5 ms·
Apple IPad’s ‘Buzz Saw’ Success Cuts PC Sales at HP, Dell
- coffeedrinker 16y agoBuying an iPad is buying a second device of a kind different than anything you currently have. Buying another computer is done to replace one that is obsolete (something that is less frequent over the last several years). In other words, computer sales were destined to "fall off" a bit anyway. Once tablet devices reach a saturation point with limited benefit for upgrading, they will suffer a similar fate.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoYou are correct, but the event you're taking about (the "everyone who can afford one has a computer" event) happened years ago. We're already there. Destiny is history. That said, things never really decline, because prices are going down, the need for computing is going up, and so the market is always expanding and sales just steadily grow now and forever. You only ever see these kinds of false "declines" where people are really just shifting to a different kind of computer.
- roc 16y ago> "The tablet is going to replace at least the home computer." I don't know about that. But what I think is still a huge deal, and far more likely, is that families will trend back toward one shared PC in the den and use multiple secondary devices for individual use. While I don't think you can get away without a home PC, you can certainly share one more easily when all but a handful of tasks are doable (if not more enjoyable) on a tablet. And that's going to hurt a lot of home PC purchasing, with the notable exception of when the kids go off to college.
- cryptoz 16y ago> While I don't think you can get away without a home PC Are you saying this about today, May 18 2011? If you are, I suppose you might be right. But by, say, the end of the year, or maybe next year, I think you'll be absolutely wrong. The tablet market moves fast and soon there won't be a single task that isn't only doable but indeed more enjoyable on the tablet. Right now, my Xoom outperforms (measured in my happiness levels, not CPU speed) all my home PCs for every single task except software development. I see no reason at all to have a home PC if you own a Xoom or similar tablet. I just bought the nice bluetooth keyboard which means that now even composing blog entries or writing emails is nicer on the tablet. Everything's changing, and fast. It would be shortsighted to suggest that everyone needs an i7, 4GB of RAM, 2TB of storage and a DVD drive in 2011. Desktops will become more and more of a niche device, used only by nerds, while tablets and their descendants will take over the whole consumer market.
- allenp 16y agoI think if your definition of a tablet includes an optional keyboard and mouse then you may be right (I see you bought a keyboard). I just think there are too many tasks that require more precise input than just a touch based screen. Most people when talking about tablets don't include those in their thinking, but it is definitely the way to go to maximize the functionality of the device.
- hvs 16y agoTablets can't do serious gaming.
- swombat 16y ago99% of people don't give a toss about serious gaming. The iPad has become the primary gaming device for me - I rarely ever play video games elsewhere.
- ugh 16y agoAlso, gaming consoles exist. A PC was never necessary for serious gaming.
- aaronblohowiak 16y agountrue, but it was more than ten years ago...
- ugh 16y agoWhy is that? You will have to explain your odd view a bit more, I fear. I can understand that some people prefer PC gaming for one reason or another but I think I’m quite correct in guessing that those people are a tiny minority – it’s a niche.
- aaronblohowiak 16y agothere was a brief window when online 3d gaming was first taking off and none of the major consoles supported it in a good way -- the only game in town for hardcore gaming was the PC. Sure, the dreamcast might have been able to do it, but everybody was using gamespy to connect to their favorite servers.
- scott_s 16y agoI came here to say something similar. I think it may also replace computer upgrade purchases. That is, it's not strictly necessary to replace the current computer, but gosh is it running slow. But if the family uses the iPad more, they can tolerate a slow computer during the word processing and bill-paying.
- nanijoe 16y agoI have no home computer...I have my Laptop for work, and everyone else uses an iPad or phone.
- bonch 16y agoOf course it's going to replace the home computer. Tablets are becoming the home computer. If tablets browse the web, access email, play music, and more, why would most of the public need a PC? Only those with technical needs would require a tower and monitor on their desk.
- nanidin 16y agoIt seems like a pretty big jump to determine causality here - nowhere in the article do they mention consumer studies indicating consumers have purchased the IPad in lieu of a PC. Until they do that, this seems like speculation at best. For instance, maybe people realized that a new PC doesn't buy them anything in terms of performance for their web browsing and document editing needs.
- swombat 16y agoAnecdotally, I know several people who have replaced their computers completely with iPads. They won't be buying new laptops any time soon (and yes, they use their iPads for work).
- Hov 16y agoIt might be illuminating to know what kind of work they do? Me being a software developer, I obviously can't use an iPad at work...neither can our Business Analysts or testers. If you're a manager I suppose you can get by with one. If you're actually producing stuff ie, software, tech specs, bug reports etc, then no.
- lukeschlather 16y agoAnecdotally, I didn't bother to set up two monitors when I started my current job (since I was the sole IT person) and after about six months I added one since there are a few lying around and was blown away by how much my productivity improved. Granted, I'm doing development, but most tasks involving a computer are positively impacted by increases in screen real estate. I've had the bookkeeping office say they won't work with less than two monitors, and one of them needs to be largish. Given the spreadsheets they work with, I see the need. There are plenty of tasks where the lack of real estate might seem to be unimportant, but what it comes down to is that when you're trying to fit anything of nontrivial complexity on a screen the size of the iPad, you use more and more mental energy on context-switching as the complexity increases.
- swombat 16y ago
- rrrazdan 16y agoIf tablets really are the future of computing, then developing countries can bridge the digital gap quickly with inexpensive tablets. http://www.engadget.com/2010/07/23/35-tablet-from-india-looks-to-be-worth-every-paisa-video/ http://www.engadget.com/2010/07/23/35-tablet-from-india-look... Imagine 500 millions like these in every Indian's pocket.
- rubinelli 16y agoThose Indians, they sure have big pockets! ;^) Jokes aside, that's a good point. When you have your own computing device, you have the chance to play around with it instead of just following a script ("click the blue e, type facebook, press enter..."). These low-cost models lack 3G and have a horrible battery life, but if they become popular, I'm sure we will see enterprising individuals opening hole-in-the-wall cafés offering cheap wi-fi and charging cradles.
- antidaily 16y agoThe price point is similar. Both browse the internet just fine. But one has Angry Birds and FaceTime. One is new and cool. One is dusty, has viruses and keeps reminding you that your software license may be non-genuine.
- kenjackson 16y agoTablets are purely a very short-lived stop gap (think a few years). The future is phone sized devices with foldable screens. Use it small when you're on the go. But when you want to sit on the couch or on the bus, you open it up. The dedicated tablet becomes a niche product for those people that need the full power of a dedidicated large machine. http://www.slashgear.com/samsung-develops-sweet-foldable-amoled-screen-with-no-seam-13151802/ http://www.slashgear.com/samsung-develops-sweet-foldable-amo...
- erikpukinskis 16y agoThere's no way a screen the size of the iPad is going to fit in your pocket in the next 10-20 years. Not because it can't fold, but because it weights a pound and a half. The battery alone is 5+ ounces, more than the entire weight of an iPhone. Dedicated tablets are here to stay.
- kenjackson 16y agoDisplay efficiency is getting better all the time. If PenTile ever becomes reasonable, that has a 40% reduction in power. And if you gave me the choice to carry a heavier phone, but get rid of a tablet, I'd do it. Lastly, I suspect the size of these tablets would be 7" rather than 10".
- berntb 16y agoI didn't realize the reason why 7" is bad before I got an iPad and started to read web pages, pdf documents etc. For 7" to take over, you need to change standard for page sizes (or operate the eyes of everyone over 40).
- 6ren 16y ago> Tablet owners are actually more likely than US online consumers in general to have recently bought a PC http://blogs.forrester.com/sarah_rotman_epps/11-05-17-hps_earnings_and_the_post_pc_era http://blogs.forrester.com/sarah_rotman_epps/11-05-17-hps_ea...
- kenjackson 16y agoThe numbers don't add up... PC sales are about 85-90M per quarter. iPad was selling at 4.7M that quarter. If every person who was going to buy a PC bought an iPad it would be a 5.5% reduction. Consumers are about half the market, so maybe you say 11% of the consumer market. And that again is assuming EVERY iPad sale is a lost consumer PC sale. HP dropping 20%+ is bigger than the iPad.
- rick_bc 16y agoYou forgot about Mac :)
- kragen 16y agoI worry a lot about this, because users have a lot less freedom with the iPad than with PCs; they're a lot more vulnerable to Apple, which can abuse its power in the same way that Facebook can. If the iPad or something like it wins, disruptive innovation in computers is dead, because incumbents will control the market, and incumbents don't like disruptive innovation.
- schmittz 16y agoI agree that incumbents don't like disruptive innovation (in general), but who says that a) Apple wouldn't mind as they've in general done a phenomenal job of interrupting themselves before others have had the chance over the last twenty years or b) that another new company won't unseed Apple as Apple (while not in market share, but in prominence and recently also income) has unseeded Microsoft.
- zmmmmm 16y agoI worry too, but the good news is that Honeycomb looks like it may well escape the near-death experience of launching too early with the Xoom. If you gloss over the small glitches nearly everyone who uses it loves it. Fingers crossed we're heading to at least two viable tablet OSes, if not three (number three being a total wildcard, but I would probably pick windows 8 if only because eventually business adoption will give the momentum).
- kragen 16y agoHoneycomb is still proprietary, isn't it? And Motorola is notorious for locking down its devices so users can't control them, even if the users do have a version of software that they want to install. (Edit: glad to hear they aren't doing that on this one.)
- rick_bc 16y agoThe losts are in revenues, not units. It's entirely possible that people opt for lower priced computers instead of iPads.