4 ms·
A lack of knowledge of British history is hardly grounds for questioning someone's grasp on reality.
by barrkel 16y ago
A lack of knowledge of British history is hardly grounds for questioning someone's grasp on reality.
- btilly 16y agoI'm questioning his grasp of reality because he believes that about a thousand years of recorded history didn't happen, and there is some plot among historians to cover this up. In this particular case a lack of knowledge of British history is a lack of knowledge of world history. The British Agricultural Revolution resulted in major increases in food supply, that allowed populations to grow rapidly. What Britain discovered got exported to the rest of Europe, and European colonies. The result was a greatly expanded carrying capacity for the human population, which enabled a world-wide population explosion. Now granted, most people don't know about this. But if you're curious about the history of population growth in Europe, it really is easy to find out what historians have to say about it. And when you do so you should run across this fairly quickly.
- hugh3 16y agoI do agree, that article is slightly nutty. It has the usual air of a very smart guy getting outside his area of expertise -- one simple observation plus one leap to a rather world-shattering conclusion minus a few key pieces of knowledge which anyone in the actual field should know about. It's not quite the same thing as having a tenuous grasp on reality. It's more like listening to Einstein (or Chomsky) on politics -- very good in one field, rather over-confident in another.
- singular 16y ago> It's more like listening to Einstein (or Chomsky) on politics -- very good in one field, rather over-confident in another. Chomsky is very careful to heavily reference and back up his political opinions, so I'm a little confused as to how he is over-confident in the field? I assume you simply disagree with him?
- gaius 16y agoIt must be noted that what Chomsky is famous for, his deep grammar, has never been shown to be anything more than a particularly elegant theory, not representative of actual real linguistics - and that is what he is good at, assembling beautiful arguments ultimately based on nothing. He's an extremely skillful rhetoritician and orator - but the acid test is, does this work?
- singular 16y agoI'm not informed enough about linguistics to be able to determine whether what you say is true or not, but it is certainly irrelevant to what we're actually discussing - Chomsky does supply evidence to back up his political claims.
- gaius 16y agoMmm yes, like I say, he's very good at being convincing and selective use of references is a part of that, but his conclusions are reheated anarcho-syndicalism, a system that was tried and failed in the 1930s. It doesn't matter how elegant your theories are - what matters is what actually happens when the rubber hits the road. Just like a good (in the sense of skill) salesman can sell you a product you don't actually want by producing all the evidence you need...
- barrkel 16y agoIn parsing, we talk about things like Chomsky hierarchy and Chomsky normal form as a matter of course.
- zwischenzug 16y agoI've never found major fault with Chomsky's analyses in any field. I'd be interested to know where you think he's been over-confident.
- thaumaturgy 16y agoOne of the traps associated with becoming dedicated to games of strategy is that you begin to see the subtleties of the game everywhere in the world around you. Gradually, you might begin to believe that there are vast orchestrated conspiracies, played out across the world as though it were a game of chess.