9 ms·
Erdoğan’s censorship now targeting media outlets in Europe
- siculars 6y agoReally looking forward to see how the EU respond here with Turkey vs, say, China or Google or FB. It's just interesting to me how values change depending on whom you're talking to.
- zentiggr 6y agoPolitics is the general relativity of human relations. There is no absolute frame of reference.
- briantakita 6y agoReligion (with Theology/Philosophy) is the absolute frame of reference of human relations.
- zentiggr 6y agoI'm sorry, but with my (admittedly broad and _shallow_) view of religious history, trying to see human relations through the filter of religion seems at least as fluid and relative as politics. So much individual human mucking about with what could be basic universal principles. On one end, people who say that "this version of this written word is God's literal truth" when their version has a known history of edits, blatant rewrites, and translation errors. On the other end, recently started religions (Jainism is the first but not by far the only) that are at least as valid in their core principles but have their own dogma and assumptions. Throw in Quakers etc who believe in a direct personal relationship with their God, and I can't see any consistency except "believe in us, and convince your friends! Their soul is in peril if they aren't with us!"
- Alupis 6y agoErdogan has been a loose canon for a long time, and I suspect is only tolerated because of Turkey's precarious NATO membership.
- Tomte 6y agoNo, because the EU's refugee deal with Turkey is paramount. Without it there are more refugees in Germany (and other "core" EU countries), and the tense political atmosphere tips over.
- foolmeonce 6y agoYes, but given past issues, the German government response is most likely to push/penalize Youtube into no longer helping Erdogan while ignoring any direct confrontation. Yet another YouTube ban in Turkey should work for almost everyone.
- systemvoltage 6y agoWhy aren't neighboring countries like Saudi Arabia, UAE, Iran, Ethiopia, etc. taking in 100% of the refugees? Can someone shed some light about refugee situation around NATO/EU? While humanitarian aspects must be taken care of, I only see refugee situation in Germany as a negative thing. It brings nothing to the country, and in fact brings other nonsense such as religious fundamentalism. These people are not going to assimilate into German culture. Edit: I know you’re downvoting based on political stance. Would be great if we can engage in a discussion. Could you share your thoughts please?
- xxpor 6y agoThat's the same thing people said about the Gastarbeiter in the 70s.
- pjc50 6y ago> Saudi Arabia, UAE, Iran They don't want to, and disregard the human rights of large numbers of people already in the country. > Ethiopia Can't afford to. There is no solution without ending the war, and there's no solution to that without addressing the forces keeping it going. It's like many of the Cold War conflicts, a proxy for wars not being fought with Russia.
- cblconfederate 6y ago> Speaking to the Deutsche Presse-Agentur (dpa), [German Foreign Minister] Maas said: “I do not find the demand of an arms embargo against Turkey strategically correct. It is not easy to do this against a NATO partner. We saw that NATO ally Turkey easily bought missiles from Russia because it could not buy from the U.S.” https://www.dailysabah.com/politics/eu-affairs/german-fm-maas-turns-down-greeces-call-for-arms-embargo-on-turkey https://www.dailysabah.com/politics/eu-affairs/german-fm-maa... > At a summit on Friday, EU leaders agreed to prepare limited sanctions on Turkish individuals over a row with Greece and Cyprus about offshore energy exploration, but postponed discussions on any harsher steps until March. https://www.ekathimerini.com/260286/article/ekathimerini/news/turkey-says-it-wont-abandon-east-med-rights-over-eu-sanctions-threat https://www.ekathimerini.com/260286/article/ekathimerini/new...
- metroholografix 6y agoIt's telling that only an outgoing US administration decided to -weakly- sanction Turkey over the Russian missile fiasco. The European Union looks more and more like a banking cartel than a federation of nation states. Germany and Spain, that vehemently opposed sanctions in the last eurogroup, are doing good business selling weapons to Turkey. Weapons, that are then used by Turkey to openly threaten Greece and Cyprus. There was a slight concession in 2019, with a temporary stop on new contracts being awarded, but that obviously did not affect existing ones.
- SoSoRoCoCo 6y agoIs there any country that makes weapons that doesn't sell them for a hefty profit? Hell, in the past decade the Americans have funded the death of their own troops by selling rocket launchers and bombs to the Saudis that are resold/handed out and used in Afghanistan and Iraq. I recommend the 1980's "Deal of the Century" with Chevy Chase and Gregory Hines. It's a black comedy about the insanity of countries selling weapons to their own enemies.
- aduitsis 6y agoThe Congress cancelling a deal to sell a 100 F-35s along with some of their parts being produced in Turkey hardly sounds like a weak sanction.
- MrMorden 6y agoTurkey's S-400 system was both contracted for and delivered during the Trump administration. We'll see what the US does or doesn't do when the president isn't the weakest since Harrison.
- disown 6y agoWhat values are you speaking of? Censorship is and has been alive and well in germany for a long time. You can even say germany has no conception of free speech, they just mimic it. Germany is the inspiration of censorship around the world. https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/11/06/germany-online-crackdowns-inspired-the-worlds-dictators-russia-venezuela-india/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/11/06/germany-online-crackdow... https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170720/01434337827/russia-does-copy-paste-germanys-new-hate-speech-online-censorship-law.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170720/01434337827/russi...
- grishka 6y agoStop relying on faceless corporations then, use PeerTube.
- m_a_g 6y agoI’m living in Turkey and it’s really ironic that I can’t even access this article. That is the extent of these censorships.
- djeiasbsbo 6y agoI archived it here, hopefully that works: https://web.archive.org/web/20201231175554/https://www.turkishminute.com/2020/12/31/erdogan-censorship-targeting-media-outlets-in-europe/ https://web.archive.org/web/20201231175554/https://www.turki...
- codefined 6y ago> On 9 October 2016, GitHub and Internet Archive[273] were blocked and associated administrative orders were subsequently posted by the BTK stating that access had been officially restricted. Not sure it'll be accessible. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_in_Turkey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_in_Turkey
- prox 6y agoIs there any chance Erdogan will be democratically ousted?
- planetis 6y agoIf you can tolerate a police baton up your anus, hold a rally. :) (I'm referring to human rights reports from 2016, which stated that detainees after the failed coup were sodomized by the police)
- petre 6y agoHardly. He's got a tight grip on the media, imprisoned or silenced most of the opposition, purged the military and the police after the failed coup and has the support of the conservative Turks, which basically granted him a mandate for many years to come. He'll probably end up being president for the rest of his life, just like Franco. Now his ambitions lie beyond the Turkush border into Southern Caucasus and Europe. Europeans should at the very least push back, support their Greek and Cypriot fellow EU members, grant asylum to kemalists, kurds and his other opponents, refuse further blackmail with refugees pouring in.
- planetis 6y agoAfter spending the last year reading about constant warmongering and provocations against my country, with military units on combat alert even on holidays, I only have to say democracy should be reinstated in Turkey and I hope the circumstances can not detriment the friendship and common heritage of Turkish and Greek people.
- planetis 6y agoAnd also someone should care about the Syrian refugees, these people are being used as a pawn to make demands and their rights are violated.
- krastanov 6y agoI appreciate you saying that. I am from the Balkans but from neither of these two countries and I was wondering whether you would say most of the people around you share your view. It is heartwarming to see humanist messages like yours, but I have the impression that much bigger part of the Balkans expresses more jingoistic nationalistic and xenophobic views.
- planetis 6y agoBalkans are a war torn region, I honestly don't share some of my compatriots, idiotic opinions about naming other countries. Although they haven't lived though let's say Sarajevo in the 90s, I hope we all realize, that war isn't the solution to disputes. To answer your question, I try to surround my self with educated people, not dogmatic morons.
- RealityVoid 6y agoI understand your sentiment, but, the flip side is that a strong military is a good safeguard for peace. I have this... Hard to formulate opinion that you should be prepared to prevail in violence but at the same time avoid it as much as possible.
- maxwell 6y ago
- theemptiness 6y agoAt some points, a company (any company) has to assume a legal system. When the legal system does not work well - be it, because the laws require censorship, or be it because not everyone can effectively fight for their rights in the courts - this will lead to problems and injustice. It seems, Turkey is not the only place where it's tough to get copyright claims sorted out in court, but the claim is that the (assumed) legal means are leveraged for going after political opponents. The EU will have to understand that freedom of speech and the legal framework of copyright claims can be at odds and can be abused in this way. This isn't going to be easy, but leaving it to private companies to come up with something will likely not produce the desired outcome as they will all eventually go the path of least resistance and profitability (it's in general not a private company's job to defend values and reform the legal situation).
- bitcharmer 6y agoI have no idea how this dictatorship is even considered for EU membership. Can someone explain this to me?
- Deukhoofd 6y agoIt's not. At the moment all talks about its membership are frozen due to its more and more autocratic rule.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoWhen they were first seriously considering it, it wasn’t a dictatorship; things went seriously downhill in the past several years since then.
- shp0ngle 6y agoThat EU membership was never serious
- pjc50 6y agoThey applied in 1999. They were told what criteria to meet. They have not yet met them. This includes freedom and rule of law criteria. EU accession is not going to happen until Turkey is more like a normal European country.
- mertd 6y agoWhile true, let's not pretend the membership criteria were ever objectively evaluated in Turkey's case. It was always entangled with domestic politics of member countries. And one would wonder if member states like Poland and Hungary would meet such criteria right now.
- jetrink 6y agoIt's hard to believe the process is still going on. I remember on the first day of a class in 2004, the instructor had everyone introduce ourselves. One of the students started with, "Hi, I'm from Turkey. You have probably heard about my country from our lame attempts to join the EU..."
- doener 6y ago"The channel, already under an access ban in Turkey since 2019, was shut down in mid-December and is now inaccessible on YouTube. The Erdoğan government had it shut down using YouTube’s copyright policy."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 6y agoAmericans and the American media complain about how bad Facebook and tech censorship is, and it is bad, but overseas in countries such as turkey it is way worse. Americans truly take for granted the freedoms they have.
- temp472025 6y agoWouldn't taking it for granted be the opposite? The strong response to any perceived attack on freedom of speech shows the value placed in it.
- watermelon59 6y agoI don’t think it’s taken for granted. Those complaints stem from fear of turning into a place like Turkey and other nations with strict censorship. If we don’t complain now, it may be too late later on.
- jorblumesea 6y agoI think Americans are really preoccupied by that kind of stuff, because if we normalize the behavior then we might become a Turkey or Russia some day. Democracy and freedom of press and expression are intrinsically linked. That being said, there's many who talk about "big tech" censorship but ignore some of the other problems of modern big media. So it's not always people who are pro-freedoms bringing this up.
- DanielBMarkham 6y agoThis is a very tricky situation. Two things come to mind. 1. Turkey wants a fight. I keep up on reading the western commentary and analysis about the region (Not the mainstream crap), and it's apparent to me that deeply-entrenched forces in Turkey want a fight. Our strategy so far is to do the best we can to ignore/placate them. I'm not sure how long that continues to work. 2. From time-to-time, we talk on HN about the internet becoming more and more walled off, with commercial ventures preventing competition and nationalistic devices like the Great Firewall of China preventing movement of information. There's not going to be one dramatic moment when we wake up and the net is gone. It's probably mostly gone now, and every day a bit more slips away unnoticed. We talk about and react to stories like this, but there are plenty of similar actions that nobody responds to. It's like Google customer support: the only way to make anything at all happen is to make a big stink, and in the long-run even doing that doesn't matter much to the average net user. I am deeply unhappy and concerned about Turkey's future. I wish there was something I could to to help, but any response at all from the west will be used as political fodder. They're not in a good spot right now.
- psKama 6y agoI don't believe HN is the right place to engage in political discussions but I need to clarify couple of points. > Turkey wants a fight. You need to make clear references about what and who you refer to when you say "Turkey". Even with a totally oppressed media and everything else, Erdogan's support in Turkey is in the band of 30-40%. Majority of Turkish citizens are not happy with him. Western world keeps doing the some mistake (if not on purpose) as they do with Russia, skipping that difference when bringing up all the negativity about him. As Putin, this just helps him solidifying his base, by using this to create a common enemy outside of Turkey. With that said, I don't believe even Erdogan himself wants to have any fight with anyone outside of Turkey but just trying to protect country's interest internationally. That's why although his support is in a band of 30-40%, a solid 85% of Turkish people are supporting his international policies.
- tehwebguy 6y agoYes, thank you. I am not one to mince words but think people make a huge mistake when they talk about what ${country} wants instead of ${country.leader} or ${party}
- istanbul7 6y agoThat website controlled by followers of gulen that killed 250 innocent people in 2016. Can somebody tell me that DAES (ISIS) related main news websites is allowed in Western countries.
- merth 6y agoyou can't come to a western website and drop the fact like that. funny how would HK feel if this was ISIS promoting website on western ban on ISIS propaganda instead of Gulenist one. as western says one mans terrorists, others freedom fighter.
- planetis 6y agoMr, in democratic societies voicing your views is protected by the freedom of speech. However hate speech and extremist groups preaching it should be prosecuted, as criminal organizations. A Jewish philosopher has advocated for this stance (whose name I've forgotten). Are you a sympathizer of this group by any chance? Why do you think it would be beneficial for a person living in a Western country being subjected to extreme violence, intolerance and hate speech?
- merth 6y agostaging coup and killing 250 civilians isn't extreme enough for you?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- threesmegiste 6y agoThere are several youtubers live in turkey, say what they want to say about Erdoğan.
- papichulo4 6y agoSource?
- Aduket 6y agoAtheist turk here, this youtube channel is the largest social media channel of gulen religious sect/terror group, which tried to topple erdogan in 2016. Despite hating Erdogan to my guts, i can assure you that this gulenist movement/terror group is a bigger threat to secularism and democracy in turkey and world alike.
- goda90 6y agoThere's a lot of doubt internationally that Gulen was behind the coup attempt. And there are some that believe it was a false flag operation to allow Erdogan to solidify his power.
- YinLuck- 6y agoThere's a lot of doubt internationally whether the Earth is flat or round...
- alisonatwork 6y agoI find this to be one of the most insidious side-effects of press censorship under authoritarian regimes - it seems to create an ecosystem of resistance media that is just as biased as the government propaganda. A similar thing happens with China through stuff like Epoch Times or Guo Wengui's channel. The outlets that position themselves as strong opposition to the regime are themselves untrustworthy sources, which ironically just serves to bolster the position of the regime. ("See? You can't trust anything! Even in so-called free countries all the news is fake!" etc) Do you have any recommendations for media organizations that are doing reliable reporting on Turkey but aren't propaganda fronts for one faction or the other?
- pjc50 6y agoYeah, this was a serious problem in Egypt where the post-Arab Spring elected goverment was less liberal than the military dictatorship.
- cblconfederate 6y agothat's why you need open media, so all sides can be heard, and frankly exposed for what they are
- turkishguy34 6y agoIf you inspect the article and its author, you can easily see that its author Yasin Kesen is a member of FETO ( Fetullah Gulen's Terrorist Organization ) and he is run off from Turkey to Germany just before than 15 July coup attempt ( in this attempt, FETO is killed more than 300 innocent civil person in streets, bridges and homes. They misilled bombs from airplanes, they attacked also TBMM (Grand National Assembly of Turkey). People are mashed by tanks pallets in streets. He is a terrorist organization member and writing disparagement posts. They tried to get the governance, but failed. Their commanders give command to their pilots and tank drivers: "Kill everybody that moves. No pity. Just kill". And their friend in a foreign country writes something to calumniate the legally voted governence.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoA lot of us think that if it was a real coup attempt that the mastermind was Erdogan. Infiltrate the coup plotters and trigger a hopeless coup.
- eternalban 6y agoI can't reach any Iranian website from NYC. DNS does not resolve. Is this "targeting media outlets"? https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.presstv.com/Detail/2020/04/25/623910/Iran-newspaper-treasury-department-ofac-block https://www.google.com/url?q=https://www.presstv.com/Detail/... Google is allowed to look at Iranian [headlines] and they have this teaser: "US's Treasury Dept. blocks, seizes website of 'Iran ... - PressTV" "Apr 25, 2020 · Tried before 204.155.146.233 and other addresses that point to PressTV but in the look up translate pointer table it blocks the ip address that ..." Oh, I love the smell of irony, even in the afternoon..
- boraoztunc 6y agoOK I will try to explain really what's going on and how it feels to live in Turkey, and try my best to keep this as objective as possible, besides my personal opinions. First of all, democracy is not happening, at all. If you have any opposite thoughts, yes thoughts, not actions, you can face real jail time. This can be a comment on Twitter, or even something you say in your neighbourhood, around friends, anything and anywhere. No cartoons, no essays, no personal blogs. You can have an pollice officer in your door knocking. We have a big website called "eksisozluk" which motto was "sacred source of knowledge", and now is filled with entries, posts regulated and restricted with court orders, deleted accounts, and also imprisoned users. Turkey blocked Youtube, Wikipedia and such websites for a very long time. Paypal is still not operating. Even they seem not related, everything is related. Journalists are in prison, some of them are in exile, or some even dead. Sorry for not revealing news or links, because of time, but Google can do that for me in an instance. So go ahead and search. They are doing everything in their power to succeed. And I believe this will go on for a long time.
- threesmegiste 6y agoTurkey first blocked youtube for insulting videos about Atatürk.
- Nginx487 6y agoHate to see how easily monopolistic services like YouTube give up basic human rights, in order to please tyrants, who's in solo charge of accessing to the market, which YouTube does not want to lose. I witnessed multiple shutdowns of accounts, criticizing Russian regime. No explanation was provided, like Google always does. Selling ads is more important, than life and freedom of people.
- YinLuck- 6y agoTurkey has the misfortune of having its English-speaking jet set tilting so heavily in one political direction. Because of this, all the international community hears about/from Turkey is that the sky is falling due to Erdogan... It takes a keen reader to realize that these same English speaking Turks have been screaming about the sky falling for the past 17 years... Full disclosure: I support Erdogan and I readily compare him to other "so-called" dictators like Orban in Hungary. I highlight "so-called" because these "dictators" routinely win their elections and are otherwise constrained by rival political factions. For example: Erdogan's recent shift to an aggressive foreign policy is not due to the swinging moods of a dictator, but his alliance with a smaller far-right parliamentary party whose votes he needs to keep his ruling coalition. Turkish democracy is weak, it always has been. Prior to Erdogan Turkish democracy wasn't Norway. It was more like Egypt. As imperfect as it is now, I can only think of Israel as having a more functional system in our region.
- OpticalWindows 6y agoHe seems dead set on buying into the chinese model of governance, russian military hardware, and larger regional ambitions. All of those still seem to be out of his grasp.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoIt's obvious why You-Tube allows them access to the content system. It's the price of being allowed to operate there at all.