9 ms·
> It's my personal bias but I see every group this way. I have the same "bias". What people seem to forget is that the scientific method was supposed to be a
by pdonis 6y ago
> It's my personal bias but I see every group this way.
I have the same "bias".
What people seem to forget is that the scientific method was supposed to be a way to develop theories that made good predictions in spite of the fact that humans, both individually and in groups, are unreliable and do all sorts of crazy things for all sorts of crazy reasons. Calling oneself a "scientist" or having an advanced degree does not make one less susceptible to that. One has to set up institutions that will harness the craziness of humans and human groups in a direction that, on average and over the long term, is productive.
But what most people call "science" today is not such an institution. For example, the real message of the "replication crisis" is that most of what the average person is told is "science" is actually nothing of the sort. A sane institution of science would never have labelled that stuff as "science" in the first place; it would have said "sorry, we're still working on this, no results yet". And a lot of times it would say that and there never would be any results, and science would say "no results from this line of research; that's to be expected since many lines of research that initially look promising don't pan out".
- cycomanic 6y agoThe are several things about the replication crisis. First, it is important to remember that science always had unethical behaviour, intrigue and politics. In the end the best science always won, but it might have taken significant time. One could also say that by the very nature of us speaking about it, it can't be an existential crisis. Finally, I would argue that the large problem stems not from within science, but from how "science administratio/funding" has changed. Essentially, the idea of making science more (a)countable/measurable has lead to a state where scientists spend large fractions (>30%) of their time applying for funding. Also the funding is very much tied to some measurable outcomes, so there is just no time left to dedicade to reproducing results, because you can't get funding for it. I believe we as society need to come back to a view of seeing science as a general good, without the need to produce some immediate measurable outcomes (in fact this is true for many aspects of society) . Unfortunately the MBAs are running the show almost everywhere so I don't see this happening anytime soon.
- pdonis 6y ago> science always had unethical behaviour, intrigue and politics Yes, this is part of what I was referring to when I said that humans do all kinds of crazy things for all kinds of crazy reasons. > In the end the best science always won I'm not sure I agree. I would agree if you limited your claim to hard science--areas where we can nail down the best theory by lots of data and controlled experiments--but many areas that are called "science" are not amenable to that. > by the very nature of us speaking about it, it can't be an existential crisis I'm not sure I agree with that either. > I believe we as society need to come back to a view of seeing science as a general good, without the need to produce some immediate measurable outcomes I agree with this, but I would also add that science should be viewed as a tool for finding good predictive theories, no matter what those theories end up predicting. Unfortunately much funding of science now is given with the expectation that a particular kind of result will be what "science" predicts.
- bonoboTP 6y agoI've been thinking about it lately how this may be a linguistic game. Science is just a label and when anything turns out to be wrong, we just say, "well that's part of the scientific process". In this way science can never be really wrong, because it is always open to being proved wrong and if so, it just incorporates that new fix/criticism as a new part of science. (Similarly philosophy seems to be impossible to criticize well without the criticism becoming labeled as philosophy itself) I think it's rather that we have had a bunch of great curious people who worked on interesting stuff and found out a lot about nature. But we can't equate that with institutional credentialed authoritative "Science". I guess there is some underlying scientific ethos, that can be learned between the lines, but I don't think it's a clear method (as in the intro textbook definition).
- pdonis 6y ago> I guess there is some underlying scientific ethos The ethos is simple: all scientific models are judged by their predictive power, and nothing else. If your model does not make accurate predictions, it is wrong, period. Nothing else matters. I agree that there is no single "method" that guarantees that models will satisfy the above criterion.