4 ms·
>This sounds a lot like the usual moving of goalposts whereby "anything computers can do isn't AI, so AI doesn't work". Well, it's also useful to establish a c
by coldtea 6y ago
>This sounds a lot like the usual moving of goalposts whereby "anything computers can do isn't AI, so AI doesn't work".
Well, it's also useful to establish a concrete definition of what is AI, and what is to be expected of it.
>"chess was supposed to be a demonstration of human intelligence"
Well, if it was, it was a bad one, and in restrospect it's obvious. You can play chess (as a program) and have totally 0 IQ in all over realms (e.g. any specialized chess engine, which is nothing like a general AI), whereas that's no true for humans. Human intelligence allows a chess player to ALSO play chess, it's not a chess-oriented algorithm.
The same way a plastic ruler might measure better than us ("this is 12.45 inches", whereas we might say "that's about a foot", but its "measuring intelligence" is not human intelligence by any definition.
- FartyMcFarter 6y ago> Well, if it was, it was a bad one, and in restrospect it's obvious. That's exactly the point - this keeps happening with various things. Having reasonable machine translation / playing chess / computer vision were all considered as AI problems at some point, now they're often dismissed as not being AI, depending on whether or not computers are seen as achieving them. Alternatively, progress in those problems is dismissed due to not having enough "understanding" or "abstraction", even if computers are way better than humans at solving them (e.g. Penrose's point about chess). The goalposts keep moving so that AI is always what computers can't yet do.
- pm90 6y agoI’ll bite. So what? Goalposts changing isn’t some sign of shadiness. Science isn’t a soccer game. Goalposts change all the damn time. Newtonian physics was considered as something that explained almost everything. Then we discovered that it doesn’t really, there are other theories that are better in being able to account for experiments. It’s not some sign of some big con. There was a goal, it was achieved and we moved on to the next one.
- FartyMcFarter 6y agoTo use your physics analogy, the situation with Penrose and AI would be like someone going "see, Newtonian physics don't explain everything, I told you physics is unsolvable!".
- coldtea 6y ago>That's exactly the point - this keeps happening with various things. Well, that's not "goalpost moving" then, it's "improving our understanding and updating wrong notions we had".