9 ms·
> And it's fairer in that the burden is shared collectively rather than just by some industries. This is where we disagree. Companies that employ workers belo
by arcticbull 6y ago
> And it's fairer in that the burden is shared collectively rather than just by some industries.
This is where we disagree.
Companies that employ workers below subsistence wages are actually being indirectly subsidized collectively by every single taxpayer.
Those underpaid employees are the ones who then go on to collect public benefits to make up the difference between survival and their take-home pay, and those benefits come out of our tax dollars.
Allowing employers to pay below subsistence wages is corporate welfare.
All this bill does is tip the scales back to where they need to be: if you as a business are not paying a living wage to your employees, you're effectively forcing the taxpayer to pay the part of the salary you're not interested in paying.
This is also the interest the state has in the matter, as not doing so negatively impacts the state.
No more mooching.
> Goldman Sachs doesn't get hurt by a minimum wage, but small business owners, such as those running a convenience store, do.
And I'm sorry but those businesses wouldn't exist without the government passively subsidizing them by providing benefits to the workers they're stiffing.
If these are the kinds of businesses we want more of, it should be via an explicit, active subsidy program. If not, they will have to go out of business or find a way to make the economics work. That's capitalism.
- rtx 6y agoIf you are not paying more then you are making more. It will comeback to the society as taxes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- trickstra 6y agoIt would, if the money wasn't being sent away and laundered (did Panama Papers not teach us anything?) or if the taxes weren't "forgiven" like in the case of Amazon or even the $750 Trump taxes. Practice shows that it doesn't come back, no matter how well it sounds in theory.
- smt88 6y ago> It will comeback to the society as taxes. It should, but it doesn't. Amazon is a classic example. Despite being the beneficiaries of many types of corporate welfare (including paying some full-time employees so poorly that they had to be on welfare), Amazon has paid $0 in tax a few times. In fact, there is no meaningful relationship between Amazon's profits and taxes. Their profits go up, and sometimes their taxes actually go down[1]. 1. https://www.washingtonpost.com/resizer/fWL3rv40cvsIPAqSvf1wzRPl44A=/arc-anglerfish-washpost-prod-washpost/public/UC2UWT4MENA4DLABR2MZUK4X2I.png https://www.washingtonpost.com/resizer/fWL3rv40cvsIPAqSvf1wz...
- throwaway09223 6y agoNo, their revenues go up not their profits. I understand you have a link with the word "profits." WaPo is misusing the term. Profits are revenues after expenses and the numbers in that graph are not taking certain expenses into account. When the expenses are taken into account the profit drops to zero. Specifically, one of the big expenses deducted before calculating tax was liquidation of employee stock options. And guess what? Instead of being taxed at the corporate income tax rate those options were taxed as individual income for the employees who exercised them -- an even higher rate! In your example the gains were in fact taxed. The tax was just applied in a different place than where you're happening to look.
- smt88 6y agoThank you for explaining profits to me. I'm glad you did so long after I went to business school, because your description of this situation is mostly wrong. > WaPo is misusing the term. Profits are revenues after expenses and the numbers in that graph are not taking certain expenses into account. "Profit" is not a defined term. It's shorthand for something else, usually gross profit, operating profit, or net income. For 2018, AMZN had gross profit of $93B, operating profit of $12B, and net income of $11.6B. The WaPo numbers in the graph use one of the latter two figures, so the graph is absolutely correct. It is NOT revenue in the graph, and their profits have absolutely gone up. Do you honestly think an edited and widely read paper like WaPo is going to make an incredibly basic accounting mistake in their business section? > In your example the gains were in fact taxed. No, they weren't. Most of Amazon's shares are not held by employees. Taxing employees is not solving the core issue that everyone is upset about, which is that Amazon (taken either as an entity or as its owners, most of whom are not employees) is paying close to 0% taxes. Period. That's it. No one is arguing whether the activity surrounding Amazon generates tax revenue. That's outside the scope of the argument.
- cltby 6y agoYou’re not subsidizing minimum-wage companies. You’ve decided that workers should enjoy an arbitrarily high standard of living but are unwilling to shoulder the full costs of providing it (e.g. through taxes). Instead, you went to the ballot box and kicked those costs to corporations. The minimum-wage companies are subsidizing you.
- arcticbull 6y agoA living wage for an individual with no children in King County, Washington is $16.09 per hour worked. If you pay less than that, the government via entitlement programs makes up the difference. That's corporate welfare, and this bill goes a long way to addressing that. [1] If employers do not pay enough that their employees require the use of zero entitlement programs, they are mooching off the state in the amount of the entitlement programs their employees consume. I'd be open to, instead of raising the minimum wage, having the state bill employers to recover the cost of entitlement programs they had to provide for their employees. [1] https://livingwage.mit.edu/counties/53033 https://livingwage.mit.edu/counties/53033
- cltby 6y agoThere's plenty of fat in this budget. The hypothetical worker in your link might consider increasing his labor supply beyond eight hours a day. Maybe he could forego his biannual iPhone upgrade. He might even cut his consumption of high-dollar first world medical care. Now, I understand you think these are all things that, as a matter of decency, our citizens should have. That's great! Then pay for it, and stop saddling everyone else with the costs of your morality.
- arcticbull 6y agoTake it up with MIT, not me. I'm sure they'd love to hear your theories about how fridges aren't necessities in the winter :) I take it you're an expert in living wage calculation? For what it's worth when I reviewed their methodology, as I suggest you do, I didn't see a line-item for "biannual iPhone upgrade." [1] And re: medical care, I'm sure you know someone making $12/hr can't afford to set foot in a hospital in America. For a single-income household of 2 parents and a child, the threshold for Medicaid eligibility is $15/hr. As a taxpayer, I retort, stop saddling me with the bill for the employees time you're consuming but refusing to pay for. If their services are that important to you, I'm sure you can pay what it costs without forcing me to split it with you. As a fine upstanding participant in this nation's economy, I'm confident you'll find a way. Maybe forego that biannual iPhone upgrade ;) [1] https://livingwage.mit.edu/resources/Living-Wage-Users-Guide-Technical-Documentation-2020.pdf https://livingwage.mit.edu/resources/Living-Wage-Users-Guide...
- missedthecue 6y agoSubsidizing low skill workers so that they are able to get work and acquire skills and experience is a good thing. Why must you say it with such a negative tone?
- arcticbull 6y agoI agree 100%. However, doing it through this weird reach-around where you have to make low-income earners a public charge (based on the immigration terminology) while subsidizing only the companies that pay so little as to require it - isn't IMO a rational approach. Have you seen how arduous Medicaid is? Food stamps? That's not a vocational training program, that's a punishment for being poor while having a system set up explicitly to make you poor. After all, this is not subsidizing the individuals, it's subsidizing the business. It's a blunt instrument right now. Just paying minimum wage doesn't guarantee any sort of education or training. What corner store offers education and training programs? The rational approach is to make companies pay a living wage as a baseline, and then if you want to encourage certain behaviors - like educational training, for instance - offer tax credits and rebates. Or, if you want to subsidize specific low value added businesses like corner stores, subsidize them directly. Begin with a baseline of livability, and then, if the company wants to go above and beyond, reward them for doing so.
- missedthecue 6y agoCorner stores don't need to be providing higher education to employees in order to be giving them skills. Basic jobs provide plenty of skills and lessons that cannot be learned while sitting at home, such as dealing with customers, time management, and basic problem solving in a work environment. I think the better option is to guarantee a minimum wage through a subsidy, while abolishing all minimum wage laws. Like a negative income tax. So let's say you earn $12 stocking shelves, the government should subsidize $4 per hour to give you a total income of $16 per hour. If you make $15/hr, they subsidize $1. If you make $20, they subsidize zero. In this way, the downsides of minimum wages are avoided (cutting back on hours, laying people off, raising prices, and pricing low skill people out of the workforce), while still allowing a decent income for anyone working full time. You can tax the subsidy at a higher rate than your normal tax rate, so that businesses are still dealing with competitive market incentives and cannot pay a $1/hr leaving the remainder to the government, and so that employees are always incentivized to take the highest paying job. If you run the numbers, providing every employee in america with a $16 minimum wage, working 40 hours per week, and assuming the average employee making less than $16 makes $12, would cost $500 billion per year. This is not an out of reach policy.
- scarface74 6y agoPrivate America shouldn’t be responsible for providing a livable wage. The government should be. Just tax private corporations enough to pay for it.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y agoSome taxes are more expensive than others because they dampen more economic activity. Corporate income taxes are one of the worst. To illustrate by example, if you were to directly tax investment activity $1 per trade, you'd kill almost exactly $1 of GDP. Nothing would be gained. Land value taxes and VATs, it turns out, are some of the best because they're inexpensive and largely non-distortionary, and personal income taxes are somewhere in between.
- arwhatever 6y agoIt seems this logic could just as easily be used assert that entitlement programs should be reduced to match minimum wage, just as well as raising minimum wage to reach parity with entitlement programs. I'm not saying we should; but it seems like there's some other component that needs to be added to your logic, and a quick brainstorm by my non-economist brain doesn't seem to be able to fill it in.
- XorNot 6y agoSure you could do that, cause a bunch of people to be evicted, the homeless rate would go up, the crime rate would go up, you'd have problems with disease due to poor hygeine and hospital costs due to those homeless only turning up in emergency when it was an emergency due to EMTALA. Then "something must be done" so you could spend a bunch of money building more jails, imprisoning and murdering a bunch of these people via law enforcement and the net result would be a society where somehow Americans decided that the most important thing to them was the profit margins of billionaires and Uber rather then being able to walk down the street without getting mugged or smelling human effluent. The classic American thinking on welfare and labor relations: that surely there's no other possible reasons to do these things.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Companies that employ workers below subsistence wages are actually being indirectly subsidized collectively by every single taxpayer. Companies that employ workers at any pay that reduces their public benefit entitlement are subsidizing every single taxpayer, not the other way around.
- petre 6y agoThe workers are, out of their pockets, not the companies. The companies just enable it.
- LudwigNagasena 6y ago> Companies that employ workers below subsistence wages are actually being indirectly subsidized collectively by every single taxpayer. I don’t see what leads you to this conclusion. It seems self-evident that people who get paid need less government-provided (ie taxpayer-provided) benefits.
- XorNot 6y agoWalmart's workers cost the public $6.2 billion (https://www.forbes.com/sites/clareoconnor/2014/04/15/report-walmart-workers-cost-taxpayers-6-2-billion-in-public-assistance/?sh=6f07422f720b https://www.forbes.com/sites/clareoconnor/2014/04/15/report-...) in welfare. Some of this is food stamps. Which Walmart bills the government for when food is bought from their stores using them. Walmart moving into a small town and driving a bunch of small business's out doesn't make anything more efficient, it literally costs the taxpayer more, of which a bunch of that goes to Walmart's owners as revenue.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoWalmart would be employing these workers even without them receiving welfare. Have you ever lived in a developing country? If you have, you'd know how little people can subsist on and continue to work. In fact, without welfare, and programs like SSDI - which when it started in the 1950s, accepted only 200,000 people as a result of strict eligibility requirements, and has since grown into a massive social welfare program with over 10 million beneficiaries - far more people would be applying for the jobs offered by Walmart.
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoAre you saying that if Walmart fired these workers the budget would increase by $6 bln? If not then it is just a highly misleading statistic bordering on intentional misinformation.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoEssentially, over time. If you could also prevent other existing competitors from offering Wallmart-level pay or worse. In this scenario, the demand for groceries didn't disappear - just Wallmart did, and now there's all these ex-Wallmart people looking for a job. New grocery stores would form, and if they paid enough to get these people off welfare, that would be (per GP) $6B of money freed to be allocated elsewhere. Food prices could raise a little bit, though, and food variety could get reduced (but these are not necessarily bad in the balance).
- philwelch 6y ago> Those underpaid employees are the ones who then go on to collect public benefits to make up the difference between survival and their take-home pay, and those benefits come out of our tax dollars. If those workers were capable of earning enough money to no longer be eligible for public benefits, they would choose to take those jobs instead. But they aren’t, so they don’t. If they didn’t have the option of working low-wage jobs and supplementing that income with public assistance, they would be unemployed and completely dependent on public assistance. In other words, it is low-wage employers who subsidize the taxpayer, not the other way around.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> If those workers were capable of earning enough money to no longer be eligible for public benefits, they would choose to take those jobs instead. But they aren’t, so they don’t. The jobs available on the market aren't continuously and uniformly distributed on the pay axis between $0 to ${whatever corporate CEOs take home}. Most people can't marginally improve their pay by marginally improving their capabilities. > If they didn’t have the option of working low-wage jobs and supplementing that income with public assistance, they would be unemployed and completely dependent on public assistance. Not if they had an option of working higher-wage jobs. The market pushes salaries down as much as it's allowed. Apply some upward pressure, and the market just may find it in its heart to pay more for the same job.
- dxdm 6y ago> If those workers were capable of earning enough money to no longer be eligible for public benefits, they would choose to take those jobs instead. It seems weird to me to accept it quasi as a law of nature that large parts of the population get paid below subsistence level for their work, often doing physically or emotionally hard labor, while others earn big in bullshit-rich environments. I get that we need some sort of market for effective allocation of resources. But seeing how rich western societies are as a whole, while still giving many of their members trouble with feeding themselves, housing and (in some countries) getting adequate medical care, makes me wonder how far we've really come with finding a good way to distribute wealth adequately. Saying that "the market forces" don't allow people to make enough money to get by seems like such a cop-out to me. Yes, public benefits are a way of redistributing wealth for a better outcome, but let's not forget that the market is a human creation and we can influence how it operates in multiple ways. If public benefits subsidize cheap labor in exchange for cheaper consumer prices, that is (as has been pointed out) a way of shifting some of the price off the product to be paid via taxes, externalizing some of the cost to the general public, incurring a human cost on the people who provide the labor, while allowing private investors to take a share of the transfer as their profit. I don't know if that's the most effective way of distributing resources here, but let's not forget that we might not only want to optimize for money making potential here, but also for harder to price things like the pursuit of happiness.
- darawk 6y ago> Companies that employ workers below subsistence wages are actually being indirectly subsidized collectively by every single taxpayer. This is a very common and very wrong interpretation. Taxpayers aren't subsidizing the company. Taxpayers are subsidizing themselves. In a competitive market (which all low wages jobs are in) the employer will simply pass on those savings to the consumer. Uber passes them on to riders, Walmart passes them on to shoppers, etc. There is no subsidy to the corporation. The subsidy is to society at large, which is exactly appropriate for tax money to fund. Uber isn't going to experience margin compression in Seattle as a result of this. All they're going to do is raise their prices. The equilibrium effect of that is two-fold: 1. Fewer rides 2. More cost to Uber's customers Uber will make less money, but only as a result of the loss of volume. They will not be making more or less money per ride. There will just be fewer rides. That's it.
- beowulfey 6y agoWhile true so long as this is only happening in Seattle, if this kind of legislation were to spread Uber would definitely start seeing margin compression.
- BMSmnqXAE4yfe1 6y agoUber's cost per ride is exactly zero. So they WILL make more per ride. Of course, there will be fewer rides, as more people will choose car or public transportation. They will probably lose overall.
- massysett 6y agoWhat is there always this assumption in wage law debates that employers have unilateral ability to “just raise their prices” and “pass costs on to the consumer”? There are plenty of other possibilities. It is also possible that the company will suffer reduced profits. Indeed, if the marketplace truly is competitive, the employer takes the price the marketplace offers. The employer can’t simply arbitrarily set prices any more than a corn farmer can show up at the grain elevator and demand a price for his corn. Economists like to talk about the invisible hand of the free market setting prices, but somehow when the minimum wage is being debated many economists toss the invisible hand into the trash heap and start saying that businesses can set whatever price they want and for some reason the market will simply bear it. I’m not saying minimum wage laws are a good idea, but economists have no credibility when they won’t even allow for the possibility that wage laws might reduce corporate profits rather than leading to increased prices.