3 ms·
I left academia for industry, so my opinion might be colored by the transition. The way I see it, the easy problems that can be solved by one or two individual
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
I left academia for industry, so my opinion might be colored by the transition.
The way I see it, the easy problems that can be solved by one or two individuals are mostly gone. You need large diverse teams to tackle interesting problems.
To translate this into policy, you need opportunities for many more first authors, and you need to try to incentivize completely different departments to work together.
- virtuallynathan 6y agoI’m not sure this is true in all areas, there are very simple questions left unanswered in health/medicine/nutrition that could be at least partially answered by very small studies.
- bra-ket 6y ago> You need large diverse teams to tackle interesting problems This ‘corporate’ view of science is just not true, kind of like adding “man-hours” to software projects doesn’t necessarily account for better software, speeds up or enables those projects. Large diverse teams just produce more mediocre research, if recent experience with massive “deep learning” industry is of any indication, or fail completely like that “blue brain” project with multi billion funding and thousands of participants. Bigger is not always better and it has never been necessary for good science.
- mattkrause 6y agoThe Human Brain Project is an extreme case. On the other hand, there are pretty hard limits to the sorts of projects that our standard model of a single full-time person[0] can do, even with some part-time collaborators (i.e., middle authors). This is especially true for projects that involve a combination of very different approaches: bioinformatics, HTS, in vivo validation, etc. I've noticed more and more papers with multiple (sometimes 5!) co-first authors, but that's a kludge around the fact that we can't figure out how to allocate credit to teams. [0] And, almost invariably, a trainee
- s0rce 6y agoI'd say this is true in a sense that you "stand on the shoulders of giants", you rely on a lot of technology and science that has been developed by others. But small non-diverse teams can accomplish important (but likely small) breakthroughs in their field. You don't necessarily need a large diverse team to do important science. My anecdote is my PhD work.