3 ms·
I'd expect any submissions to this are just appended to a database without any actual validation beyond the trivial Luhn checksum and then there's a batch proce
by Nextgrid 6y ago
I'd expect any submissions to this are just appended to a database without any actual validation beyond the trivial Luhn checksum and then there's a batch process once a day (maybe the same one that actually generates whatever marketing "insights" they claim to provide) that reads from there and ignores any card numbers from the opt-out DB.
- bitexploder 6y agoYou would hope that. I’ve been in infosec doing application security as a consultant a long time. Developers have often destroyed my hopes :)
- vageli 6y ago> You would hope that. I’ve been in infosec doing application security as a consultant a long time. Developers have often destroyed my hopes :) I used to work at a big bank in the US and the parent's description sounds exactly like how it would work.
- earthboundkid 6y agoGovernment and banks have been continuously using computers since the 60s, so as a result there’s a lot of “fancy web API to collect data… that gets batch processed by an ETL on a mainframe overnight.” Much more of it than I realized as a young dev at least.
- bitexploder 6y agoYou could be right but I have found almost this exact bug in production systems (credit card oracle sitting on the public Internet of a big card processor with no rate limiting and a really obvious timing delta). Both scenarios (batch or live processing) are pretty likely IMO. Just depends on what mess of APIs you happen to end up on.
- netsharc 6y agoHuh... create script to fill DB with all possible Visa numbers, tomorrow's "marketing insight" will suddenly be an empty file because everything will be excluded. Bonus, if they can't separate which exclusions were from legitimate requests and which came from this script, they can't just delete those entries from the database. Of course, no one should do this...
- overscore 6y ago> Bonus, if they can't separate which exclusions were from legitimate requests and which came from this script, they can't just delete those entries from the database. I think they would probably just declare them all invalid, and roll back to yesterday.
- chris_wot 6y agoI think that millions of requests from a particular IP address might give the game away.
- jmpman 6y agoPerfect use case for Splunk.