3 ms·
I don't believe anyone with any significant knowledge of the subject has ever seriously suggested that the ability to play chess well requires full human level
by simonh 6y ago
I don't believe anyone with any significant knowledge of the subject has ever seriously suggested that the ability to play chess well requires full human level AI. Automatons that can play chess, some real and some fake, have existed for hundreds of years and nobody I'm aware of mistook them for human level intelligences but just clever curiosities, so I think this is clearly a particularly poorly informed straw man argument.
I can maybe imagine someone not working in AI or unfamiliar with how computers work, and ignorant of the history of Chess automatons maybe saying something like this, but even if so who cares? It's simply wrong. We're not going to issue Deep Blue citizenship because Chess.
The gold standard test for human level intelligence has long been and still remains the Turing Test. Not hobbled, limited "easy mode" tests as in some recent competitions for chat bots, but a full on, no holds barred freeform dialogue including whatever games, discussions, tests and topics a sophisticated tester chooses.
- FartyMcFarter 6y agoI'm not saying that chess equals human-level intelligence. I'm saying that dismissing any progress in AI because it doesn't solve a corner case of a previously important unsolved problem is moving the goalposts of AI research. Especially if dismissing the progress requires usage of fuzzy terms such as "understanding".
- simonh 6y agoRight, but I suspect what’s happening is the inverse. Things like a chess and image classifiers are special cases. They’re important problems of course, but they’re not core building blocks of general AI and mistaking them for that is, well, a mistake. And sure some people do that, like the famous comment on Slashdot that Alphago was a sign that general AI was imminent, but actual AI researchers know this is simply not the case. Discussions about be real human level AI do involve using poorly defined terms unfortunately, but that’s because we don’t actually understand general Intelligence. I think pinning down those concepts more concretely will be part of the process.
- gowld 6y ago> The gold standard test for human level intelligence has long been and still remains the Turing Test The Turing Test was an offhand example that Turing brainstormed. The hard part of the turing test isn't "intelligence" but "human" -- imitating a human's irrational quirks. It doesn't make sense to call that a "level", because computers are far better at imitating humans than humans are at imitating computers. In other words, humans can't even pass a symmetric Turing Test.
- simonh 6y agoI disagree, I think the hard part of the Turing test is passing well constructed interrogations that check for comprehension, deduction, improvisation, etc. For example you teach the subject a novel game, ask them to play it, then change the rules, or you describe a situation, describe changes and activities and interrogate them on subsequent states. Essentially check for problem solving, deduction, etc, things that require actual intelligence. You can't proxy a test for intelligence to other attributes, like quirks or personality. You have to actually test for the attribute in question.
- Oreb 6y ago> I don’t believe anyone with any significant knowledge of the subject has ever seriously suggested that the ability to play chess well requires full human level AI. Douglas Hofstadter did.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> Automatons that can play chess, some real and some fake, have existed for hundreds of years Those were midgets inside a box. > The gold standard test for human level intelligence has long been and still remains the Turing Test. Most HN readers, and most of Gen X, would fail a Turing test today as being "too ignorant to even talk to." So not sure what you're expecting.