3 ms·
Ok, so who do you go to that isn't? Even Fairphone is up to their eyeballs in Chinese suppliers and they say in their own literature they can't account for all
by simonh 6y ago
Ok, so who do you go to that isn't? Even Fairphone is up to their eyeballs in Chinese suppliers and they say in their own literature they can't account for all their upstreams.
Apple are always the ones that get walloped publicly on issues like this, and actually I'm ok with that. It's good these issues get air time at all, if Apple didn't exist and it was all Microsoft, Samsung and such none of this would ever get out and if it did nobody would care. But pretending this is all about Apple, slagging them in a comment and then going and buying the next Chinese made gear from Amazon or whoever is just brushing this under the rug.
- strogonoff 6y agoPurism’s Librem 5 seems to be a worthy alternative. They publish[0] schematics and aim to allow users to verify that hardware hadn’t been altered by a supplier. [0] https://puri.sm/posts/a-different-kind-of-transparency/ https://puri.sm/posts/a-different-kind-of-transparency/
- simonh 6y agoBoth efforts are great and well worth pursuing, but Purism don’t really talk at all about their hardware supply chain. Their focus in on the software and end user privacy, so they’re exposed to exactly the same hardware supply chain risks.
- strogonoff 6y agoDisclosing suppliers implies existential possibility of a supplier that can be trusted. A user with heightened security needs understands that the only way to guarantee supplier trustworthiness is to personally be present at the factory. Disclosing schematics (open-source hardware) and board x-rays removes the supplier trust requirement. A user with heightened security needs can diff received hardware with the reference (don’t trust; verify), or build their own phone to the spec.
- joncrane 6y ago>they say in their own literature they can't account for all their upstreams. Sounds to me like a) at least they're trying and b)they're being honest. Still a significant moral upgrade over most of their competitors.
- simonh 6y agoOh absolutely, I've got a lot of respect for that team. I'm just saying even if you're wiling to really go the extra mile this can still happen. I think the only way to really address it is to put the blame squarely where it actually lies, with the people doing it. Holding manufacturers to account does play a role in flushing these problems out into the open, but we need to be realistic about the limits of what we can expect from them.
- Schiendelman 6y agoIsn’t Apple doing both a and b? They seem very open about struggling with suppliers, commit to goals they can use their clout to impact, and report on those goals using third party verification.