3 ms·
> Could not find that part of the letter If they were really for free speech, period, that's what they would say. But they don't say that. They say they are fo
by pdonis 6y ago
> Could not find that part of the letter
If they were really for free speech, period, that's what they would say. But they don't say that. They say they are for "the free and unfettered conduct of scientific research and debate". But who gets to decide what counts as "scientific research and debate" and what doesn't? They do.
- Someone 6y agoI read that as picking one battle at a time. Also: who says they do decide what’s scientific research and debate?
- pdonis 6y ago> who says they do decide what’s scientific research and debate? Because that is how academia works. And they're all academics.
- ilyaeck 6y agoThe letter is from academics to an academic organization (ACM), so yes: its scope is the rules of engagement in academic institutions. The issues you are bringing up are out of scope.
- pdonis 6y ago> The issues you are bringing up are out of scope. No, they're not. Scientific research and debate are not the only topics that get discussed at academic institutions; in fact no topic should be off limits for discussion at academic institutions. Nor should the institutions themselves have any privileged position in deciding what counts as relevant for a particular topic, whether it's scientific research and debate or anything else.
- whakim 6y agoIt isn't really "picking one battle at a time" when this is a valid counterpoint. Do you think that these same scientists would claim that researching, say, eugenics, is an acceptable use of an academic institution's resources and brand name? If not, who's drawing the line and what is the line?
- tomp 6y agoBecause if they were outright for free speech, their position would be even more offensive and unacceptable for the pro-woke than it already is (“oh, so you support the nazis?!”)