA Constitution was imposed on the populace, was such a situation. Free farmers opposed capital both violently and via monetary policy (through pro-inflation and relaxed debt-enforcement laws passed by states in the grip of actual representative government). Madison and the rest of the conspirators were far more troubled by the latter excess of freedom; they certainly didn't invite any poor tenant farmers to Philadelphia. There they succeeded in making USA safe for capital. "Federalism" was a lie from the beginning; no state is allowed to inconvenience big business. In the 1860s a rather destructive war was fought over that issue (among others). Ever since then, whenever and wherever circumstances have favored the positions of workers more than capitalists can accept, the USA Army (or sometimes the Pinkertons!) have stepped in to violently modify negotiating positions. In the post-WWII period they were unable to do that for several decades, and USA enjoyed its greatest prosperity. In the late 1960s they figured out a way to make a war hurt the population more than it hurt capital (and also they killed half a dozen of the people who were warning us about it), and USA has gone downhill ever since. Year after year, they introduce discrete "shocks" that devastate the poor and middle class, while always keeping the resources of the state ready to support the interests of capital. The "mistakes" of capitalism that we observe in every decade are in fact its most vital features. When the spoils of progress accrue to capital, they don't accrue to humans. Even if we imagine they didn't "implement it properly" last time, there's no reason to expect they'll do it "properly" next time either.