5 ms·
Organic meats found to have the same greenhouse impact as regular meats
- meat-industry 6y agoWhy would anyone think otherwise? Organic isn’t about greenhouse gases, it’s about keeping toxins out of food.
- bobthepanda 6y agoTo be honest, I would’ve thought that organic meat might produce more greenhouse gases, since they need more land and higher quality food for the same amount of meat.
- AussieWog93 6y agoI think you could argue it's more about marketing than either of those things. I don't know about meat, but one of the more interesting facts to come out of the Randy Constant case was that there was no way to chemically test whether or not grain was actually organic - which would only be possible if organic and non-organic were chemically identical.
- giuliomagnifico 6y ago> out of food. Yes but keep them out of food and put them in the air (or elsewhere) is not a good goal.
- athms 6y ago>Organic isn’t about greenhouse gases, it’s about keeping toxins out of food. Organic is about selling expensive food to stupid people. There is nothing inherently better about organic. It isn't healthier. It isn't better for the environment. At best, the yields are equal, but normally they are lower. With lower yields come higher prices. There are plenty of organic pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers that are just as dangerous as synthetic varieties. There are more cases of food recalls for organic contamination than synthetic. The issue with GMO is not food safety, it is patents. The use of GMO crops have reduced chemical usage while increasing yields. They have also introduced critical vitamins and minerals to groups of people that have deficient levels. This has been a boon in Africa.
- abdullahkhalids 6y ago> There are plenty of organic pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers that are just as dangerous as synthetic varieties. Don't let perfect be the enemy of good. The purpose of buying organic is signalling your preferences for eating healthier food. Yes, sometimes, the process we set up to do this, will yield worse results, but that just means we should try harder, not give up on eating healthier.
- athms 6y ago>The purpose of buying organic is signalling your preferences for eating healthier food. A tomato grown with organic pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers has the same nutrition value as a tomato grown with synthetic pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers. A genetically modified tomato can more nutritious.
- junon 6y agoSad to see an accurate take on GMO be so fervently downvoted on a site full of people claiming to be scientifically minded.
- wcarron 6y agoI suspect it is because callinge everyone who buys organic food (probably a significant % of this site) stupid isn't a great way to frame the argument, regardless of its accuracy.
- athms 6y agoI originally put gullible, but changed my mind. Anybody that has taken chemistry and biology in high school should be able to grasp why organics are not better. This is basic science education. The arguments of folks that embrace organics are nothing more than pleas to emotion and sometimes pleas to tradition. It is not ignorance, it is stupidity. It is the same thing with petroleum. The majority of folks on this site want to see the end to oil exploration and refining, because they only consider its use as a fossil fuel. An electric car could not be made without oil. As an example, a single tire uses seven gallons of oil, five gallons are used as feed stock and two are used in the manufacturing process. There are plenty of highly educated people here that simply ignore reality because it makes them feel better.
- seesawtron 6y agoBecause it is being popularised as being an environment friendly and animal friendly option. The latter is still true I suppose?
- MandieD 6y agoI’m honestly (and pleasantly) surprised that organically-raised meats don’t have a significantly higher greenhouse impact than conventional ones. I prefer organic because, at least in Germany, the animal welfare standards are higher for it. I don’t actually care if the animal feed itself is organic, because I figure the chickens and cows really don’t care.
- idoubtit 6y agoIn France, there are distinct certifications: "Bio" for organic food, and "Label rouge" for high quality meat. For instance, animals with the later certification may eat non-organic food, but they spend most of their days outside, their feeding is sane, and the food process is controlled down to the distribution. No hormones, no chlore... Of course, some products can have both labels. And some farms, especially the smaller ones, apply similar processes but without any certification.
- MandieD 6y agoLabel Rouge chickens are my favorite, and I wish I could find that same standard for other meats in Germany.
- mhd 6y agoGerman organic labels can get pretty weird, though. Your regular EU label still allows castrating piglets without anaesthetization. And if I remember correctly, the minimum requirements about how many you can keep per square meter aren't that much better than the lowest rung of the new "Tierwohl" scale (1-4 on packaged meats). On the other hand, with the "Demeter" label (the third-largest organic association in Germany) you get some better statistics, but not by much, and you're also paying for the farmers to bury cow skulls filled with magic herbs. I'd really appreciate a EU-wide label with some graduations that actually mean something.
- mark_l_watson 6y agoThis is tangential. My wife and I eat organic meats that are as humanely raised as possible for health reasons. For the environment, and our health, we eat very little meat.
- charliebrownau 6y agoPlease dont have kids We need less privlaged rich upper class liberal people in multicultural diversity enriched cities