2 ms·
> but I do implore people to keep in mind when deciding on policy the law of unintended consequences This is one of those things that feels easy with the benef
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
> but I do implore people to keep in mind when deciding on policy the law of unintended consequences
This is one of those things that feels easy with the benefit of hindsight, but it's extraordinarily difficult to do up front.
Specifically: There are no modern studies that could quantify the negative externalities of mass quarantine on the mental health of a population. Obviously isolation will be detrimental to many, but where would you even begin to put a number on it?
Even more difficult, there are counterbalancing factors to mass quarantine such as a reduction in traffic fatalities. This one could maybe be estimated up front because we do have some statistics and models around traffic deaths.
Coronavirus is a unique situation because the negative effects are very non-linear. The fatality rate will skyrocket if/when hospital capacity is overwhelmed. Many policy decisions have been made in order to avoid those non-linear scenarios, which can look like overkill if you only consider them in the context of having avoided those scenarios.
But the real problems come from the political maneuvering that this opens up. Once you open the door to unmeasurable or unpredictable possible downsides of a policy, you will be flooded with "think of the children" type appeals that use fear of "what if" scenarios to grind progress to a halt. At scale, there is no such thing as a possible that doesn't have downsides to someone, somewhere. Trying to mitigate any and every downside is impossible.
> I've been shocked and saddened at the unwillingness of pro-lock-down people to consider the unintended consequences
Frankly, I think the average person doesn't fall into all out "anti-mask" or "pro-lockdown" categories, despite what you see on the news. We only hear about these extremist positions because the extremist voices tend to be the loudest. When considering one's own position, it's tempting to only look at the most extreme examples from the "other side" because they're the easiest to dismiss. In reality, the vast majority of the population is firmly in the middle. The average person doesn't like the idea of extreme lockdowns any more than they like the idea of a total laissez faire approach. We just don't hear about the middle ground on the news or social media because it's boring.
- watwut 6y agoOne aspect is that there were models trying to calculate those other things like downsides. Both guesses on suicides and domestic violence going up, people not going to doctor. But that does not matter, because people will do the rhetorical point anyway. In most context, people who bring up suicide did not even tried to find whether those guesses exists. It is almost end of year, we have actual suicides statistics available. Suicides went slightly up, but not by much and they went slightly up in preceding years too. More people died from covid. Our best estimates say that if hospitals would get overfulled, in those places mortality would be even higher. But that does not matter for "what about" political point. Because that one is not motivated by attempt to find best policy, it is motivated by wanting the other side to be wrong.
- johnojerk 6y agoThey did one after SARS for folks who had to quarantine in China and Toronto. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3320456 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3320456