3 ms·
"Implement one-click shopping with a different mechanism and the patent doesn't apply." What different mechanism? What different mechanism implements one-click
by jerf 16y ago
"Implement one-click shopping with a different mechanism and the patent doesn't apply."
What different mechanism? What different mechanism implements one-click shopping that isn't one-click shopping?
I'm serious. Lay it out for me. Then, if you manage to get that far, explain what your difference has that the B&N implementation didn't have. Don't just handwave.
"I haven't read the claims(and I'll bet that you haven't either)"
Wrong.
In fact...
"They're about disclosure..."
If you have any programming skills, you should go read the patent and see just how much is "disclosed". First, sit down and sketch out what you would need to implement in order to create a one-click ordering system. No, seriously, sketch out the basic systems on paper. Then go read the patent. Then boil out the legalese. Then observer that your sketch and what the patent contains has roughly the same amount of information.
You are at a disadvantage until you do this, by the way, because like I said, I have read this, and several other such patents. You need to read at least one before continuing on. And ask yourself the question, exactly how much help are these patent applications in implementing a solution to the given problem to one "skilled in the art"? This is part of the reason software patents are so stupid, they almost all completely fail this test. You cited one of the handful of counterexamples already, but an exception it very much is.
"Patents have nothing to do with encouraging people to create alternative solutions."
You need to brush up on your patent defenses if you're going to spend any time defending them. They're for the purposes of promoting innovation, and the stimulation of alternate solutions is one of the big ways they do this. It is only a recent perversion of the goals of IP that they are solely intended to serve as property and create gatekeepers and therefore allow people to block innovation as they see fit.
- anamax 16y ago> What different mechanism? What different mechanism implements one-click shopping that isn't one-click shopping? As I thought, you haven't read (or understood) the claims. The claims describe the mechanisms that the patent covers. Do one-click shopping with a different mechanism (that is, eliminate and/or replace one or more elements), and you're home free. I don't know, or care, what mechanism B&N was using. (I'm guessing that you don't know either, so ....) I do know that some combination of B&N's lawyers and a court decided that B&N had used a claimed mechanism. If so, that's the result that we'd want from any other patent, so why is software different. (If B&N didn't actually use a claimed mechanism, that's a different problem, but again, that wouldn't be anything different about software patents.) > If you have any programming skills, you should go read the patent I've both (significant) programming skills and some familiarity with patent law. (I've even written a couple.) Moreover, I have read the patent. > You are at a disadvantage until you do this, Not to anything that you've shown. >> "Patents have nothing to do with encouraging people to c>reate alternative solutions." > You need to brush up on your patent defenses if you're going to spend any time defending them. They're for the purposes of promoting innovation, You need to brush up on your understanding of basic English and/or logic. "create alternative solutions" is not the same as "promote innovation". It is one way, but it is not the only way, so whether a given patent encourages "create alternative solutions" or not is irrelevant. Patents encourage innovation by rewarding it. > It is only a recent perversion of the goals of IP that they are solely intended to serve as property That's simply absurd and has no basis in history. Patent assighment is not new, and that's a fundamental characteristic of "property". Moreover, US Patents have always worked by restricting what other people can do. That's how they funnel money to inventors and the folks who support them. There's a reason why I mentioned AG Bell. What do you think that the telephone patent lawsuits were about if not "gatekeeping"? It's perfectly reasonable to think that there might be more effective ways to promote innovation or to reward inventors, but that doesn't entitle you to misrepresent how patents actually work.
- anamax 16y ago> And ask yourself the question, exactly how much help are these patent applications in implementing a solution to the given problem to one "skilled in the art"? You're assuming that a patent is "bad" if the solution is obvious given the problem. That's wrong. Patents for new problems with an "obvious" high-level solution are completely legitmate and well-established in every other domain. In other words, the novelty can be in the problem. Why is software different?