35 ms·
What is there around to replace string theory with? I predict that if there ever is a viable alternative available with even 0.001% more evidence supporting it,
by whatshisface 6y ago
What is there around to replace string theory with? I predict that if there ever is a viable alternative available with even 0.001% more evidence supporting it, strings will vanish in a day. Presently all other approaches to quantum gravity are in a less developed state and make even fewer predictions.
- Iwan-Zotow 6y agoFewer than 0? How come?
- whatshisface 6y agoString theory at least predicts gravity in three dimensions. Other approaches to quantum gravity are not even far enough along to do that - it was an immense and relatively recent accomplishment to have LQG on a circle.
- guscost 6y agoString theory has not made predictions that are in any sense meaningful to science. “Confirmations should count only if they are the result of risky predictions; that is to say, if, unenlightened by the theory in question, we should have expected an event which was incompatible with the theory--an event which would have refuted the theory.” - Popper
- whatshisface 6y ago>String theory has not made predictions that are in any sense meaningful to science. You're welcome to set the bar of meaningful at any level you like; such a statement cannot in principle be disagreed with. However the point stands that string theory has made more accurate empirical predictions than any other theory of quantum gravity. That doesn't mean no other theory of quantum gravity will ever beat it, just that the focus on string theory among people and funders who are precomitted to studying quantum gravity is rational.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoI had not heard of this, can you point me to string theory enlightened measurement that has shown the accuracy of string theory above other theories?
- whatshisface 6y agoLook around you and note that there appear to be about three dimensions, and furthermore there's gravity. Also, quantum mechanics is true. String theory is the only theory that satisfies both of those conditions at once. Other approaches to quantum gravity aren't that far yet, but could conceivably yield those predictions at some point in the future. Today, though, there's only string theory.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoI thought I remember string theory positing more than three dimensions. Does string theory explain our perception of three at human length and time scales?
- whatshisface 6y agoYes, in string theory the extra dimensions are very small, leading to three macroscopic dimensions the same way the thinness of a piece of paper leads to two macroscopic dimensions.
- guscost 6y agoYou are still using “prediction” in a sense that I would say is not at all “risky”. Put another way, so far string theory is an elaborate kind of curve-fitting — a mathematical construction that matched the empirical data available at its inception, but one that to this day has never predicted a novel measurement. Unencumbered by the theory, we would not have expected any recent experiment to produce different results.
- whatshisface 6y ago
- kestonis 6y agoIt did. In book "Everything is Now" by Bill Spence writes that research in string theory led to developing new mathematics which led to helping to manage data in hadron collider which led to detecting Higgs boson. It is not direct cause and effect correlation but it helped with due process.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoYou can’t base the correctness of a theory on what the techniques it developed lead to. For example, astrology probably developed techniques of recording astronomical events and likely some mathematical techniques, but that does not mean that astrology is a correct theory.
- layer8 6y agoLoop quantum gravity seems like an important contender, although as you say it isn’t developed far enough yet to make any predictions.
- whatshisface 6y agoWe have several important contenders, but it is kind of funny that if you rank all contenders by relevance to empiricism, as is rightly demanded by Woit and Hossenfelder, string theory comes out in the lead.
- riknos314 6y agoOne could argue that this is somewhat due to selection bias, as string theory has been given the most research time/funding historically, thus it's had the longest time to mature. If the other contenders had the same research effort it's very possible that at least one might be found to actually be more relevant to empiricism.
- whatshisface 6y agoString theory exhibited quantum mechanics plus gravity since the day it was invented, it's not like LQG where setting up three macroscopic dimensions is a nearly insurmountably difficult problem. People think that the problem can be solved, otherwise nobody would bother with it, but string theory is obviously the first and best thing to try.