3 ms·
Blaming "over parenting" has been around for at least as long as I've been a parent, possibly even going back generations. I wonder if the micro-management of
by analog31 6y ago
Blaming "over parenting" has been around for at least as long as I've been a parent, possibly even going back generations.
I wonder if the micro-management of parenting by popular culture can itself be seen as a form of over-parenting at a societal level. As we helicopter over our children, we are constantly aware of an even larger helicopter hovering over us, ready to blame parents (especially moms) for every tiny little transgression that led to our kids not growing up to be perfect in every way.
- itronitron 6y agoIt's funny that the educational system complains the most about helicopter parenting yet they are the ones setting unrealistic performance expectations for students.
- gls2ro 6y agoYou are so right about parents being easily judged according with some high standards. Or it might be just me the one who when saw the title of this article I was thinking: "Great, another article which will show me how bad I am at parenting" When my child was born I did an extensive research about what kind of books should I read which are baked by science and will teach me how to be a good parent and I read most of these books. Then I found that - at least for me - it is very hard to apply what they are suggesting. Then I started to feel bad that I am not doing enough. I even paid time to talk with a paediatric psychologist to make sure that I was understanding the science of child development in the right way. And after a couple of sessions which were mostly going like this: I was going with a list of studies I read and questions I had about how to apply them and she explaining the big picture and where does fit or not. Until one day when she asked: "Did you watched your child? What does he want? What does he enjoy? Is he ready for this?" And then (months later) I realised that by trying to apply all this things I was not myself and in the same time I was actually not paying attention to the child's own needs. I put a lot of stress to myself to the edge of burnout by reading and thinking all the time about this good parenting stuff. He is a full person which his own desires and forming his personality. Does not matter what I want him to be. I should offer the best that I can but in the direction that he wants to explore. Now we go for a bike ride. Or play outside. Or read. Or do a paper rocket. Sometimes I help him dress, sometimes he wants to do it himself. But I don't have a plan of how the day will be. I still struggle with questions about my parenting style. But I try to be more aware of his personality.
- vagrantJin 6y ago> wonder if the micro-management of parenting by popular culture can itself be seen as a form of over-parenting at a societal level. Can you elaborate on this? We are social animals so I guess this is behaviour that might be quite old. I'm going to go on a limb to conjecture that coddled kids aren't as productive, resilient or resourceful as their headstrong counterparts. Could it be possible in old times that "the society" needed resourceful and headstrong young people over those who can hardly wipe their own arse without their mother, especially in unstable political groupings (from clans to villages to cities to provinces to nation states)? But the kind of helicoptering in the article is basically coddling a child to oblivion regardless of age which hampers the development of said child's potential. No one said anything about perfection. No one ever has. That's the unreasonable and impossible standard an emotionally unstable parent(s) may strive for thereby overcompensating on some imaginary 'specialness' in their children.
- closeparen 6y agoSomething that struck me from books set in the olden days was how children seemed to be parented by the whole community. I wonder if the diminished role of the "village" in our more individualistic era makes it more critical, in perception or in reality, for parents to get everything right.