5 ms·
I wasn’t sure it was sarcasm to be honest! I’ve seen more insane comments on HN posted with 100% seriousness and conviction.
by ryandrake 6y ago
I wasn’t sure it was sarcasm to be honest! I’ve seen more insane comments on HN posted with 100% seriousness and conviction.
- ineedasername 6y agoI tried to keep it right on the edge... I find that provokes more critical thought than letting people "off the hook" with a more obvious comment they can automatically agree/disagree with. It's easy to dismiss examples as "absurd" when a concept is taken to its logical conclusion. It's the ones that walk right up to the edge, to the gray area boundaries of someone's conceptual framework, that make them consider what those boundaries are or should be.
- xref 6y agoYour comment is the same superficial “hey I’m just asking questions!” deflection that a lot of lazy intellectualism resorts to. “Maybe eugenics is a good idea because we can create a biologically superior human, we should at least discuss it!”
- loopz 6y agoNo, his post require thought, which is not immediately obvious. Thus it gets ignored or dv. It's just a reaction to the free market magical chimp thinking out there.
- ineedasername 6y agoConsidering it's a form of economics that a sizeable portion of HN think is best, it is not at all equivalent to randomly bringing up a topic that has long been held by most of society to be a bad idea and saying "just asking the question!". It is broaching the topic in a way that doesn't automatically get upvoted by people who agree with it, or automatically downvoted by those who disagree. I also wasn't asking a question. I was giving an actual example of the consequences of the economic system many HN'ers believe in.
- ineedasername 6y agoas another aside, this seems to be a problem with modern discourse in general. In multiple arenas I see pendulums swinging so far to one side or another that what might have been seen as satire or parody not long ago now has to be considered as someone's serious commentary on a topic. Pendulums can't keep swinging further & further without destabilizing the entire fulcrum & structure. To stretch the metaphor further, I hope as they're on the down stroke this time around we can put a little bit of equal & opposite force against their inertia.