5 ms·
I wonder if incidents like this will push MS towards open sourcing windows. IDK what their revenue looks like, but I'm guessing that selling the OS isn't as fr
by cogman10 6y ago
I wonder if incidents like this will push MS towards open sourcing windows.
IDK what their revenue looks like, but I'm guessing that selling the OS isn't as front and center as it used to be (from the way they are changing in terms of supporting things like linux).
Even if they keep a pretty tight license around the source, releasing it to the public would earn a lot of good will while potentially finding and fixing security problems.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoI always thought the reason they charged for their OS was due to their anti-trust lawsuit so as to state that they weren't actively trying to dominate the market or something along those lines? Also, OEM operating systems are kind of circumventing that.
- easton 6y agoThe reason I always heard was that there’s tons of binary blobs in Windows they bought from vendors that’d have to be reimplemented (the zip library is the most notable example). Russinovich said never say never though, so I don’t know. https://www.wired.com/2015/04/microsoft-open-source-windows-definitely-possible/ https://www.wired.com/2015/04/microsoft-open-source-windows-...
- acct776 6y agoBeing open source is not correlated with charging licensing fees. It just means you can read the source.
- Jestar342 6y agoSome licenses very explicitly prohibit source distribution/publication.
- ksec 6y ago>I wonder if incidents like this will push MS towards open sourcing windows. What I am thinking as well. Unimaginable if it was 10 years ago, but modern Microsoft seems to be taking a different approach. And Apple desperately need some competition to keep Tim Cook honest.
- sterlind 6y ago(I work for MS but not on Windows.) I don't think Windows will be open-sourced precisely because it's not as important as it used to be. It'd be a ton of work to root out vendor code incompatible with OSS licensing, remove internal dependencies etc. That's not worth it unless we have big plans for Windows to stay relevant, which I have no knowledge of but suspect that we don't. Probably we'll see the most relevant pieces be opened up, like the driver model awhile back.
- cogman10 6y agoSo while not the whole thing, seems like they could open source core pieces like the kernel. That will probably take some code reorg to achieve though so maybe that's why it'll never happen. Last I heard on HN, windows was pretty much just a giant repo with everything in it. That'd have to change for them to release core pieces (If it hasn't already).
- cglong 6y agoFWIW, Microsoft has been slowly shifting some components to OSS (Command Prompt, Windows Terminal, Calculator, WinUI). Disclaimer: work at Microsoft but in Azure
- cogman10 6y agoAs far as community trust goes, MS has been killing it for the last several years. They've done a 180 in terms of being good software citizens. I'm really hopeful that core pieces (such as the kernel) end up hitting the public eye.
- userbinator 6y agoCalculator The horrible new version that is ridiculously huge, phones home, and somehow is slow enough to need a loading screen? I really wish they would've just opened the good one, but you can already find that one in the leaked 2k source...
- rightbyte 6y ago
- robotnikman 6y agoI've heard that one of the major obstacles to open sourcing Windows is that a lot of code in the Windows codebase may be proprietary and owned by companies other than Microsoft. Apparently its also an obstacle for many other closed source programs when it comes to considering a transition to open source
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]