3 ms·
This seems to be indicative of the great problem of the future. If a small percentage of the world’s population are devious and seek to ruin things for everyone
by MichaelZuo 6y ago
This seems to be indicative of the great problem of the future. If a small percentage of the world’s population are devious and seek to ruin things for everyone else, how does the global society punish that? If it’s only just 1% of the population, that’s still over 70 million folks spread across thousands of jurisdictions... The ultimate free rider problem. And will likely grow exponentially until we come up with some way to change the structure of the world, or if the fraction grows, until they consume all the productive surplus.
- cmelbye 6y agoThis attack vector was created by gigantic, centralized, and ineffective bureaucracies. I’m not sure if it follows that a new international bureaucracy is needed to stop the damage.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoI frequently read that the problem with government is that we just need more of it. That they just don’t have enough money and power to be effective yet.
- MichaelZuo 6y agoAnd yet certain countries will need a ‘gigantic, centralized, bureaucracy’ regardless of any other factor because of the existence of WMDs, so to get rid of such is an impossible option for the globe. What other options are there once the existence of such ‘gigantic, centralized, bureaucracy’ is preordained on this planet for the foreseeable future?
- vlovich123 6y agoThis doesn't need a global solution I think. Just make a requirement that people need to get a one-use access code in-person from a government office after presenting some ID (DMV or whatever). Alternatively allow this one-use access code to be delivered by mail within the US. That would instantly cull a giant amount of international electronic fraud but does carry some user friction points to figure out. The easiest way to cull a scaling problem caused by technology is to inject some kind of geographic-limiting or human-required action into the process.
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoThat one time access code is your social security number, by the way... If a number is so important it becomes valuable and becomes the target of scams. And govt offices will be tempted to piggyback on that number since it can be directly linked to an identity regardless of address changes, employment changes, phone number changes, and name changes
- treis 6y ago>in-person from a government office In the middle of a pandemic?
- vlovich123 6y agoMaybe not at the beginning of the pandemic because of all the unknowns. Over the summer though? Yes. We know how the disease works. If we can keep grocery stores open I'm sure you can put up plastic barriers & enforce mask wearing in government offices. The DMV is open today (as other other government offices that can't work remotely). Again, I'm not saying this is a perfect system, but it should be sufficient to significantly cut down fraud. If you want a system that scales better, you have to have a reliable national ID system but Americans historically have been very loathe on a functional version, instead using social security numbers for that which fail on many many fronts.