4 ms·
What costs do individuals have to pay when their government is very good at identifying them? When you have a piece of data available, it tends to get used. H
by colechristensen 6y ago
What costs do individuals have to pay when their government is very good at identifying them?
When you have a piece of data available, it tends to get used. How could that be a bad thing when enhancing identifiably is the topic?
- john_minsk 6y agoIt can be anonymous and you will have to present an evidence that certain transaction belongs to you only when the situation requires it. Government can ensure information split at the time of registration and then dictate that only warrant can allow to link the 2. Anyway, the ability of governments to identify their citizens is technological problem. Overall during our history we agreed to potential of being identified by governments. Tech brings new tools to them. I wish they could adopt them quicker. Overall we shouldn't be afraid of new tech and more reliability. But what we need is the system that will be future proof in terms of balance between individual and big entities even if their technological ability to identify you is near perfect.
- kansface 6y agoAssigning some bytes to a person is easy, but how do you authorize transactions? People will not keep a secret... secret. People will not remember a secret. People will lose cards. Smart phone adoption is maybe 75% in the US. Many people do not have internet access, a phone line, or even electricity! People have all sorts of disabilities, many can't read, and many still don't have permanent housing or even an address. The technology is the easy part.
- rebuilder 6y agoFollow-up questions: what data on race and creed does the USA collect that e.g. European states generally do not? And what is the difference between enabling the state to discriminate between its citizens vs.enabling its citizens to prove they are who they say they are?
- oh_sigh 6y agoHow exactly do you think the government is going to get a bunch of people on board to develop and operate a system to discriminate based on race, such that there isn't a single whistleblower? Would they just outsource it directly to the KKK or what?
- rebuilder 6y agoLike the Nazis did it, for example. That's the experience that keeps several European states from keeping tabs on race, isn't it?
- colechristensen 6y agohttps://wikipedia.org/wiki/Kristallnacht https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Kristallnacht Who says it needs to be a secret? The past shows that people happily let things happen out in the open. The present should show you that plenty of people still have the loyalty above all mentality and would easily be manipulated into doing whatever was desired. Just leak demographic data to the proud boys and when they do things, low key condemn them but not really. How have whistleblowers been working out lately? There have been many and the effects have been... underwhelming.
- jariel 6y agoSo I understand the 'drawback', especially for 'universal data'. But let's just use something more mundane: Are you concerned that the government has a 'record of you' regarding your Driver's License? Probably not. We have drivers licenses, we have social security. It's a very reasonable step to have some kind of 'good id'. Yes, there'll have to be legislation around it for privacy.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoPeople tolerate these kinds of things as necessary evils. It would be great if we didn't need ID to drive and didn't need SS but that's not the world we live in. The fact that people tolerate necessary evil is not argument for more evil.
- jariel 6y ago"People tolerate these kinds of things as necessary evils." They are not 'necessary evils' in any minds but those of HN commenters. They are just 'normal artifacts' in the minds most people. People are generally not concerned with the existence of DLs and they are generally not some kind of 'threat'. If you literally brought up 'privacy' issues to most Americans, maybe they would say something, but I'll be $100 that most Americans, on the subject of 'Drivers License' would never bring up the issue of 'privacy' unsolicited. An SS card with literally a photo on it, the most minor of changes, could effectively serve as a really good 'ID'.