10 ms·
Regardless of whether you like Flash, this should be yet another ominous warning that you do not really own your computer anymore. It's one thing to shut down
by userbinator 6y ago
Regardless of whether you like Flash, this should be yet another ominous warning that you do not really own your computer anymore.
It's one thing to shut down servers used by an online service (and there's already plenty of disgust about that), it's something else entirely to essentially reach into everyone's machines and delete what they don't want! Imagine if Microsoft decided to attempt to wipe all traces of MS-DOS from existence --- this is similar, in that people have spent countless hours of effort and built lots of "applications" upon the platform, and while they would not expect the original company will "support" that eternally, they expect it to still be usable.
No doubt there will be something in the EULA that lets them do this, but I still think it's crossing a line.
The frog continues to boil slowly...
- Grimm1 6y agoOkay but you can't have that way and then have the liability rest on the company for recompense in the case of a vulnerability. That's why this has gone this way because of the threat of being sued.
- SimeVidas 6y agoYou’d have a point if Flash Player was paid software.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoThere are still ways of playing flash for those who truly need to. https://lightspark.github.io/ https://lightspark.github.io/
- voldacar 6y agoYeah but thats not the parent's point. The problem isn't a lack of ability to play .swf files, it's about the user's control over his machine
- protoman3000 6y agoCan you on your own machine run your own bootloader and execute whatever instruction you would like to execute? If yes, what’s your point?
- EvanAnderson 6y agoFor an increasing number of devices the answer to your first question is no. We've already normalized the idea that a significant market percentage of small-form-factor battery-operated general purpose computers don't actually belong to the people who bought them. We're a hair's breadth away from normalizing that idea with personal computers.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoI should be the one to decide when my computer stops being able to do something it could already do. The default should be that I do nothing and my computer continues to be able to do what it already did. It's wrong every time I have to do something to allow my computer to continue doing something it already did. This is why I have to be exceedingly careful not to install updates on those dwindling platforms where I still have that control. I have no idea what features are going to be removed, and usually have no way to get them back. (Hello e-fuses in the Nintendo Switch, or Apple no longer signing old iOS releases to prevent downgrading.) We should not normalize the idea that third-parties can take away the capabilities of devices we own. Edit: I would go so far as to say that it should be illegal for a device manufacturer to prevent you from reinstalling any old firmware onto a device you own. (Yes, yes-- I know that we're getting into the whole "But that old device firmware has security bugs! Think of the Internet!" discussion. Liability, both for device manufacturers and for device owners, is a conversation we need to have too.)
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoDevil's advocate- as long as that feature is there Microsoft has an obligation to support it. The feature has fallen out of use. Why should Microsoft be forced to support this forever? You're free to stop updating Windows right?
- EvanAnderson 6y agoWhat does "support" mean? Let the feature continue working has it has. Sure. Yeah. You shipped the code. It exists forever. You don't get to take it away later because it's not in your business interests. Fix bugs? I'll pay for that if I want that. Software is a service. They shouldn't be obligated to fix bugs for free (unless they agreed to that in a contract). With Windows 10 I'm not free to stop updating Windows if I want a computer connected to the Internet. Microsoft does dirty tricks to make if very difficult for me from completely stopping the update treadmill. They've shown that it's an arms race, too. I can't possibly keep up with that opponent.
- 6y ago
- merb 6y agothere is also ruffle, but it does not have as3 support :-(
- type0 6y agoIt is yet another ominous warning about the dangers of proprietary software
- kungito 6y agoCan't you install an older version of Windows (like 7 or XP) to use older deprecated software? At some point we need to let the old stuff dissappear from main branch
- throwaway201103 6y agoDoesn't that rapidly become impossible if you don't already have the installation media? Where would I get a (legitimate/safe) copy of Windows XP at this point?
- userbinator 6y agoarchive.org can help.
- stretchcat 6y agoAn ominous warning that you no longer own your computer, or the inevitable consequence of you never owning this proprietary software in the first place?
- rcoveson 6y agoMy bias is definitely to agree with this sentiment, but I'm going to play devil's advocate: Windows 10 automatically updates itself, which is a reasonable thing for a consumer operating system to do. It happens to be a very "wide and deep" OS which includes a lot of userland stuff as part of the same release bundle, like OS X/macOS. There are FOSS projects that also operate this way. The GNOME environment comes to mind as a similarly "wide and deep" example. I myself have had the experience of having a GNOME feature I was using removed after an update. The recourse in that case isn't much different from the recourse in the Windows 10 Flash case. You can either live without the removed thing or find a third party solution. What you can't do is just stop updating the thing; you'd lose (community) support and important bug fixes. Of course, as long as it's FOSS you can just fork it, right? But really that's not the appropriate solution for cases like this. We're talking about the removal of a basically stand-alone feature. If the official bundle stops supporting that thing, forking the bundle is not the way forward. Bringing in a third party is. So the way I see it, both the problem and the solution here are the same for both Windows and large FOSS software bundles like GNOME. They're the opposite of narrow projects, so stuff is bound to get removed eventually. You can't stay on an old version, you shouldn't fork, and in some cases you probably shouldn't even protest, as the reasoning for removal may be sound.
- throwaway201103 6y ago> What you can't do is just stop updating the thing That's the choice being argued. You should have that option. It's unreasonable to expect that old software will always be supported. There is a real cost to it. But as long as I still have the machine it should be my choice as to when it no longer does the things I need it to do (at least until the point of physical failure).
- rcoveson 6y agoI didn't mean it that way. I meant to point out that you're stuck between a rock and a hard place whether you're a GNOME user or Windows 10 user. It's possible to stop updating, but you probably can't, because you probably need something in some Windows or GNOME release down the road.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThis has been the case since Google Chrome. If you tolerated Chrome and it's "evergreen browser" behavior, you supported the process that eventually became software developers' assumption that they should update themselves without permission on their schedules, and retire and remove features with regularity. In 2020, we no longer have a right to act surprised about this, because we should've done something to fight it a long time ago.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoI broke that functionality in Chrome so I could control when it updated. I didn't accept it. I won't accept it. I would encourage others not to accept it. I will abandon platforms that take away my control. That's not tenable for a lot of people. There's just a lot of "cool stuff" that I don't get to use if there isn't a Free solution. I deal with it. I hate it, but I deal with it.
- JadeNB 6y ago> I broke that functionality in Chrome so I could control when it updated. I didn't accept it. I won't accept it. I would encourage others not to accept it. > I will abandon platforms that take away my control. If you are still using Google Chrome, then it sounds like you will work to avoid the limitations of platforms that take away your control, which is very different from avoiding them.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoI did not accept Chrome's "evergreen" functionality-- I didn't say that I don't use Chrome. I continue to use various hobbled Chrome versions when circumstances dictate. I use Firefox when I can. I wish I didn't need Chrome from time to time. If my underlying OS prevents me from hobbling Chrome I'll ultimately have to abandon Chrome (and probably the OS).
- RandallBrown 6y agoThis is also how websites work.
- protoman3000 6y agoImagine if OS vendors and Intel decided to attempt to install microcode updates that fix severe vulnerabilities on your machine and essentially reach into everyone’s machines and delete what they don’t want! The frog continues to boil slowly...
- Roritharr 6y agoImagine if the President told the NSA to remove every copy of a file. the pathway you've described would be potentially viable to reach a large majority of files in storage someplace. Terrifying thought.
- rightbyte 6y agoChild's play compared to add data to a specific file ...
- protoman3000 6y agoHave always this piece handy https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~rdriley/487/papers/Thompson_1984_ReflectionsonTrustingTrust.pdf https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~rdriley/487/papers/Thompson_1984_Ref...
- cesarb 6y ago> remove every copy of a file I vaguely recall that this (or something similar) was one of the worries about Palladium/NGSCB back in the day.
- matsemann 6y agoIf they didn't, people would instead lament them how their OS is unsafe. Removing or disabling unsafe programs is a security feature, almost as if detecting malware.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoThen let's talk liability. Nobody comes and takes away your car if you fail to have safety-related recalls performed. You might face significant liability if you cause injury as a result of ignoring a recall. I am perfectly fine with a world in which end user companies or individuals assume liability when they fail to adhere to a manufacturer's prescribed update regime. In the business world, I expect insurers to drive this. As "cyber attacks" get more and more costly the insurance industry is going to put the hammer down.
- WorldMaker 6y agoThe car analogy isn't a great one here either because there are seatbelt laws, light/lamp laws, etc that do carry serious penalties (such as fines and even jail time). Nobody will necessarily repossess your car, sure, if you fail to fix a broken headlight or seat-belt, but you can still be fined or jailed for it. (Though even repossession can happen as those fines/jail time can in turn cause repossession of your car as a secondary effect, depending on your loans/liens/bonds and the state in which you live.)
- EvanAnderson 6y agoThere is the potential for personal liability as a result of ignoring recalls. I'm not talking about failure to maintain a vehicle. I'm analogizing willfully ignoring safety-related recalls.
- WorldMaker 6y agoI'm not talking about "failure to maintain a vehicle" in a general sense, either; I'm talking safety-related recalls as well, because there have been serious repercussions in willfully ignoring safety-related recalls in the automotive world. IIRC, under the aegis of seatbelt laws some states impounded cars that didn't get a critical safety-related recall due an issue with the Toyota automated seatbelts of the late 80s/early 90s. Issues like that often end up with class action suits to deal with corporate liability issues, it's not all personal liability either. Maybe that's still too "one time for one particular issue" to easily dismiss the flaws in your analogy. What about emissions-related recalls? Some states still have ongoing vigorous emissions testing requirements and some of those requirements include checking for emissions-related recalls. Failures are sometimes impounded, almost always disallowed permits/registrations to use of the roads. One of the largest scandals of which should still be in recent memory, "Dieselgate", where VW was forced at great expense to recall entire models of cars that would not be allowed on the roads of all states that followed US EPA laws. Which the US federal government led a lawsuit (which included several states as additional complaintants) against VW for the problem, and leveraged a massive corporate liability fine. VW had to work to buy back all the recalled vehicle models, and had to do massive corporate restructuring in response to the US provided mandates that they accepted in lieu of fine payment. Your car analogy is over-simplified, even if it is not entirely wrong.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bitexploder 6y agoI have increasingly felt alienated in my relationship with my computing devices. I started in the mid 90s with Linux and Win95 and you owned and could understand the whole computer. iOS and the trend of walled computing gardens were ostensibly done for security and user experience, but users have lost control of their devices. Not everyone needs that of course, but I t is a big reason I migrated to Linux this year after having an off again on again relationship with Linux on my primary computing device. macOS is good, but it used to be great. Way too many technologists are eating up things like M1 / Apple silicon without asking if it’s a good thing. It performs great, but does it really matter? I’m pretty sure it doesn’t help me code or do things in emacs any more efficiently. After Apple hardware quality dropping a lot I just don’t feel the experience is good enough to justify it anymore. Maybe M1 will be a big evolutionary step that we simply can’t ignore, but I know I can do everything I need to for the next few years on my Linux laptop. I will evaluate again when it’s EOL. Mid-2015 Mac was the last great MacBook IMO. It’s been downhill from there. It’s been a slow incremental decline in quality of both the hardware and the OS. And I really loves my Mac and Apple ecosystem a lot, but the writing is on the wall for these walled gardens. iOS is still solid and my iPhone 12 is great... but it may be my last iPhone as well. Same with Windows, honestly. Win 7 was probably the last great windows operating system. Win10 has been very okay for me. All the forced reboots and telemetry in macOS and Windows... yuck.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoI feel like I'm going to end up being a veritable "hermit in a shack" because I won't tolerate the expectation of serfdom to our feudal hardware manufacturer and software developer overlords.
- bitexploder 6y agoUltimately we need a world where more than just technologists can run on commodity hardware and free operating systems. Hardware reached a point where most people can do all their computing in cheap hardware and Linux is really quite sufficient for most people, but many small and some medium size issues combine to make it too hard for most folks to embrace.
- 6y ago
- TameAntelope 6y agoNot for nothing, but the "slowly boiled frog" idea is a myth. When the water gets too hot, the frog will jump out. In other words, when the problem becomes bad enough, we as metaphorical frogs, will react normally. This is a Good Thing, and you should be wishing Microsoft, Apple, Google did this more often, because if they did, we'd all be meaningfully safer, having lost zero liberty along the way. Nobody's freedom is threatened because Microsoft removed software that was notoriously unsafe and was also set to stop working at the same time. Maybe a more apt analogy would be "boy who cried wolf"...
- EvanAnderson 6y agoHow is taking away an ability my computer had, without my consent, not threatening my freedom? (I'd like to see the EULAs for the affected Windows and Flash versions, too. I don't recall reading licenses for on-prem installed software that talk about the licensor being free to arbitrarily disable or remove features.)
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoYou don't own the software. You didn't even purchase the Flash player. Adobe has zero obligations to you. You could turn around and claim their behavior is a CFAA violation but good luck winning.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoI get that. I understand that software is licensed. I agreed to a license. If that license doesn't say that the "manufacturer" can arbitrarily remove features at a later date then I'm not sure how they get a pass for that. Edit (to your edit): Yeah. It sounds criminal to me. They'd be exceeding their access granted to my system. Definitely sounds like CFAA territory in the US. Fat chance that anything would be done about it, but it can still piss me off (and make me try to gin-up pissed-off feelings in other people).
- thombat 6y ago
- ogre_codes 6y ago> you do not really own your computer anymore. Wish people would stop using this phrase with regards to PCs. If you buy a laptop, it's yours. Load linux on it and you will never have to deal with this. Even the new M1 Macs will offer this option (though there are some hoops to jump through). What you don't own is the commercial software which runs atop it. In some cases the hardware makes it difficult to change what software you run (most smartphones), but we're talking about Windows PCs here. You can install what you want on them. If you don't like what Microsoft and Adobe are doing, don't use their software.
- spijdar 6y agoYou don't even need to bring Linux into the picture, necessarily. But whatever piece of proprietary software you run with DRM and obfuscation and licensing, you don't control. It's up to you to do a cost analysis and decide if it's "worth it" -- I use lots of proprietary software, I'll admit. Office365 and Steam are two big examples that I either can't or won't give up because of the professional or personal consequences. However, in both cases, I'm not in control of either piece of software. That's what I get for using proprietary software. It sounds like crazy Stallman ranting, but maybe he was right on this one -- the real solution is to not let proprietary plugins like Flash become "required" to use the net. As long as your computing platform is free, you have the choice not to. The number of people agreeing with this sentiment that this is about controlling our computers is kind of disheartening. This isn't OS or firmware level lockdowns, just a piece of software.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> You don't even need to bring Linux into the picture, necessarily. I only bring in Linux when I need it to get a job done! I use MacOS and have an iPhone. I don't worry about the philosophy since they have for years done (mostly) what I need. If it look like MacOS will stop being useful to me, good resale values on Macs means I can move on.
- chmod775 6y ago>What you don't own is the commercial software which runs atop it. I do! I bought it after all. If the software does something I did not agree to at time of purchase, I'm going to hold the seller accountable. If the gardener you're paying suddenly went and threw a painting in the trash because he considered it ugly you'd have a problem with them too. Whether or not people 'agreed' to this being done is another question though.
- Simulacra 6y agoFrom a philosophical perspective... Except for your thoughts and perhaps your life, which is another discussion entirely, it is arguable that you don't own ANYTHING. Not your home, your car, software, or the phone in your hand. You only have it because a corporation or government allows you to have it.
- filmgirlcw 6y agoCounterpoint - in nearly all cases (and I would say essentially all cases since Windows 8 was released), this was software that the user didn’t decide to install at all. Instead, it was installed for them by either their OEM or was included in Windows or by a browser maker or was part of some other software package (that almost certainly didn’t require it). So removing something that is a proven security risk, that the manufacturer actively deprecated years ago, and that it is shutting down server side in two weeks, seems to be far different than removing something that was a core part of the operating system. And even then, as others have pointed out, software updates remove features from software all the time. I totally agree that it feels weird and is bad if an update actively uninstalls something for legal reasons, like Amazon taking stuff off of Kindles remotely, but we're talking about software the user didn’t ask to install and that the maker is shutting off anyway. The vast majority of Flash usage was web-based and the web version will cease to be supported at the server level and at the browser level in a matter of weeks. Users that deliberately want to run insecure software or outdated web browsers have that option, and there are plenty of alternatives to display archival content. Any non web-based Flash applications have been written using Adobe Air for over 12 years (and desktop Flash apps have always been a rarity anyway), and Adobe Air isn’t going away. If there really is a self-contained app (probably a game) that wasn’t packaged using Adobe Air that absolutely relies on an ActiveX plugin, there are alternatives the user can find and use. Technology becomes obsolete. And software stops running. At least there are preservation efforts out there. There are infinitesimal edge cases where a user knowingly and specifically installed Flash Player for non web-based purposes. Those users are going to be given a warning before the application is removed, allowing them time to find an alternative way to access those files.
- euske 6y agoNot just computers but an increasing number of devices in general: some cameras, thermometers, and vacuum cleaners require immediate online activation (w/ software update) or they don't function properly; this is a borderline fraud in my opinion. We should mandate that companies must give a clear warning for things like this.
- Santosh83 6y agoThermometers? Seriously!? Unbelievable! I'm waiting for 2025 when a piece of cutlery or your garden hose will need internet activation.
- studius 6y ago> Regardless of whether you like Flash, this should be yet another ominous warning that you do not really own your computer anymore. This is definitely true with regard to applications and services. People give rms a hard time for going on about free software, but he saw this coming. "One assumption is that software companies have an unquestionable natural right to own software and thus have power over all its users. (If this were a natural right, then no matter how much harm it does to the public, we could not object.) Interestingly, the U.S. Constitution and legal tradition reject this view; copyright is not a natural right, but an artificial government-imposed monopoly that limits the users’ natural right to copy." -rms[1] I don't suggest jumping into the deep-end with free software mentality without full consideration. However, Google Play Music went under recently[2] with all of the content that people bought becoming potentially unavailable, so it's worth thinking about how much we don't own. [1]- https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/fsfs/rms-essays.pdf https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/fsfs/rms-essays.pdf [2]- https://9to5google.com/2020/12/03/google-play-music-dead/ https://9to5google.com/2020/12/03/google-play-music-dead/
- matheusmoreira 6y agoCorporations in general just like to own and control everything. Just look at the mess that is intellectual property rights. There's essentially no limits to what they will delude themselves into believing they can own.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoWho starts corporations? Who hires lawyers to try to protect intellectual proprty rights? It all starts with one or a few people exercising free will. To take a more common example than Bill Gates and friends, something as seemingly "non-corporate" as Pi-Hole has become a private corporation and "owns" a trademark. Regardless of reasons, it is what it is -- individuals poised to enforce "rights" against, to block, others. The "delusion" is quite contagious. Not disagreeing with the comment, just pointing out that these problems emanate from wilful participation in the delusion by individual persons.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kbenson 6y agoWhile I generally agree with this sentiment in a lot of cases, I don't think it really applies here. Microsoft ships Flash with Edge and Internet Explorer, or allows it to be installed, but they have decided they no longer want to support this integration given that the software in question is no longer being supported and has a long history of security problems. They are no longer shipping it with Edge and IE and are preventing it from running there. You can choose to run it in other ways, but Microsoft does not want their browser used as an vehicle for exploits that come through Adobe. Chrome and Firefox are planning to do the same, for similar reasons, and you can also get Flash working on those manually if needed in similar ways. The title here is pure clickbait. It's not Windows 10, it's a change in the default behavior of Edge and IE, and eventually Firefox and Chrome. A change that's as easy to work around as it was to get flash originally before browser vendors started including it by default. If you want to talk about signed bootloaders and completely locked down systems and app stores and how those devices aren't really owned by you anymore, I'm totally on board. But to say that a change in the default behavior of a few applications on just some of the operating systems you can install on your PC is evidence of you not owning your computer, I think that's a lot harder of a case to make.
- foxhill 6y ago> given that the software in question is no longer being supported and has a long history of security problems. look, similarly, whilst i think the world would be better off if vaccines were legally mandatory, i would never support someone who tried to make that so. it's not (and never is) about the specifics of this _one_ thing - the world will be a better place without flash - but the general principle of who owns what & freedom. if i _truly_ own my computer, then this could never happen. > They are no longer shipping it with Edge and IE and are preventing it from running there. i don't think that's the case. the article mentions removal of the abode flash player component. a user must have already installed this application manually. browsers are to remain unaffected (for now at least). here's a quote from the article: > It is worth noting that this change won’t affect your browsers where Flash will still remain a built-in component until the next big browser update. this is more akin to microsoft shipping an update that removes VLC, and hence from the 1st of january, all your mkv videos stop playing.
- musicale 6y ago> Regardless of whether you like Flash, this should be yet another ominous warning that you do not really own your computer anymore. I'm pretty sure you can choose to not run Windows 10.
- kevingadd 6y ago"Flash content will automatically stop working in January even if you don’t remove the player manually." My opinion only here, but the only company to blame for this is Adobe and this isn't corporations slowly taking over your computer (aside from the fact that yes, it is happening) - this is just another example of how Adobe hates their customers, sort of like how you can't buy Photoshop anymore and you have to put up with their cloud updater that will delete your mac's backblaze folder. Software with an expiration date is an old poison that Adobe has repurposed to EOL their own product because they're tired of maintaining it.
- willtim 6y agoThis highlights the risk of building upon and investing in a closed-source and proprietary platform (Flash). Once Adobe discontinued it, it was inevitable that browsers would eventually stop supporting it.
- unixhero 6y ago>Regardless of whether you like Flash, this should be yet another ominous warning that you do not really own your computer anymore. If you run Windows or OSX that is.