4 ms·
This is a good point. Renewable energy is getting so cheap that throwing kWh away can be cheaper than the cost of idling other capital infrastructure. We will
by epistasis 6y ago
This is a good point. Renewable energy is getting so cheap that throwing kWh away can be cheaper than the cost of idling other capital infrastructure.
We will need to rethink a lot of our economic assumptions in energy very soon. Solar farms are already designed to produce 30% more DC energy than their inverters can handle, because it's the lowest cost balance between PV panel capacity and inverter capacity. If somebody has an application for DC energy that can be co-located at solar farms behind inverters, and can be economical running only a few hours a day, there's huge amounts of nearly free energy already available.
- mamon 6y ago>> Renewable energy is getting so cheap that throwing kWh away can be cheaper than the cost of idling other capital infrastructure. That's missing the point.The problem isn't "what to do with excess of energy at peak times?", it's "where do we get energy from on quiet, wind-less nights?" Solar and wind are highly unreliable, so storing energy for is the necessity. Or we can use nuclear.
- epistasis 6y agoWho was making this point that I supposedly missed? Where we are in the conversation, your problem has already been addressed, and part of the solution has been to overprovision renewable generation such that we have excess electricity at many times, amounting to 50% to 200% of current electricity usage. The problem you discuss has been addressed with tons of predictions and models. It's solvable with excess generation capacity, storage, and transmission capacity. Which path we choose will depend on the relative dollar costs and political costs of each. (For example HVDC transmission would likely save us lots of money, but is so difficult politically that it is unlikely to happen.) But in any case, nearly all models show that under nearly all cost scenarios, we end up with lots of excess generation capacity, with curtailed renewables generation for a large chunk of time. This is the future we are talking about, a future where we are meeting our energy demands with all renewables, and we have lots of excess generation capacity with zero marginal cost.
- mamon 6y ago>> It's solvable with excess generation capacity, storage, and transmission capacity So now you're arguing FOR energy storage? Your previous post was basically: "let's overprovision and let excessive energy go to waste, instead of building costly storage infrastructure.".
- epistasis 6y agoWe will have a mixture of storage, over-provisioned generation, and transmission, the only question is the relative proportion. And that relative proportion will be determined by how quickly costs fall relative to each other. If a kWh storage costs 10x the amortized capital costs of a kWh solar generation, we will have a lot less storage than if storage only costs 2x the amortized capital costs of a solar kWh. If hydrogen electrolysis can become cheap in 2030, maybe we will even use hydrogen for some storage, but we will have to balance the capital costs of hydrogen generation and conversion back to electricity with everything else, which will determine how much of it gets deployed.
- mamon 6y agoIt's not only about cost, it's also about practicality: there is some baseline demand on electricity even at night. Solar obviously cannot fulfill that demand. Wind also can't because it is too unreliable. So we do need some storage technology, and hydrogen is one of the options. It seems way cheaper than using Lithium-Ion batteries, but might be still more expensive than, say, pumping water uphill and using that to power a hydroelectric plant. Energy transmission can be some solution here, but we might be forced to transmit energy across the continents (so, for example solar plant in Sahara delivers power to New York City at night) which probably is too costly.
- Robotbeat 6y agoI actually think "curtailment" is not throwing away electricity any more than not running a natural gas power plant 24/7 is. The only difference is the natural gas plant has fuel costs and the solar doesn't. But both are big capital investments, so you could argue you're "throwing away" electricity you could've generated with that natural gas plant by not running it all the time. Anyway, just my little contribution to how we think about curtailment. If you have a good grid connection and optimal storage, then you don't end up needing that much curtailment (say 30%), although some is basically always optimal. See: https://model.energy https://model.energy Oh, also, under-sizing the inverter relative to the solar array DC capacity is not even close to a one-to-one curtailment example. The solar rarely makes its peak power rating, so undersizing the inverter by 25% means almost no curtailment in the real world. Effectively, you're increasing the AC capacity factor and it almost perfectly compensates (until you get very high ratios, but even then the amount actually curtailed is small). This has a bigger impact in places that have more cloudy or overcast weather. If you install more solar panels (which are a much smaller part of the total cost of the project than they used to be), you can compensate for not having as much sun without much increase in cost.
- rowland66 6y agoBitcoin mining?
- Aaronstotle 6y agoMight as well, good way to burn excess energy imo. CPU mining for other cryptos would work as well (XMR comes to mind)
- RhodoYolo 6y agocrypto mining, or stacking bricks with a crane.
- beerandt 6y ago"Surplus" capture/use is a bigger problem than most people realize, not just for solar, but throughout the entire energy economy. There's a reason you still see so many flare-offs in the petroleum industries, even though it's always been "burning dollars" and is now usually discouraged via imposed regulatory costs. Yet it still makes economic sense in many situations. Why would people invest capital in capture technology that only gets used a fraction of the time? Whether it be at a solar plant, or a refinary, people will choose to invest that capital where it's use can be maximized. There are certainly situations where it makes sense economically, but many where it doesn't, and more situations where the capital can be better spent elsewhere. Similarly, if a hypothetical town gets 15kw solar power during the day, and 15kw of hydro or wind during night, and needs 20kw backup/surge capacity from gas/nuclear/other, you've designed a system that requires a surplus of capacity, not just in generation, but also in transmission and distribution. In that context, surplus==inefficiencies. This can be somewhat minimized by so-called smart-grid technology, but people tend to focus on technical capabilities and not what makes economical sense, which is much more limiting than people realize.