3 ms·
Searle's "Chinese Room" supposes that somehow what humans do is always something more than what an algorithm can do. Either the mythical Chinese book he descri
by JKCalhoun 6y ago
Searle's "Chinese Room" supposes that somehow what humans do is always something more than what an algorithm can do.
Either the mythical Chinese book he describes is "intelligent" or perhaps humans are not as magical as we imagine we are.
At least that was my take away. If he is suggesting somehow that we are not, at our core, machines then you might as well talk about the "soul".
- dleslie 6y agoI like to think of it as a question that marks a distinguishing level of intelligence: to have the capacity to formulate and pose the question within Searle's thought exercise is a benchmark itself; one that many humans are not able to achieve. Cutting edge AI is roughly infantile in its human-like ability, and rapidly entering toddlerhood. Given the tools and processes we have, can we expect it to progress to childhood soon?
- kbelder 6y agoRight. I always feel like, if it was a valid proof against AI, it also served as a proof against human intelligence. It just seems to take for granted that there is a fundamental (near-mystical) difference between the atoms in a brain and the atoms in a computer, even though that's a very extraordinary claim.
- Barrin92 6y agoit's not an extraordinary claim at all. Digital computers and biological brains are not the same thing. Just like you can't build the Golden Gate Bridge out of jell-O, it's perfectly possible that you cannot replicate human intelligence in a completely different substrate. Physical properties matter is what he is saying. He's not denying that humans are intelligent, he's saying that biological intelligence is (likely) unique because of its configuration. The extraordinary claim is actually the almost dualistic view taken by AI people. That intelligence exists in some sort of cloud, distinct from matter or physical properties. It's almost a Descartes like, religious fantasy. Searle isn't denying that you can build AI, but that you can build any AI out of anything. He's saying that if you want to build human like intelligence, it is very likely that you need human like material. Just like when you build a house it actually matters what the house is structurally made of, it matters to an AI what it is made of. You can't make a house just out of some platonic mathematical idea of a house.
- Barrin92 6y agoThat's a common misunderstanding of his argument. He's not saying that there's requirement for a soul or anything, but that a digital computer and a biological system are not necessary equivalent. That is, not everything is 'computational' simply because people keep saying that it is. He demonstrates this by showing the difference between semantics and syntax. A pocket calculator can solve mathematical equations, but the calculator does not understand them, it is simply manipulating strings. It could be playing chess or poker or anything else, it cannot and does not distinguish what it's meaning or intent is. Searle points out that biological systems go far beyond this, we have an actual conceptual understanding of the world which we express in syntax, but we also have an underlying model, and understanding of what it is we're expressing. And the important thing to notice here that it's not Searle who appeals to a 'soul' (he is simply taking the very materialist viewpoint that brains and computers are not the same thing), but it's the "everything is computational" crowd who have almost supernatural belief in some higher realm of mathematics that is completely decoupled from physics or biology.
- Thiez 6y ago> Searle points out that biological systems go far beyond this, we have an actual conceptual understanding of the world which we express in syntax, but we also have an underlying model, and understanding of what it is we're expressing. He doesn't really point that out though. He claims that biological systems have this additional power, but there is really no proof or indication that deep down we're not just very advanced squishy calculators manipulating strings.