3 ms·
AFAIK, blockchains are good for planet-scale distributed read&write access. The government is a central authority, and tax records are not generally public inf
by klyrs 6y ago
AFAIK, blockchains are good for planet-scale distributed read&write access. The government is a central authority, and tax records are not generally public information. Sounds like a good application for a private-access, append-only database. What does the blockchain offer that, say, postgres can't handle?
Right now the record of identity is a social security number. True, it's not terribly robust, and, for instance, can be stolen -- but so can your wallet if somebody finds your private key.
- maxerickson 6y agoThe SSN isn't record though, it's the identifier for the record. I had to verify my federal tax filing this year. The agent or whatever was able to pull up my taxes from past years after a couple of authentication questions. Which that is what the GP poster is asking for, a more robust way of authenticating that a person corresponds to a record. It's a tough problem.
- klyrs 6y agoSure, I should have said identifier. I'm actually having trouble identifying myself to the government right now, because I lost my records in a recent move. It's a real problem, but ultimately I found a workaround in meatspace. That is, the workaround grants me access... but there's an unresolved issue: whoever's got that box of my records has everything they need to steal my identity. Is "the blockchain" going to prevent situations like this? Replace "lose a box of records" with data loss and/or exfiltration and you're in the same situation except perhaps that the "better mousetrap" will prevent the meatspace workaround from functioning.
- maxerickson 6y agoI also think there is a lot of risk that people start to think of official records as identity (so any flaw in the system can be used to harm people by messing up their records). But that isn't how it works, identity is an intrinsic thing and official records describe aspects of it. I certainly don't think a blockchain is of any use here. There might be some value in publishing some information in order to establish identities for use in other contexts, but a blockchain isn't necessary for that. Even issue cryptographically strong identity cards has a bunch of hard problems. How do you repudiate a card without possessing it, how do you obtain a new one if it breaks, etc., etc.
- klyrs 6y agoThen we quickly spiral into the dystopic conversation around biometrics, chip implantation, etc... this is a hard problem.