3 ms·
Option 4: spend some of their massive amounts of money to rebuild their R&D capabilities. Simultaneously give up their outdated idea that their core architectur
by amluto 6y ago
Option 4: spend some of their massive amounts of money to rebuild their R&D capabilities. Simultaneously give up their outdated idea that their core architecture is so valuable and secret that it must never be fabbed elsewhere. And spend the money to keep up with fab technology. And possibly put an actual engineer at the helm. Right now Intel seems to be going the way of Boeing — plenty of money, but less innovation than they ought to have.)
Keeping fab and design under one roof does not require that the fab and the design sides of the business exclusively with with each other.
(I think Intel should keep Altera, too. A paired CPU and FPGA solution has genuine value. One thing that Intel appears to still be good at is software tooling. If Intel were to provide tooling for their FPGAs that was anywhere near as good as their x86 tooling, then Altera could take off as everyone’s favorite platform. Right now they’re at substantial risk of losing new developer mindshare to Lattice because of the IceStorm project. I have trouble imagining that more than a few $M of total resources have been spent there.
As it stands, nVidia is a major player in big chips that do serious computation. Whatever one may think about CUDA, it’s in a whole different league from the garbage currently available from Xilinx and Altera.)
- discodave 6y agoIn 10 years, the biggest markets will likely be: 1. Mobile (I include cars, IoT etc) 2. Server/cloud (most new servers will be deployed to AWS, MS, Google, and maybe Alibaba) 3. Graphics / ML (you mentioned Nvidia and CUDA) How would your suggested option 4 help Intel gain a significant foothold in any of those markets? (or stop the Arm transition in the case of #2)
- ethbr0 6y agoCrazy idea: Why doesn't Intel launch their own cloud IaaS offering? Value proposition: Intel needs to scale manufacturing and R&D, in a way that doesn't leave them in a performance bind (ie without performance, they can't sell at scale, and thus can't afford to buy performance). Abstracting compute behind an IaaS offering would let them do exactly that while providing an alternate sink for binned chips. Furthermore, they've got decent HW/SW integration talent in-house, and they could offer a key feature other clouds couldn't: vendor agnosticism. Building {PaaS product} on an Intel cloud seems strategically smarter than building on one of the continually-vertically-integrating clouds.
- wmf 6y agoI think an IaaS-only cloud is a losing proposition. Customers want a variety of services at different levels on the same account. There may be room for innovation in federation/reselling higher-layer services but I'm not sure. Also, Intel-only would be limited compared to other clouds offering Intel/AMD/ARM. It's more likely that Intel will increase market development funding to the existing cloud providers as their market share declines.
- mcintyre1994 6y agoIs x86 likely to stay as the dominant cloud architecture though? My understanding of ARM on AWS is that if your stuff supports it then it’s better performance per dollar and basically a no brainer. I don’t see why x86 would continue to be the dominant deployment target long term, especially with Apple moving their line to ARM meaning that developers will increasingly demand compatibility with it across the stack.
- ethbr0 6y agoYou're ultimately buying ops-per-dollar. It seems like Intel could create a pretty compelling offering. Especially since AWS, Azure, and GCP all seem to be giving them the strategic middle finger.
- discodave 6y agoI like that idea, just for how crazy it is! My bear case for Intel Web Services would be: 1. As IBM, HP and others discovered, the expertise required to run cloud services is very different from what's required to sell servers (or CPUs). 2. To compete with Amazon and MS, you would need to spend several tens of billions of dollars just to get a similar infrastructure footprint. A variation on your proposal would be for Intel to buy a bunch of smaller cloud players, like DigitalOcean, and CloudFlare. Intel has the huge amounts of cash that these companies need to compete with AWS and Azure, Intel would then be vertically integrated, just like AWS is, and they would get the customer base and expertise from those acquisitions.
- ethbr0 6y ago