3 ms·
I think I just realized while Apple doesn't allow side loading apps. Because if you could side load apps, then Chinese citizens could side load apps, and Apple
by jedberg 6y ago
I think I just realized while Apple doesn't allow side loading apps. Because if you could side load apps, then Chinese citizens could side load apps, and Apple would no longer be favored in China.
This complaint makes me feel like it's as simple as that. Apple just fears China.
- Lammy 6y ago> Apple doesn't allow side loading apps HN readers might be surprised at the extent of modded-iOS-app communities (just like APK communities for Androids) that manage to exist within the meager 7-day signing window Apple allows a free-tier developer account. Tools like AltStore and ReProvision are the standard for sideloading and renewing (respectively) legitimate jailbreak-entrypoint apps: https://github.com/rileytestut/AltStore https://github.com/rileytestut/AltStore https://github.com/Matchstic/ReProvision https://github.com/Matchstic/ReProvision Even for un-jailbroken devices there are entire alternative ecosystems based around sideloading modded/pirated apps. They are obviously full of pirated stuff, usually work by abusing an enterprise cert from an endless list of Chinese companies (not insinuating anything bad, just firsthand experience), and they probably have some nasty malware mixed in here and there as well. Zero endorsement for any of these examples from the first page of a DDG search, but you get the idea: https://www.tutuapp.com/pc/ https://www.tutuapp.com/pc/ https://iphonecake.com/ https://iphonecake.com/ https://sideload.tweakboxapp.com/ https://sideload.tweakboxapp.com/ https://ipaspot.app/ https://ipaspot.app/ https://www.valuewalk.com/2019/04/spotify-up-tweakbox-users-tutuapp-lite/ https://www.valuewalk.com/2019/04/spotify-up-tweakbox-users-...
- Veen 6y agoThat's a possible reason, but do you have any evidence that it's the real reason beyond it being vaguely plausible while making Apple look as bad as possible. Preventing side-loading improves iOS device security, which is just as plausible as your theory.
- jedberg 6y ago> do you have any evidence that it's the real reason This lawsuit. > Preventing side-loading improves iOS device security Yes, this is true. Welding the doors to your house shut also improve security. But it does so at the expense of usability. There is a reasonable trade off between usability and security and Apple makes an unreasonable choice.
- pvg 6y agoI think I just realized while Apple doesn't allow side loading apps. Because if you could side load apps, then Chinese citizens You think that's the reason, since 2007 (and every year after) when Apple also didn't allow sideloading apps? It seems a little fanciful, at best.
- abc-xyz 6y agoIf the judges hadn’t blocked Trump’s attempt at banning TikTok and WeChat (he had made clear intentions that he would go after more Chinese apps/companies as well) then Apple could’ve been in a position where they were forced to block Chinese apps worldwide, which would almost certainly guarantee that China wouldn’t be able to build popular apps that could be used to spread CCP propaganda and censorship, and influence elections. Apple’s lack of side loading not only protect the users from malware, but it could also serve as the perfect weapon for the US government to make it near impossible for a company/nation to compete in the mobile app sector. That’s likely why 40%-Tencent owned Epic engaged in a desperate PR lawsuit to try to make it possible to side-load apps.