5 ms·
The more important question is how do you match response with effects. 2% of covid deaths are people under 40, there is an at least linear correlation between
by colechristensen 6y ago
The more important question is how do you match response with effects.
2% of covid deaths are people under 40, there is an at least linear correlation between risk and age.
I value a day in my life much higher at my current age than I would serval decades in the future, and in general I think this is true.
The issue is that the people with the most risk have the least to lose, and those with the least risk have the most to lose.
Eventually you have to get to the calculus of how many months of bored teenagers is worth how many months of saved life for the elderly?
When it comes to me personally, the pandemic and response has taken away a not insignificant chunk of the prime of my life. How many days of life did I save for my part and was it worth it?
People tend to have this notion to cling to every second of extended life, that’s not necessarily right.
Life is risk, and everything you do changes the risk. People tend to want to take one extreme without matching their choices with values.
- fapjacks 6y ago"Life is worth losing." -- George Carlin
- iso1631 6y agoWould you agree to withhold all medical care for over 60s for a year or two to let covid run free?
- colechristensen 6y agoNo?
- iso1631 6y agoSo what would the solution be when 10 million people need hospital beds and there are only 1 million, most of which are taken up by people without covid
- djsumdog 6y agoNo one is accurately talking about the risks. The vast majority of people who have died have been over 60. There have been young people who died, yes. But young people die all the time of things that often kill very few: fungal infections, respiratory disease, bicycle wrecks. Now the narrative is "Long Covid" which comes from very limited case studies and papers that depend on web surveys and lots of other questionable research that falls flat once you start diving into the papers. Meanwhile, all the things people are doing are about as effective as TSA Security Theater. The lockdowns simply do not work. We can see that in the numbers between California, South Dakota, Sweden and others. Every nation or municipality that takes a hard approach is no better off, and often much worse, than places that did substantially less. The masks are a placebo at this point and the numbers show they probably do next to nothing (except contribute to massive pollution, waste, shame and make us fearful of each other). In 50 years, the only way I think historians will look back upon this ear is pure mass hysteria; global mass hysteria on a scale never seen before. This is not a time of honor and should never be returned to.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoWhen the compliance is good the lockdowns work well. Witness the results in the east Asian countries. They failed horribly in countries where people care less about others and compliance is too low.
- ryandrake 6y ago> The lockdowns simply do not work. We don't really know this because almost nowhere is actually locking anything down. We have these feeble and unenforced "stay at home" orders which are full of loopholes and largely ignored. If you go out for a drive in your town today (against stay-at-home guidance), you'll see all manner of stores open, people out and about horsing around, even restaurants. We're hardly taking any precautions at all. We don't know if lockdowns work because we haven't actually tried it. It's like the Simpsons quote, "We've tried nothing, and we're all out of ideas!" [1] A few places on earth like NZ and Australia actually did stay-at-home with far fewer loopholes, mandatory quarantining, contact tracing, and they're doing much better. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOTyUfOHgas https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOTyUfOHgas
- mistersquid 6y ago> I value a day in my life much higher at my current age than I would serval decades in the future, and in general I think this is true. Write this down somewhere for yourself and look back on it in two decades. Personally, this is not true for me when I look backwards two decades ago. I also doubt it will be true when I look back two decades from now.
- reddog 6y agoNobody wants to live to be 100 except the man who's 99.
- Guthur 6y agoIt's also not entirely simple. My mother is over 65 and while at risk due to her age she now has to deal with the fact she can not see her grandchildren which are very important to her. I life in Australia and had intended to visit the UK this year or have her come over, now she will not likely see her grandchildren until sometime into 2021, nearly 3 years since she last saw them. She was also looking forward to seeing my sister with her young kids this Christmas, she lives in the mainland UK, and has had to give that up as well. Whether or not people who frequent HN value human interact much is irrelevant for my mother she very much enjoys seeing her family and that's not happening this year and makes her quite sad.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoDifferent people have different priorities. Some might prefer [risking] death to physically visiting their prodigy less often. Am I correct in assuming this grandparent lives on a different continent than the grandkids?
- nl 6y ago> Am I correct in assuming this grandparent lives on a different continent than the grandkids? >> I life in Australia and had intended to visit the UK this year or have her come over Hard to read that any other way
- 6y ago
- neillyons 6y agoThe restrictions in the UK are to try and prevent the healthcare system from being overwhelmed. COVID is maxing out capacity which is having a knock on effect where normal treatments are having to be delayed. Eg cancer treatment for a young person. Even if young people aren't at risk directly from COVID as much as older people, they are at greater risk with health issues that affects all ages because of the delay in treatments. But yeah I understand your point of view. It is frustrating all the same.
- jodrellblank 6y ago> "the pandemic and response has taken away a not insignificant chunk of the prime of my life." Bits of your life which don't go your way are still lived, and still your life. You may as well argue that sleep takes your life away, and that illness does, and that employment does, and nickel and dime your way down to defining "your life" as just the bits you choose, and then further slice them all down into "the bits which went exactly the way I wanted". Newsflash, it's /all/ your life. > "Life is risk risk includes things not turning out how you hope, do you say that risks which don't pan out are "taking away my life"?