3 ms·
This is close to one of my pet peeves about FreeBSD: They're happy to say that they've had containers for longer than Linux and that Jails are better than Linux
by yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago
This is close to one of my pet peeves about FreeBSD: They're happy to say that they've had containers for longer than Linux and that Jails are better than Linux containers, and I don't really disagree on technical merit, but they seem to completely overlook that UX and images are Docker's killer features and FreeBSD doesn't have an answer to that[0]. I personally think that implementing a jail-backed OCI runtime and getting docker running on top of it (all of which should be fairly simple to do) would be a huge boost to getting more users - bonus points if it can run FreeBSD-native and Linux images by using the existing Linux-compat layer. I've even looked into actually implementing this myself, but the runc-containerd-docker codebases were too much for me to make sense of so far, unfortunately.
[0] Actually, partial caveat: cbsd and bhyve are at least meant to fill this space, I think, but they're neither a perfect match nor as easy to use IMO.
- throwaway201103 6y agoMaybe the FreeBSD project doesn't care about getting more users? It's certainly not a big motivating factor for OpenBSD, but I don't know how FreeBSD feels about it.
- kevans91 6y agoI can't speak for anyone else, but from my perspective (and I suspect others are similar): I like the idea of a jail-backed OCI runtime, but it's not interesting enough to my personal use to overtake any of the other OS-adjacent projects I'd otherwise work on in my spare time. I could be convinced (well, paid) to make it a higher priority, but ultimately it's currently at the bottom of a barrel of much more enticing fish since I'm not really in the demographic that that kind of stuff targets.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoQuite:) And seriously, maybe one of these days I'll find the time to understand how docker works well enough to retrofit it onto FreeBSD, but, indeed... it takes significant time and/or money, and this is currently just a hobby-interest, so there it sits...