5 ms·
always entertaining how regulation unintentionally acts to increase barriers to entry for incumbents. in this case closing the barn doors almost a decade after
by swyx 6y ago
always entertaining how regulation unintentionally acts to increase barriers to entry for incumbents. in this case closing the barn doors almost a decade after the horse left the stable. you couldn't pay politicians enough for the favors they perform in earnest.
edit:to elaborate, the growth hacks of the likes of Doordash and Postmates doing exactly this got them their start, now it will be illegal to compete with them using the same methods they used. I understand there are also brand protection concerns for the small restaurants. have to weigh the tradeoffs.
- DGAP 6y agoExactly. If I'm in California and I want to challenge the incumbents with my cool new idea about how to do delivery better, now I can't. There's no way to effectively scale a sales team in the beginning to reach out to all these restaurants. And as you said, all the successful incumbent players already used this strategy to become big, now this won't materially affect them. They already have sales agreements in place with all the biggest sellers on their platforms.
- criddell 6y agoThe incumbents spent a lot of investor money to get where they are today. DoorDash, for example, started in San Francisco with something like 75 restaurants. That feels doable even with this bill. Today DoorDash is worth something like $15 billion. If you actually have a better idea and can execute, you will find investors.
- tzs 6y ago> There's no way to effectively scale a sales team in the beginning to reach out to all these restaurants. Sure their is. There's a whole system dedicated to it. You make a brochure describing the service you want to offer to the restaurants. There are then companies that will print as many copies of that brochure as you ask them to, put them in envelopes, and mail them to addresses on a list you provide. (There are companies that will make the list for you, too). Combine that with phone calls to the restaurants you think would be most beneficial to get on your service. Three salespeople using phones could contact 10% of the restaurants in Los Angeles in under a month, and all of them within a year. Restaurant delivery is local. You don't have to compete with the incumbents nationwide right from the start. You can do it one city at a time.
- throway1gjj 6y ago>unintentionally
- DevKoala 6y agoWhat do you mean? In this case small businesses were being abused by delivery apps. Once these apps captured the customers of the small business, they converted the customers to their alternative offering restaurant. This is a good piece of legislature unless I am missing something.
- foogazi 6y agoHow were businesses being abused? Do you mean customers use the app to order from X-Pizza, the app then prominently lists Y-Pizza and now X loses customers?
- bombcar 6y agoThe main issue that I saw was: 1. Customer orders from Big Don’s Pizza (but it’s actual door dash) 2. Pizza arrives late, cold, and on fire. 3. Customer swears to and at Big Don that he’ll never buy from them again. 4. Dominos wins.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoCustomer orders pizza from SmallCorp through BigCorp. BigCorp pizza arrives late, with wrong order because BigCorp transcribed it wrong, or because BigCorp's courier failed to double check all the items. Customer gets incorrect and incomplete order from BigCorp. Customer calls BigCorp to complain. BigCorp tells customer to contact SmallCorp if they have an issue. So now SmallCorp has an issue where even though they correctly fulfilled the order sent to them by BigCorp, the customer (who they have no record of) is unsatisfied. I've experienced this personally from both of the "red letter" food delivery apps. Just as bad is when they screw up and add "pick up" as an option for a company who never agreed to take pick up orders. Last week I ordered meals for my family, arrived at the place, they had no record of me placing the order because they did not do business with BigCorp.
- wskinner 6y agoDoorDash and Postmates would deliver from every restaurant, whether or not they had a relationship with that restaurant. This helped them grow quickly. A DoorDash competitor that started today would not be able to grow that way because it is now illegal to deliver from a restaurant without the restaurant’s consent. DoorDash is already large and has a well known brand, so this doesn’t hurt them. It does hurt future competitors, for whom the cost of developing a relationship with every restaurant is cost prohibitive.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lesdeuxmagots 6y agoYea, I do wonder if this will shut the door on any future high growth independent startups in the space to be created locally. DoorDash started their business doing exactly this in Palo Alto, and likely wouldn’t have been able to raise the funds or grow at the pace they did without this strategy. On one hand, you could say good, these sorts of businesses are exploitative. But I’m not sure that the industry is a net negative as a whole, and this law could shut the door on a more sustainable model.
- maxerickson 6y agoIt seems like an agreement or explicit description of what is happening (the delivery service is providing the food, not the restaurant) is going to be part of any sustainable model.
- throwaway2245 6y ago> Doordash and Postmates doing exactly this got them their start, now it will be illegal to compete with them using the same methods they used. Waiting for a company with even worse practices, to be able to compete most effectively, doesn't seem like a net win.
- wayne 6y agoIt does seem messed up that we see a bad behavior, create a law to ban that behavior, and the law's biggest beneficiary is the company doing the bad behavior.
- Ekaros 6y agoOn other hand should then the bad behaviour be allowed to continue forever? Isn't something late better than never?
- Spivak 6y agoYes but if you don’t also punish the companies who did the bad thing then you end up just giving them a moat. I’m of two minds about our legal system in this regard. It’s nice that you don’t really ever have to be worried about getting punished for things you did in the past suddenly being declared illegal but in doing so it rewards entities who have no conscience. And large groups of people acting together are quite good at silencing individual consciences.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- swyx 6y agoyea right now we are simply incentivizing going after unregulated space as aggressively as possible before laws are written for them. writing regulation after the deed is done tackles symptoms while fueling root cause.
- kevingadd 6y agoThe barn door needs to be closed. I don't care if it means there won't be more doordashes if the only way those companies can exist is by scamming customers and exploiting restaurants. I don't see why this is a problem. They're called "growth hacks" for a reason. If your concern is that people won't be able to compete with DoorDash now without breaking the law, maybe DoorDash should be penalized for past misbehavior... If you follow this "but banning this will prevent competition!" logic to its conclusion now it's logically inappropriate to make all sorts of things illegal because fraudsters got rich doing them and it would prevent competition. Personally I think it's possible for delivery apps to succeed without breaking the law. Similarly I believe a cab-hailing app can succeed without breaking the law. The fact that the big players in both markets have made "regulatory arbitrage" and lawbreaking a core part of their business model (protected by massive amounts of venture capital and highly paid lawyers) is not a reason to get rid of the laws they broke.
- ghaff 6y agoI agree with you on cab-hailing given that cabs were such a miserable experience in so many cases. (Though I expect usage will certainly go down as prices rise and coverage may get thinner as a result.) I don't know about prepared food delivery. Dominos makes it work well. A lot of Chinese restaurants do, usually for a pretty small delivery radius. But there are a lot of things that just don't have a critical mass of people willing to pay for what 30 minute delivery costs. (On the other hand, the consensus seems to be that grocery delivery, or just pickup, is going to stay fairly common going forward.)
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y ago> growth hacks Tech speak for: breaking the law. But hey, money, so who cares if we ruin a bunch of lives and make the world a worse place? Isn't that what technology is all about?
- wasdfff 6y agoIf companies need to exploit small businesses to compete, they shouldn't be in business in the first place. Boo hoo to all the stillborn future door dashes who wont be able to exploit local businesses.
- NationalPark 6y agoDoesn't that apply equally to every single law ever written? In a just world maybe the incumbents would pay something, but "somebody found a new way to hurt people, and it wouldn't be fair to everyone else who also want to hurt people but haven't yet" doesn't really address the actual problem - that people are being hurt.