3 ms·
While I agree with the overall thesis that housing prices are currently overvalued in many areas, there is a lot to this analysis that I don't like because it p
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
While I agree with the overall thesis that housing prices are currently overvalued in many areas, there is a lot to this analysis that I don't like because it paints with too broad a brush. E.g. it kicks off with:
"Housing market returns are very bad. Between 1948 and 2004 the real increase in value in the U.S real estate market was less than 1% a year."
While that may be true nationally, as they say in real estate: location, location, location. There is huge variation in real estate prices, and that 1% average masks giant gains in some areas and enormous losses in others.
The thing about real estate is that a desirable, greatly supply-restricted asset is always priced at whatever the top earners in an economy make. That's why real estate with unique, constrained features (e.g. waterfront, city center, etc.) has appreciated unstoppably, while there is a cap on price appreciation for easily-replicated homes (can always build another suburb further out in Phoenix).
Thus, blanket statements of "don't buy a home" are ridiculous without more context of exactly which home it is you plan to buy.