7 ms·
> No individual should suffer harassment or attack based on their personal or political views, religion, nationality, race, gender, or sexual orientation sigh
by pjc50 6y ago
> No individual should suffer harassment or attack based on their personal or political views, religion, nationality, race, gender, or sexual orientation
sigh One of those things is not like the others. I agree that people should not be hounded out of science. That means not publishing papers, articles or comments to the effect that "women can't do science" or bell curve arguments about some races being less intellectually capable than others. That is also hounding people out of science.
- pc86 6y agoWhich one is not like the other? I see a couple things that are choices. A couple that are innate. A couple that are considered sensitive information, and a couple that are public information. No one of these things sticks out to me as different from the others.
- yibg 6y agoDoesn’t that prevent a lot controversial discussions of those topics? Eg what if these things are true or potentially true? Do we just put a blanket ban on publication?
- africanboy 6y ago> That means not publishing papers, articles or comments to the effect that "women can't do science" I completely agree on the topic, but why shouldn't they be published and disproved by someone else with better arguments? Bad science has always been fought with good science.
- zug_zug 6y ago>> That means not publishing papers, articles or comments to the effect that "women can't do science" or bell curve arguments about some races being less intellectually capable than others. Suppose you manage a school district and you find that, after controlling for socio-economic income, your students' SAT scores are drastically predicted by race. Suppose you don't publish it, because you fear it might be used as fuel for some racist. What if it turns out that a geographic area that happened to correlate with race was getting an inferior water supply with lead in it, and because nobody was willing to look any further, the problem went on for an extra decade before being fixed?
- joshuamorton 6y agoYou've created a false dichotomy. Publishing a study that concludes that racial background correlates with SAT score isn't controversial. Pretty much everyone agrees that this is the case today. Publishing a study that concludes that, because of this, black people are innately less intelligent than others (and not, for example, that environmental or social factors are to account), would be controversial.
- zug_zug 6y ago>> Publishing a study that concludes that racial background correlates with SAT score isn't controversial That's how science should operate. The comment I was responding to seemed to indicate such statements were problematic, even without attributing the cause to innate biology.
- joshuamorton 6y agoIt doesn't though. The GP comment is about (mis)attributing causation. "Women can't do science" and "bell curve arguments about some races being less intellectually capable than others" are both causal arguments. "The SAT exhibits racial bias" is an observational statement. You took the GP's argument about causal misattribution and turned it into one about hiding observational conclusions, but that wasn't present in the original comment.
- zug_zug 6y agoYou very well may have a study that shows women produce a fraction of the science men do, maybe even per-capita, and that's not sexist per your own comment. You agreed it's only sexist if it attributes it to innate biology. I'm done responding to you though because you're tone is confrontational and emotional.
- joshuamorton 6y agoYes, because "women can't do science" and "women produce less scientific output" are different. There first is casual. The second is observational. (I guess you could make a semantic argument that "can't do science" means like "are unable to due to environmental factors" and is thus also ultimately observational, but that's not particularly convincing in the context of scientific research).
- twblalock 6y ago> That means not publishing papers, articles or comments to the effect that "women can't do science" or bell curve arguments about some races being less intellectually capable than others. That is also hounding people out of science. Science is better served when such papers are published, and then are debunked using scientific standards of inquiry. Proving those views wrong is much more powerful than censoring them -- anytime someone puts forward those views we can now say "nope, that's been debunked, here is an article that proves it wrong." Censorship creates a chilling effect on science in general. People will be afraid to do gender or IQ studies. Some of those studies might end up with results that are true, but not politically popular at the time. We should not forget that scientific orthodoxy was racist not that long ago. If scientific journals had been censored in the early 1900s, for example, anti-racist papers would have been suppressed. Today is no different -- many of our current scientific views are likely to be disproved 100 years from now, but only if we allow contrary views to be published.
- eesmith 6y ago> Science is better served when such papers are published Your argument is so broad that you will insist that flat-earth, young-earth creationists ("YEC"s), and other crack-pot pseudosciences be accepted as if they were serious and reasonable. Where should a YEC get to publish their papers? If the paper isn't accepted (because it's contrary to all evidence and has no strong evidence to support it), do you call that decision "censorship"? In 100 years do you expect that we might discover the YECs are right? And yes, people are "afraid" now to do YEC studies because of the effects of being laughed at for crackpot science and denied funding. Thing is, when YECs manage to get something published (sometimes by subterfuge), yes, there are articles debunking them. But that doesn't matter because YECs use the publication itself as evidence that their ideas are accepted as scientific. Their goal is to be treated as an equal ("teach the controversy"), not do good science, and their real audience isn't the scientific readership. We see that as well with "bell curve arguments about some races being less intellectually capable than others", where the goal is not to be intellectually honest (See Shaun's video essay at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UBc7qBS1Ujo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UBc7qBS1Ujo which goes deep into some of the dishonesty) but to provide a veneer of scientific-ness to justify racist policy decisions. Thing is, we do allow contrary views to be published. But they have to be supported by evidence. And the evidence that (for example) "women can't do science" isn't there.
- caffeine 6y ago>> That means not publishing papers, articles or comments to the effect that "women can't do science" or bell curve arguments about some races being less intellectually capable than others. That is also hounding people out of science. I disagree with this: why is it hounding people out of science? Let's say I publish a paper that literally says "Gender/race/whatever can't do science" or "Group X has N points lower IQ than group Y at the mean". Who does that keep out of the field? And how? I think it keeps nobody out of anything. Unlike the cancel-culture playbook (call their boss, name and shame, call the cops citing emotional violence, etc.) publishing a paper like that has virtually no effect on any members of the group in question.
- dbsmith83 6y agoI agree. In fact, the moment someone tells me I can't do something that I want to do is the moment I say "fuck you, watch me"