4 ms·
I have a neighbor who burns wood every day, and I bought an air quality monitor to see what the impact is on our air. The AQI hits 150 when it’s burning, which
by gnicholas 6y ago
I have a neighbor who burns wood every day, and I bought an air quality monitor to see what the impact is on our air.
The AQI hits 150 when it’s burning, which is really unhealthy. I was surprised it was this bad, especially since he’s not that close of a neighbor (on a different street even).
- DoingIsLearning 6y agoThis is an indoor measurement in your house or an outside street measurement?
- gnicholas 6y agoOutside my front door. Every time we bring in a package the smell of smoke spreads through the house. And we can’t open windows to air out the baby’s room (after a diaper change) since we’d be swapping smelly air for air that is both smelly and unhealthy.
- irq 6y agoI, too, have a neighbor with a wood burner (used during the cold months only fortunately) that easily adds 75 to 100 to the outdoor AQI (using Purple Air). My indoor air quality is unaffected due to central air filtering. Given the health impact, these burners should be seized and replaced with almost anything else, with full financial assistance. (Why? It's cheaper to replace these burners than it is to suffer the long term public health costs caused by their existence).
- gnicholas 6y agoIn California, it is illegal to burn (except for cooking or if you have no other way to heat your home) on Spare the Air days. Unfortunately, there are a surprising number of homes in the Bay Area that fall into the latter exception. I recently heard about this nonprofit that is helping people retrofit their homes and get rid of wood burning stoves. http://www.rebuildingtogetherpeninsula.org/ http://www.rebuildingtogetherpeninsula.org/
- generalizations 6y ago> these burners should be seized and replaced Wood is far cheaper than alternatives, often even free (e.g., a neighbor cuts down a tree, you get rid of it for them). Financial assistance is onerous to obtain. You're also assuming it's appropriate for some government beurocrat to make such a decision on the first place. "It's my woodstove, you can't have it."
- aaomidi 6y ago> You're also assuming it's appropriate for some government beurocrat to make such a decision on the first place. " China banned the country from getting pallets of plastic because once they factored in the public health costs, it wasn't profitable (and it was barely profitable before hand). The government bans people from driving while drunk because they have a potential to hurt others. We have precedence for the government limiting various freedoms for the safety of others. For example, in most of the US you can't smoke when there are others nearby or when indoors.
- generalizations 6y agoThere's a clear difference between prohibiting drunk driving, and telling me I can't continue to use my wood stove inside my own home.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThere's also a pretty strong similarity. We're all driving the same roads; we're all breathing the same air.
- ashtonkem 6y agoI’m a huge fan of providing incentives for people to upgrade, but I would fight tooth and nail against seizing inefficient burners. Opening up the door for the government to randomly deprive citizens of their property is an awful door to open, and it will be abused eventually, no matter how just the cause feels today.
- noja 6y agoWhat do you think about noise pollution?
- ashtonkem 6y agoI'm ok with fining people for it. I'm not fine with wandering around and seizing personal property that could conceivably be used to produce noise pollution. Generally speaking, we should only allow the government to intervene in personal freedoms when there is a compelling interest, and we should expect that the interventions are tailored to be as minimal as possible. A compelling reason existing is no excuse to give the government unlimited powers, for fairly obvious reasons. For corporations, this obviously means complying with a robust regulatory framework; if I own a company that sells wood burning stoves, then I have to comply with EPA regulations around how many grams per hour of soot it may emit when properly maintained. In exchange for having to keep up with the changing regulations, the government should provide reasonable timelines and clarity around what is expected. As a private citizen, this means accepting some limitations on how we use our private property. As a citizen I can legally purchase a car, own a firearm, and consume alcohol, but if I decide to use all three at once I will probably lose my right to have all three, plus I'll get locked in jail. Occasionally changing regulatory requirements will mean that certain pieces of equipment can't be operated anymore; if you had a car that had to use leaded fuel (not a substitute), then it would effectively be illegal to operate it going forward. What is not fine is for the government to say "your car needs leaded fuel, so we are going to seize it from you". The government should not be in the business of seizing private property that may be used to violate the law, especially when it was purchased legally. We don't do pre-crime in this country, owning something that may be used to violate the law is not a crime punishable by loss of private property. We also have constitutional protections against ex post facto laws; you cannot punish a citizen for what they purchased back when it was legal. If it's necessary to put strict limits on pollution and fine users who exceed them, that is fine by me. I'd even be happy to pay a bit more in taxes to fund optional buybacks and incentives to help users buy newer and more efficient units. But proposing that the government go and seize private property that may be used to eventually break some new regulation is beyond the pale.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoI don't know if this affects your argument, but are you sure you can trust the AQI meter's readings for anomalous levels? We recently had a discussion on this topic: [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25138485 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25138485
- apta_ 6y agoWhich air quality monitor did you purchase?
- gnicholas 6y agoI’m using a PocketLab device. I actually know the PocketLab guys from the Intel Education Accelerator; we were in the initial cohort together. I would have otherwise purchased a purple air device.
- throw0101a 6y ago> I have a neighbor who burns wood every day, and I bought an air quality monitor to see what the impact is on our air. How old is their unit? The new EPA BurnWise standard seems to really help things with efficiency and particulate. As a rule of thumb: the exhaust gases should be clear. If it's not (i.e., black or grey smoke), then there's lots of material that hasn't been combusted which is wasteful and unhealthy.